Messageboard

The Last Living Diva (114,622) by Ma from Germany Hey lambs, have any of you come across the book "The Last Living Diva" by Matthew Stevens? He based it off of his experience as working as Mariah's assistant next to Lianna during the Stella era. In the book, the diva named Alexis Shane is basically Mariah down to the t and Matthew speaks of intense episodes of mania. He even talks about it in this interview. I have to say, even if some of this stuff is dramatized and fictionalized, only to imagine that Mariah might have gone through such dark times makes me so sad for her, she must have been truly so isolated as a human being, after everything she's been through in her life, and she's still surviving, still not able to trust, still controlled, still paranoid. And never really able to heal because nothing about your life is normal. Of course you would crack. If this book is in any way even remotely close to reality, it would also explain a lot about her current state. I just really, really hope she is finally surrounded by people who care about Mariah, the person. And I hope she knows that she is so loved by the lambily and that she saved us in our darkest moments. We see you in your music Mariah, we know who you are. Even when your whole supposed support system failed you, over and over. All my love to you, and whatever grace I can give so you find peace. (Friday 2 October 2026; 01:00)

In Your Feelings (114,621) by Stacey from USA I absolutely love the arrangements for IFIA, especially IYF. I just wish the vocals matched the arrangements. (Thursday 1 October 2026; 23:48) this is a reply to message 114,614

In Your Feelings (114,614) by Bobby A from United States I never thought about In Your Feelings having a jazz influence until I found out co-writer Alissia Benveniste is jazz infusion bassist. I have been listening to a lot of contemporary jazz this evening because of it. I believe a jazz collaboration with Michael League and his band, Snarky Puppy could lead to multiple Grammy nominations and wins. MC needs a unique collaboration in 2027. By the way, MC and The Clark Sisters could win a Dove Award for Jesus I Do on October 2nd. (Thursday 1 October 2026; 07:08)

Patient Zero (114,620) by Stacey from USA I don't get the hoopla over Taylor as well. All her songs sound the same to me. Compare her stuff against Mariah's own writing sessions tracks she has released recently. No comparison at all. (Thursday 1 October 2026; 23:47) this is a reply to message 114,615

Patient Zero (114,615) by TJ from Norway There's some kind of monkey business around Taylor's career. I think it is much easier to manipulate numbers and popularity these days than before. All her songs are the same, a big snore-fest if you ask me. (Thursday 1 October 2026; 11:58)

"Jesus I Do" scammy submission (114,619) by Bobby A from United States There is a chance JID could be nominated, but MC and Clark Sisters will go up against Tasha Cobbs Leonard, Kenny Lewis and One Voice and Pastor Mike. These three gospel artists had the three biggest gospel songs from September 2025 - August 2026 in terms of radio airplay. Gamma dropped the ball with JID not being officially serviced to gospel and urban ac radio stations. Hopefully, Larry Jackson will promote and service MC's singles for MC17 the proper way. I feel a Memoirs/Butterfly fusion is on the way in 2027. (Thursday 1 October 2026; 21:58) this is a reply to message 114,616

"Jesus I Do" scammy submission (114,616) by Chicago Lamb from USA Who thinks "Jesus I do" has a chance for Grammy nomination and win? Submission window closed August 21st but we won't know until November 16th when the nominations are announced. (Thursday 1 October 2026; 13:49)

Patient Zero (114,618) by Matty from Vancouver Canada Let's hope so. There's never been a more celebrated talent. I'll give her flowers for her song writing/story telling, but the singing and dancing leaves much to be desired. Also, I know Mariah does this to some extent and the constant re-releases of the same album over and over to get a couple new songs that sound exactly the same is exhausting and I live in a strict no-Swift household, and I'm still exhausted and bored by it all. (Thursday 1 October 2026; 21:42) this is a reply to message 114,615

Patient Zero (114,615) by TJ from Norway There's some kind of monkey business around Taylor's career. I think it is much easier to manipulate numbers and popularity these days than before. All her songs are the same, a big snore-fest if you ask me. (Thursday 1 October 2026; 11:58)

MC Christmas (114,617) by pipupass from China I agree with you. Just look at Mariah Carey's makeup artist - his taste has gotten much worse, but she still won't replace him. (Thursday 1 October 2026; 17:18) this is a reply to message 114,596

MC Christmas (114,596) by nancy from Switzerland What I saw on her Facebook page, that there is critique of her not singing live, lethargy etc. When someone writes the truth on her side, her management immediately puts another post to overshadow the truth. They not even accept constructive critique. It's too expensive for a non live show. Not even the playback is done correctly anymore because she is so distracted. There are so many videos on YouTube that prove everything. She doesn't move. The only fast move she does is after the shows when she goes to the Dior, LV store in Aspen to spend the money that her fans earned hardly hoping to get an outstanding experience. And you get absolutely nothing. At least her background singers are professional and motivated. (Friday 25 September 2026; 22:14)

"Jesus I Do" scammy submission (114,616) by Chicago Lamb from USA Who thinks "Jesus I do" has a chance for Grammy nomination and win? Submission window closed August 21st but we won't know until November 16th when the nominations are announced. (Thursday 1 October 2026; 13:49)

Patient Zero (114,615) by TJ from Norway There's some kind of monkey business around Taylor's career. I think it is much easier to manipulate numbers and popularity these days than before. All her songs are the same, a big snore-fest if you ask me. (Thursday 1 October 2026; 11:58) this is a reply to message 114,605

Patient Zero (114,605) by Edward from USA Taylor's "Patient Zero" is expected to debut at #1 on the Hot 100 next week, knocking "Choosin' Texas" out of the top spot. That means "AIWFCIY" would only need to spend two weeks at #1 this holiday season to reclaim the record. Taylor would move to 16 #1s, putting her just three away from tying Mariah. Four more and she ties the Beatles, and five more would give her the all-time record. With Taylor's popularity at its peak, that's probably where this is headed. So I think it's best that we all hold hands, gather around the campfire, and mourn the 19 #1's record now. That way, when it actually happens, maybe it won't hurt quite as much. The one record I'm not so sure Taylor can touch, though, is most cumulative weeks at #1. Mariah is at 101 weeks, while Rihanna is the closest at 60, and Taylor is currently at 49. That's still a pretty big gap. And just like that, the charts are getting somewhat interesting again. (Tuesday 29 September 2026; 03:30)

In Your Feelings (114,614) by Bobby A from United States I never thought about In Your Feelings having a jazz influence until I found out co-writer Alissia Benveniste is jazz infusion bassist. I have been listening to a lot of contemporary jazz this evening because of it. I believe a jazz collaboration with Michael League and his band, Snarky Puppy could lead to multiple Grammy nominations and wins. MC needs a unique collaboration in 2027. By the way, MC and The Clark Sisters could win a Dove Award for Jesus I Do on October 2nd. (Thursday 1 October 2026; 07:08)

Fantasy track list (114,613) by MusicfanJ from Germany What a wonderful tracklist. I love all the classics. Timeless music with heart and soul. Mariah and "Summertime" would be very interesting. It's one of the best songs ever and hard to cover. But Mariah and covers are a "dream team". Lately I've been listening a lot to The Verve's "Bittersweet Symphony". What a classic from the late 90ies. It's still so good and always will be. (Wednesday 30 September 2026; 19:44) this is a reply to message 114,610

Fantasy track list (114,610) by Rose from United States I know inspiration doesn't always flow all the time for artists but I would be happy with an album of covers. A concept album of really good songs from the past that fit her current voice. She always makes the songs she covers her own and puts so much emotion into them. I'd like to hear more in her lower range too. For this, I wouldn't even want huge publicity around it. It could be an album (or albums) she releases quietly. I know I'm greedy in regards of Mariah but I can't help it. She's already given us so much, but I want more. I really liked My Prayer and think she could travel down that vein more. My track list: Unforgettable - Nat King Cole It's Magic - Dinah Washington Stardust - Nat King Cole I Only Have Eyes for You - The Flamingos Just My Imagination - The Temptations Summertime - Ella Fitzgerald Life Is but a Dream - Dion Since I Don't Have You - The Skyliners Smoke Gets in Your Eyes - The Platters Unchained Melody - The Righteous Brothers The Impossible Dream - Roberta Flack Bonus: not like the others, but I love them: The Sound of Silence - Simon & Garfunkel Bittersweet Symphony - The Verve Lover, You Should've Come Over - Jeff Buckley (Wednesday 30 September 2026; 02:35)

Patient Zero (114,612) by Lainsky from Philippines Well, this is good news, and it would be even better if it happened. This is funny, Edward: "We all hold hands, gather around the campfire, and mourn the 19 #1s record now." However, you got a point there. I also hope that this could be Taylor's verge of a downturn in popularity because of the aforementioned criticism in that paper. I mean, come on. Most artists tend to experience a decline in popularity after about 20 years in their careers. (Wednesday 30 September 2026; 12:37) this is a reply to message 114,605

Patient Zero (114,605) by Edward from USA Taylor's "Patient Zero" is expected to debut at #1 on the Hot 100 next week, knocking "Choosin' Texas" out of the top spot. That means "AIWFCIY" would only need to spend two weeks at #1 this holiday season to reclaim the record. Taylor would move to 16 #1s, putting her just three away from tying Mariah. Four more and she ties the Beatles, and five more would give her the all-time record. With Taylor's popularity at its peak, that's probably where this is headed. So I think it's best that we all hold hands, gather around the campfire, and mourn the 19 #1's record now. That way, when it actually happens, maybe it won't hurt quite as much. The one record I'm not so sure Taylor can touch, though, is most cumulative weeks at #1. Mariah is at 101 weeks, while Rihanna is the closest at 60, and Taylor is currently at 49. That's still a pretty big gap. And just like that, the charts are getting somewhat interesting again. (Tuesday 29 September 2026; 03:30)

Patient Zero (114,611) by Zachariah from Croatia That still brings me so much anger when I think about it. (Wednesday 30 September 2026; 07:49) this is a reply to message 114,609

Patient Zero (114,609) by Bill from the UK If only Migrate had been a single we'd be an extra #1 ahead... (Tuesday 29 September 2026; 23:13)

Fantasy track list (114,610) by Rose from United States I know inspiration doesn't always flow all the time for artists but I would be happy with an album of covers. A concept album of really good songs from the past that fit her current voice. She always makes the songs she covers her own and puts so much emotion into them. I'd like to hear more in her lower range too. For this, I wouldn't even want huge publicity around it. It could be an album (or albums) she releases quietly. I know I'm greedy in regards of Mariah but I can't help it. She's already given us so much, but I want more. I really liked My Prayer and think she could travel down that vein more. My track list: Unforgettable - Nat King Cole It's Magic - Dinah Washington Stardust - Nat King Cole I Only Have Eyes for You - The Flamingos Just My Imagination - The Temptations Summertime - Ella Fitzgerald Life Is but a Dream - Dion Since I Don't Have You - The Skyliners Smoke Gets in Your Eyes - The Platters Unchained Melody - The Righteous Brothers The Impossible Dream - Roberta Flack Bonus: not like the others, but I love them: The Sound of Silence - Simon & Garfunkel Bittersweet Symphony - The Verve Lover, You Should've Come Over - Jeff Buckley (Wednesday 30 September 2026; 02:35)

Patient Zero (114,609) by Bill from the UK If only Migrate had been a single we'd be an extra #1 ahead... (Tuesday 29 September 2026; 23:13) this is a reply to message 114,605

Patient Zero (114,605) by Edward from USA Taylor's "Patient Zero" is expected to debut at #1 on the Hot 100 next week, knocking "Choosin' Texas" out of the top spot. That means "AIWFCIY" would only need to spend two weeks at #1 this holiday season to reclaim the record. Taylor would move to 16 #1s, putting her just three away from tying Mariah. Four more and she ties the Beatles, and five more would give her the all-time record. With Taylor's popularity at its peak, that's probably where this is headed. So I think it's best that we all hold hands, gather around the campfire, and mourn the 19 #1's record now. That way, when it actually happens, maybe it won't hurt quite as much. The one record I'm not so sure Taylor can touch, though, is most cumulative weeks at #1. Mariah is at 101 weeks, while Rihanna is the closest at 60, and Taylor is currently at 49. That's still a pretty big gap. And just like that, the charts are getting somewhat interesting again. (Tuesday 29 September 2026; 03:30)

Patient Zero (114,608) by BFF from US It's interesting that you mention Taylor because there was a pretty harsh criticism of her most recent material in The Atlantic today. She might be on the verge of downturn in popularity. (Tuesday 29 September 2026; 20:27) this is a reply to message 114,605

Patient Zero (114,605) by Edward from USA Taylor's "Patient Zero" is expected to debut at #1 on the Hot 100 next week, knocking "Choosin' Texas" out of the top spot. That means "AIWFCIY" would only need to spend two weeks at #1 this holiday season to reclaim the record. Taylor would move to 16 #1s, putting her just three away from tying Mariah. Four more and she ties the Beatles, and five more would give her the all-time record. With Taylor's popularity at its peak, that's probably where this is headed. So I think it's best that we all hold hands, gather around the campfire, and mourn the 19 #1's record now. That way, when it actually happens, maybe it won't hurt quite as much. The one record I'm not so sure Taylor can touch, though, is most cumulative weeks at #1. Mariah is at 101 weeks, while Rihanna is the closest at 60, and Taylor is currently at 49. That's still a pretty big gap. And just like that, the charts are getting somewhat interesting again. (Tuesday 29 September 2026; 03:30)

23 Weeks (114,607) by Rose from United States I’ve never even heard "Old Town Road" or "Choosin' Texas". Not even once. Who is buying these records? (Tuesday 29 September 2026; 08:53) this is a reply to message 114,593

23 Weeks (114,593) by Edward from USA Remember when debuting at #1 on the Hot 100 actually felt like a huge accomplishment? Now Ariana has done it eight times. "One Sweet Day" held the record for 23 years, 4 months and 13 days. It took Mariah 6 years and 5 months to reclaim it, and now, just 8 months and 19 days later, it's broken again. I don't know if you see the trend here. I wouldn't have minded if "Despacito", a worldwide phenomenon, or "A Bar Song (Tipsy)", which was absolutely everywhere in the US, had taken the record. But "Old Town Road" and "Choosin' Texas"? Nah. Sorry. I've always followed the charts, but this is getting so frustrating that I'm probably going to stop paying so much attention. At this point, some of it just doesn't make sense to me anymore. (Friday 25 September 2026; 15:13)

Glitter (114,606) by Rose from United States I was hoping for a theater re-release and to be able to buy it on digital again. But with publicity around it. (Tuesday 29 September 2026; 04:49)

Patient Zero (114,605) by Edward from USA Taylor's "Patient Zero" is expected to debut at #1 on the Hot 100 next week, knocking "Choosin' Texas" out of the top spot. That means "AIWFCIY" would only need to spend two weeks at #1 this holiday season to reclaim the record. Taylor would move to 16 #1s, putting her just three away from tying Mariah. Four more and she ties the Beatles, and five more would give her the all-time record. With Taylor's popularity at its peak, that's probably where this is headed. So I think it's best that we all hold hands, gather around the campfire, and mourn the 19 #1's record now. That way, when it actually happens, maybe it won't hurt quite as much. The one record I'm not so sure Taylor can touch, though, is most cumulative weeks at #1. Mariah is at 101 weeks, while Rihanna is the closest at 60, and Taylor is currently at 49. That's still a pretty big gap. And just like that, the charts are getting somewhat interesting again. (Tuesday 29 September 2026; 03:30)

23 Weeks (114,604) by BFF from US The ascent of streaming and changes around how it is factored into chart determinations really changed the meaning of achieving a number one record. The ways that music is consumed have changed a lot since "One Sweet Day" set that record in the mid-1990s, but OSD certainly held that record for a very long time. And it achieved the record by being both a radio airplay hit and a success as a commercially released CD single. Some of these changes have been for the better and some for the worse. I personally like streaming because it is more portable/minimalist and doesn't create so much waste in terms of physical materials, though I'm sure the data centers are using up a lot of energy. (Monday 28 September 2026; 11:46) this is a reply to message 114,593

23 Weeks (114,593) by Edward from USA Remember when debuting at #1 on the Hot 100 actually felt like a huge accomplishment? Now Ariana has done it eight times. "One Sweet Day" held the record for 23 years, 4 months and 13 days. It took Mariah 6 years and 5 months to reclaim it, and now, just 8 months and 19 days later, it's broken again. I don't know if you see the trend here. I wouldn't have minded if "Despacito", a worldwide phenomenon, or "A Bar Song (Tipsy)", which was absolutely everywhere in the US, had taken the record. But "Old Town Road" and "Choosin' Texas"? Nah. Sorry. I've always followed the charts, but this is getting so frustrating that I'm probably going to stop paying so much attention. At this point, some of it just doesn't make sense to me anymore. (Friday 25 September 2026; 15:13)

23 Weeks (114,603) by Stacey from USA Well said. I echo your sentiments. I'm glad I've got so much music to enjoy for years to come. (Monday 28 September 2026; 04:50) this is a reply to message 114,595

23 Weeks (114,595) by Terna from Nigeria Lol, why get worked up? Remember Mariah's AIWFCIY will definitely snatch back that title this very Christmas - a gift that will keep giving long after she's gone (that in itself is such a flex). At this point now I'm over all that chart watching, placement etc. I just enjoy the music and the fact Mariah is still here and still making music just for the love of it, after what that demonic industry has put her through. Just enjoy her accomplishments and vast, satisfying body of work. PS: Just think of it, by the time Mariah accumulates 50+ weeks at #1 with "All I want for Christmas is you", nobody will be able to match, talk less of breaking that record because let's face it, no song is staying at number for a whole year, it's just not happening. Haha. This woman is so blessed. They try so hard to erase her, but she keeps coming back and proving them wrong and we love to see it. (Friday 25 September 2026; 19:38)

So 1997 (114,602) by Jamie from UK Maybe she's waiting for the 40 year anniversary for the debut or there's some technicality's currently that is preventing her from releasing the demo tape and unheard songs. Who knows? I think it will come at some point, we just have to be patient. But Mariah hasn't already given us more in the past 12 months than other legacy artists and there's more to come in October with Glitter so I'm not complaining. (Sunday 27 September 2026; 13:54) this is a reply to message 114,601

So 1997 (114,601) by TJ from Norway I forgot the 25 years release. What happened to her debut album and the vault? I'm confused. (Sunday 27 September 2026; 08:39)

So 1997 (114,601) by TJ from Norway I forgot the 25 years release. What happened to her debut album and the vault? I'm confused. (Sunday 27 September 2026; 08:39) this is a reply to message 114,598

So 1997 (114,598) by Jamie from UK I don't think we will get an MC30 for Butterfly as we got a 25th anniversary edition so I don't think the need is there. She definitely needs to do something with the debut and Emotions albums though, I need me some more new unheard songs from that era. (Saturday 26 September 2026; 13:27)

So 1997 (114,600) by nancy from Switzerland I don't think we need another Butterfly reedition because there was her super expensive 25th collectors vinyl edition. I don't have it because I don't want to support that anymore. The package with all pictures etc looks great of course. And you'll notice that it has really the Mariah glamour in it. In order to make more money only a vinyl edition was produced. NO CD edition of course. The same thing for The Emancipation of Mimi and Glitter too. I do not support that anymore. Also the merch of her former era is leaving me disenchanted. The only thing I'll consider to buy is her new stuff. Here for it all of course. (Saturday 26 September 2026; 17:28)

Mariah Christmas in the UK (114,599) by Jamie from UK I'm the same. I made the decision a couple of years ago not to see her live again, which also makes me sad. My family can't believe it but the reason I used to want to go and watch her has gone. I still love her and always will but her performances now are not the Mariah I love. For those that go I hope you have a great time but it's a no from me. (Saturday 26 September 2026; 13:32) this is a reply to message 114,592

Mariah Christmas in the UK (114,592) by Lee from UK I was so close to buying tickets for me and my partner to the Manchester show but I hovered over the "Get These Tickets" button for too long. My sensible brain kicked in and said "Are you really going to spend all of this money to watch Mariah give nothing on stage and lipsync like a mime to pre-recorded vocals?" I then closed my browser and went back to work. I feel sad about it but after paying to see her in Sandringham and feeling disappointed, I do not want to be duped again. (Friday 25 September 2026; 09:52)

So 1997 (114,598) by Jamie from UK I don't think we will get an MC30 for Butterfly as we got a 25th anniversary edition so I don't think the need is there. She definitely needs to do something with the debut and Emotions albums though, I need me some more new unheard songs from that era. (Saturday 26 September 2026; 13:27) this is a reply to message 114,597

So 1997 (114,597) by TJ from Norway I like to believe that 1997 was yesterday and that Butterfly still has some singles on the top 100's. And then I looked at the calendar. I just realised that we might be very lucky next year if she keeps up the tradition with her 30th anniversary albums. She has expressed her love for that album so many times, that I really do believe she can do some magic with such a release. What do you think? (Friday 25 September 2026; 23:08)

MORE MESSAGES