Messageboard

About Bobby A from United States: I have been a Lamb since 1990. I know Mariah. I love her music. I breathe her music.

MTV Unplugged and Glitter significance (113,094) by Bobby A from United States I watched the MTV Unplugged concert yesterday after thinking about one of MC's most famous phrases. MC said, "You know I am not used to doing this." MC finally received a breakthrough moment when she realized that she could connect with her audience. And yes, she did connect with her audience in such a huge way after all of her nervousness, hesitation, and lack of performance experience. MTV Unplugged proved all of her critics wrong that she was just a manufactured studio artist. I believe after the MTV Unplugged concert, MC began to really overwork herself to the point it caught up with her during the Glitter era. Has anyone else thought about the significance of the MTV Unplugged concert and the Glitter era? (Tuesday 27 January 2026; 09:22)

Possible The Rarities II songs (113,093) by Bobby A from United States Lol. TJ, save some songs for the Rarities III and IV. I am predicting 13-15 songs and possibly one new song. I suspect MC's focus will be primarily the following eras: 1. The demo tape 2. Debut 3. Daydream 4. Glitter 5. Charmbracelet 6. TEOM 7. Memoirs 8. Somebody's Ugly Daughter - separate packaging 9. TV live performances (Tuesday 27 January 2026; 02:01) this is a reply to message 113,091

Possible The Rarities II songs (113,091) by TJ from Norway Are we sure that she is releasing Rarities part 2 this year? I hope for more than two discs. It should be at least four. Yes I'm greedy. One disc with all those songs that have other versions than the album cuts (like for example All in Your Mind), one with SUD, one with different live songs that haven't been on CD before (If It's Over - SNL, the duet with Bolton and so on) and one with the Paris Charmbracelet concert (with the band introductions). I'm sure I could make a fifth disc as well, but that's Mariah's job. Oh dear, I forgot her demo tape. I need five to six discs. (Monday 26 January 2026; 20:58)

Possible The Rarities II songs (113,090) by Bobby A from United States I forgot about We're Not Making Love Anymore. It will be very interesting to see which songs end up on The Rarities II. I am predicting a October or November release this year if MC releases The Rarities II and Somebody's Ugly Daughter. Sony Legacy has to package and market them both in such a way to maximize physical sales. (Monday 26 January 2026; 16:09) this is a reply to message 113,085

Possible The Rarities II songs (113,085) by Lainsky from Philippines How about "We're Not Making Love Anymore" with Michael Bolton, Bobby A? I believe it is a nice duet she had, aside from the remake of "Endless Love". (Monday 26 January 2026; 08:05)

I won't allow it (113,083) by Bobby A from United States You can hear Anderson .Paak and Bongo By The Way having fun with MC after she sings, "You should have been more proactive." IWA should get a Nile Rogers remix treatment with Daft Punk and Brent Faiyaz features as the final single this summer. (Sunday 25 January 2026; 08:59) this is a reply to message 113,079

I won't allow it (113,079) by Giovanni from USA I love the production on "I won't allow it" and the song shows what a sense of humor Mariah has haha. Thought it was about Brian but it's actually about Nick. I would love to have heard 2009 Mariah sing this song. HFIA reminds me so much of MOAIA. (Sunday 25 January 2026; 07:03)

Possible The Rarities II songs (113,081) by Bobby A from United States I thought I would look in my Mariah book to see what MC could possibly release as the The Rarities II tracklist. 1. Weakness of the Body 2. Lose Control 3. Reach For The Sky 4. Help Me Make It Through The Night 5. Right To Dream 6. Where Are You Christmas? 7. When I Feel It 8. Secret Love 9. Sprung 10. Imperfect 11. Skydiving 12. You and I - BET performance/Stevie Wonder Tribute 13. Last Night A DJ Saved My Life - VH1 performance 14. 2015 Diane Warren collaboration 15. 100% 16. Bring It On Home 17. With You I'm Born Again - duet with John Legend - VH1 performance 18. Thirsty ft. Rich Homie Quan 19. Goin Up Yonder - Richard Smallwood cover 20. Jesus I Do - Acapella 21. The Demo Tape 22. All My Life - Acapella 23. My Saving Grace - BET performance 24. Betcha Gon Know - Acapella 25. Metorite - QTip's original version 26. Looking In - MLB All-Star Charity event performance 27. Vision of Love - Grammy performance 28. Yours ft. Justin Timberlake (Sunday 25 January 2026; 08:46)

2026 Mariah (113,072) by Bobby A from United States Thank you, MusicJFan. I am better today. Snowarmgeddon is coming and I may get a couple of no school snow days. (Friday 23 January 2026; 02:24) this is a reply to message 113,070

2026 Mariah (113,070) by MusicfanJ from Germany "She was left with no choice, but to write songs that would heal her broken spirit inside." Yes, her songs from the start often shows it. They are very special, I just love the early lyrics. The same with "Make it happen". I'm sorry to hear you've got troubles with your co-worker today. I work in an office for administration, mobbing has happened sometimes by co-workers too. It can really poison the atmosphere and costs energy. The best thing is to ignore those idiots and false snakes or talk with the boss maybe. Sometimes it helps, sometimes not. But anyway don't let them "take away" your friendly spirit. Listen to the one and only Mariah and enjoy her music. She's really the best to cheer the mood up. (Thursday 22 January 2026; 12:39)

2026 Mariah (113,067) by Bobby A from United States I guess a song like TGTBW helped MC heal from her traumatic childhood. I can imagine 20-year old Mariah had no one to turn to for support once she signed her contract with the corporate morgue. I am sure she couldn't talk to anyone at the label about her traumatic childhood. MC had to put that all behind her and focus on getting her career started. She was left with no choice, but to write songs that would heal her broken spirit inside. I think MC successfully healed her spirit, but she still deals with side effects of everything mountain and valley that she has had to overcome. My spirit was crushed today by a co-worker, but still I rise above her actions. I understand completely now MC why you must write your beautiful and inspirational songs. (Thursday 22 January 2026; 00:31) this is a reply to message 113,058

2026 Mariah (113,058) by MusicfanJ from Germany Good question. I wonder too. And I miss lyrics like "There's got to be away". I can still relate to it. And it's still up-to date and maybe always will. More than with luxury bags LV, shoes or a private plane. (Wednesday 21 January 2026; 14:38)

The JD bounce (113,050) by Bobby A from United States It would be smart of MC to plan a JD ballad as the lead single for the deluxe edition of HFIA instead of a new remix version of one of the album tracks. IYF making it to the top of the R&B chart shows that people have missed hearing a Mariah Carey ballad on the radio. Releasing a JD ballad with that famous JD bounce could propel MC back to the top 10 or higher on the Hot 100 during the second quarter. I feel something big is on the way this March. (Tuesday 20 January 2026; 00:54)

In Your Feelings (113,046) by Bobby A from United States In Your Feelings is doing extremely well on on R&B charts. I think Gamma chose not to announce it as the official 4th single for a reason to guarantee the success on R&B radio that is currently having. It had worked for sure. I guess that would explain the reason for no video. What is next for IYF? Hopefully, a remix is on the way. (Sunday 18 January 2026; 01:10)

Trilogies and sister songs (113,043) by Bobby A from United States Here are the new Jack Swing sample sisters: Crybaby, Thank God I Found You (Make It Last Remix), The One (So So Def Remix), Makin It Last All Night (What it Do) and The Impossible (Saturday 17 January 2026; 17:31) this is a reply to message 113,040

Trilogies and sister songs (113,040) by Lighty from China Relationship sisters: Dreamlover, (AIWFCIY), Fantasy, Honey, Sweetheart, Heartbreaker, Loverboy, Boy. (Saturday 17 January 2026; 11:28)

One era to relive again (113,034) by Bobby A from United States TEOM/2005 is one era that I wish could relive again. MC came back hard after the industry had basically written her off. I started calling MC "my girl" during this era. It was a great time for the Lambily and the new Lambs. Some of JD's, Bryan Michael Cox's, and Johnta Austin's best songs are on TEOM. (Friday 16 January 2026; 07:29)

Reddit thread - save one MC song from each album (113,033) by Bobby A from United States Great list. The sequencing actually flows very well. (Friday 16 January 2026; 07:19) this is a reply to message 113,027

Reddit thread - save one MC song from each album (113,027) by Haiji from United States MC - Alone In Love Emotions - Can't Let Go Unplugged - If It's Over (Live) MB - Never Forget You Merry Christmas - Miss You Most Daydream - I Am Free Butterfly - Outside Rainbow - Crybaby #1's - When You Believe Greatest Hits - Endless Love Glitter - Lead The Way Charmbracelet - Subtle Invitation The Remixes - My All/Stay Awhile TEOM - Fly Like A Bird E=MC² - Migrate MOAIA - H.A.T.E.U MCIIY - When Christmas Comes MIAM - Faded #1 to Infinity - Love Takes Time Caution - 8th Grade The Rarities - Slipping Away HFIA - In Your Feelings (Thursday 15 January 2026; 22:42)

Trilogies and sister songs (113,031) by Bobby A from United States What about Miss You being a precursor song to WBT and Don't Forget About Us? All three songs are definitely about Derek Jeter. (Friday 16 January 2026; 05:12) this is a reply to message 113,026

Trilogies and sister songs (113,026) by Haiji from United States If you think about it, Can't Let Go would be the original WBT. The song structure, writing format, even the how she sings the verses, builds up to the climax. I'm not speaking about the style of singing since she sings a bit faster on WBT. And I know she pretty much does the whole build-up to climax on almost every song. I hope I'm making sense lol. So for me, the sister songs would be CLG, Everything Fades Away, Melt Away, Whenever You Call, Crybaby, Never Too Far, Yours, We Belong Together, DFAU, I Stay In Love, For The Record, H.A.T.E.U., Angels Cry and Faded. I'd throw 8th Grade and IYF in there but they're slightly different to me, since there's a beat change at the end. I do agree with the trilogy being WBT/DFAU/ISIL. (Thursday 15 January 2026; 21:41)

Timing is everything (113,009) by Bobby A from United States I was thinking the same thing. HFIA should have been released in October with IYF as the lead single on the same day to benefit from MC's holiday airplay and Christmas concerts. The whole vibe of HFIA is not very summery, but it exudes a walk in the city or sitting by the fireplace at home listening experience. By the way, Jesus I Do received two NAACP Image Award nominations. We can vote on the NAACP Image Awards website until February 7th. The awards ceremony takes place on BET on February 28th. (Wednesday 14 January 2026; 12:24) this is a reply to message 113,006

Timing is everything (113,006) by Lara from Middle East HIFA has so much potential but I think its timing was off and kinda rushed. I guess they wanted it out before TS takes over. Type Dangerous video seems rushed out, remember it was delayed because of editing? Sugar Sweet video never saw the light. Knowing that if she sang it with Kehlani alone it might've had more chance to get it done (easier to get together 2 people than 3), and she could've benefited from Kehlani recent success from her Folded single. If she had released it a bit before Christmas, get those 2 singles ready by release, and released Play This Song like last week just before Bruno Mars released his music, she also would've also benefited from the extra exposure Anderson .Paak got. I definitely feel she was rushed to it. Look at Bruno Mars, he posted one day before his album announcement and the day after released the single with the video ready. I'm no expert but I don't think that video costed more than TD, but it looks way more polished and constructed. He waited 10 years to release but released in control. It doesn't look like that for Mariah anymore sadly, maybe her condition doesn't allow it to control like she wants to. (Wednesday 14 January 2026; 07:42)

Deluxe coming? (112,987) by Bobby A from United States Shezz just asked me to chime in because he knows I am the prediction queen and that has always been my area of expertise on the board. Lol. We all value your comments on the board. What have you heard in New York? Give us some tea. (Tuesday 13 January 2026; 02:17) this is a reply to message 112,983

Deluxe coming? (112,983) by Edward from USA I want to chime in, but since you specifically called on Bobby A and I'm answering instead, am I about to get the Céline treatment on the Chapter MCArchives message board of your memoirs? I just want to be prepared. (Monday 12 January 2026; 17:12)

Deluxe coming? (112,986) by Bobby A from United States Shezz, I believe the HFIA deluxe is coming soon because MC likes for people on her team to tease or comment about her upcoming albums. Didn't Kristofer Buckle tease about Caution on his Instagram page when it was about to drop? February would be perfect for MC to drop a IYF remix or a new song with Sza to promote the deluxe. I feel big things are on the way next month. (Tuesday 13 January 2026; 01:09) this is a reply to message 112,981

Deluxe coming? (112,981) by Shezz from Pk Apparently Mariah's photographer Dennis Leupold teased HFIA deluxe and then deleted it. I somehow can't link the screen grabs here but it's on X and Instagram. He posted some pics of her in a pink dress that were in the album sleeve I think, looked very familiar. Here's hoping we get a few new songs or good high profile remixes so it gets a good boost that it deserves. And Paul McCartney on My Love. Robert Anthony? (Monday 12 January 2026; 15:24)

Deep cuts album (112,979) by Bobby A from United States Someone on TikTok commented on an user's video about Faded being a deep cut. That's true. However, the commenter said the whole MIAM album has "damn near deep cuts" on the album. Do you agree? What other MC album would be considered a deep cuts album? Emotions? Caution? (Sunday 11 January 2026; 18:42)

Anderson .Paak influence (112,977) by Bobby A from United States It's amazing how Anderson .Paak's melodies and vocal harmonies are so recognizable in IYF and the new Bruno Mars' song I Just Might. Although Anderson .Paak did not write IJM, you can tell Bruno Mars was influenced by the one album he made with him. (Saturday 10 January 2026; 22:39)

In Your Feelings feat. Bruno Mars (112,975) by Bobby A from United States Bruno's new song, I Just Might, is so good. He reminds me of the male MC for his vocal skills, songwriting ability, and his business savvy. I love February album releases. We need a MC and Bruno collaboration this year. It is long overdue. (Saturday 10 January 2026; 15:40) this is a reply to message 112,967

In Your Feelings feat. Bruno Mars (112,967) by Lainsky from Philippines Since her recent performance of this song is gaining airplay, I hope she officially releases it as a single. I saw someone mention that it might seem desperate if it's recorded with Bruno Mars. That could be the case, or it might not. He has a new single out now that sounds like it's going to be a hit. I believe that their vocal ranges and qualities blend well together, and it could work out. If this collaboration leads to a hit for both of them, why not, right? I just think there's an opportunity for Mariah and her team to seize at this moment. Additionally, with this version, they could release a deluxe edition of HFIA on her anniversary, featuring a couple of new songs and remixes. Just a thought that I chose to say here. (Saturday 10 January 2026; 02:28)

Rarities 2 (112,974) by Bobby A from United States It would be a great business decision to combine The Rarities 2 with Somebody's Ugly's Daughter. Maybe a double vinyl release would drive sales even more. Does MC only have left about 10 previously unreleased tracks from 1990-2014? Also, she could include some of her best live tv performances from award and late night talk shows. 2026 is going to be interesting to see what she releases. (Saturday 10 January 2026; 15:33) this is a reply to message 112,973

Rarities 2 (112,973) by MusicfanJ from Germany That would be wonderful. I so need another Rarities by Mariah. (Saturday 10 January 2026; 10:43)

In Your Feelings (112,964) by Bobby A from United States IYF is gaining radio airplay this week on AC stations because of MC's [New Year's Eve] performance. (Friday 9 January 2026; 08:43) this is a reply to message 112,961

In your feelings (112,961) by Xavier mariohmix from Spain I don't know, but I can't get this song out of my head. It's catchy, it's got a wonderful vibe, it sounds classic, but different at the same time. And the speedy and tongue-twister phrase "I think you might be getting a little bit toooooo..." is so iconic. I'm singing it all day long. (Thursday 8 January 2026; 23:05)

Confetti & Champagne (112,962) by Bobby A from United States Is it OOC's sister? (Thursday 8 January 2026; 23:46) this is a reply to message 112,956

Confetti & Champagne (112,956) by Terna from Nigeria It's my favorite from the [new album], and the most standout "Mariahesque" track on the whole album in my opinion. It's got a distinct summery vibe for chilling and hanging out and yes it should be a single, complete with a video treatment. (Thursday 8 January 2026; 12:09)

In Your Feelings and "stuff" (112,946) by Bobby A from United States Who is the model in the My All video? I thought AI gave me the wrong name. AI always thinks that Honey is MC's best video when I conduct my searches. (Tuesday 6 January 2026; 13:36) this is a reply to message 112,944

In Your Feelings and "stuff" (112,944) by Lighty from China David Fumero was in the Honey video, not My All. (Tuesday 6 January 2026; 11:44)

In Your Feelings and "stuff" (112,943) by Bobby A from United States The surprise hit that should have launched HFIA. With a video treatment like WBT featuring David Fumero (My All), IYF would have been that perfect summer love song. (Tuesday 6 January 2026; 05:59) this is a reply to message 112,930

In Your Feelings and "stuff" (112,930) by Haiji from United States This might actually make more sense. I wasn't thinking the 4 letter F word lol I was thinking the S word. I'm hoping there isn't another version of IYF using explicit words, it'll take away from the song imo. I'm praying for a video and single treatment soon for this song. (Monday 5 January 2026; 15:25)

Great news (112,940) by Bobby A from United States I think you might be getting little bit too in your feelings. (Tuesday 6 January 2026; 05:12) this is a reply to message 112,936

Great news (112,936) by Edward from USA I sense a subliminal message on your post. (Tuesday 6 January 2026; 02:36)

MORE MESSAGES