Saturday 3 September 2005

Mariah Carey sings the Prince songbook

Mariah Carey surely isn't any kind of critics favorite, but you can't deny her popularity with fans. As I write she's got the #1 and #2 singles on the Billboard Hot 100. Her omnipresence caused me to break down and actually give several close repeated listens to her smash The Emancipation of Mimi album. My perhaps somewhat harsh review drew forth a surprisingly strong response from Mariah's "lambs", some of whom are pretty vicious for gentle sheep.

Still, this resulted in a vigorous and partly useful discussion of the better and worse aspects of Ms Carey. Really, she does have a pretty impressive vocal instrument. Some fans make a big point of defending her also on the grounds that she writes her own songs, unlike some and such other pop singers.

But that's just the problem. She's surely got the instrument, and maybe she can sing, but it's hard telling because her songs just suck. Ray Charles himself could not have sold me on these Mimi songs. That's not really an indictment of Mariah Carey. Singing and songwriting are significantly different talents. Kris Kristofferson is one of the greatest songwriters of his generation, but he just cannot sing. He's writing absolute all time standards like "Me and Bobby McGee" and "Sunday Morning Coming Down", but still can't make a listenable album.

From the other side, pretty much everyone agrees that Ella Fitzgerald and Frank Sinatra were among the greatest singers in the history of recorded music. However, they weren't songwriters. If Sinatra had insisted on writing his own material instead of interpreting the works of master writers, he would probably have sucked.

Perhaps then it would behoove Mariah to recast herself at least for a minute as an interpreter of song. Put them fancy pipes to work on some real songs. In the spirit of Ella's famous songbook series, then, Mariah might do some good and even improve her critical rep not just covering, but interpreting the Prince catalogue, the greatest r&b song roster of the modern era (or ever).

She's probably not going to be comfortable or have a natural fit for some of his more sexually explicit or otherwise outre songs. I don't see her singing "Sexy MF". The freaky religious stuff is probably out of her emotional range and commercial comfort zone. The more rock oriented stuff probably wouldn't work for her, so no "Let's Go Crazy". Plus, there are a couple of his songs with seeming definitive covers. Unless she's got some whole different take on them, it probably wouldn't behoove her to do "Nothing Compares 2U" or "I Feel for You".

However, she could probably do some good with the fluttery melodrama of "Condition of the Heart" or "Sometimes It Snows in April". It's a great song which I've never heard covered at all. Drama queen that she is, what about taking a pass at "When Doves Cry"?

(Blogcritics.org)



COMMENTS
There are not yet comments to this article.

Only registrated members can post a comment.
© MCArchives 1998-2024 (26 years!)
NEWS
MESSAGEBOARD