Messageboard | The Mariah Carey Archives

Only registrated members can post messages. Registration is free.

About Randy from USA: MC is my favorite artist of all time and I love her songwriting skills on her introspective songs. My favorite album: Butterfly. My favorite song: Right To Dream.

I am bipolar about Walter A (108,666) by Randy from USA

So here's my two cents. A lot of you are excited that she could work with him again. Even I raised my eyebrows when I found out he was producing the Streisand song. I swear he's the dude that was among the attendees at that table where Tommy put that knife to her throat and he said nothing. Turned his eyes and went home to sleep. And that's their break. That's my theory. Anyway my favorite album is Butterfly. My favorite songs on the album are Butterfly, My All and Close My Eyes. They are his productions. So yeah they made magic together. But if you get into her catalogue deeply, Jimmy Jam and Terry Lewis were his replacements and they did an amazing job with Petals, Against All Odds. Through The Rain is one of my favorites. Let's not talk about Big Jim Wright and Languishing. So did MC really need Walter A for great ballads/introspective songs? Could it be what she's been saying all along, all she needs is a good piano player because she can play but she's terrible? If I hear her say that again, by the way, I'm gonna stab myself in the tongue with a fork. So what do we need Walter A for and what are we excited about again?
(Saturday 3 May 2025; 20:34)

National Poetry Month (108,630) by Randy from USA

You know now that the month is coming to an end. And MC being delayed in the [Rock and Roll Hall of Fame], I just realized she has never done a book of poetry. I'm so random. Jewel has. Tupac has. And both of their books are on my shelf. But the woman who wrote that haunting lyric to My All and the saddest song about hope (Right to Dream) in her down time could totally write a book of poems. It may bring her down to earth since everybody thinks they can write them anyway so it's relatable. It would force her to give up the diva showgirl act when she promotes it. But yeah, Languishing. That should be the title. I feel better already.
(Tuesday 29 April 2025; 20:33)

Let's not act surprised (108,620) by Randy from USA

I get no satisfaction out of being correct. When this whole process started, I knew that it was an uphill battle. What I've been trying in vain to get everyone on this board to see is that I really do believe in the talent of Mariah Carey. I know the industry doesn't respect her, and what's sad is when I look at the greats: Stevie Wonder, Michael Jackson, Joni Mitchell, Bob Dylan, Carole King, Aretha Franklin, and I look at Mariah at her prime, she outings and outranks every one of them, but the public would never be able to equate the lighting, the bad side, the eternally 12, the teetering in heels with someone who is a great. When you say Mariah Carey's name in public there are snickers. To most she's someone who whistles and is a Christmas tradition. Need more proof that the industry doesn't respect her look at how many album of the years Taylor Swift has won? Look at the fact that they let Mary J. Blige, OutKast and Missy Elliott into the Rock 'n' Roll Hall of Fame before Mariah. This is where the queens will say Mariah doesn't care, but I even call that BS because she campaigned on her own site asking us to vote and creating a special video with her career accomplishments. I called this months ago and ran around like my hair was on fire and most of this board yawned and turned over and went back to sleep, so today I return the favor.
(Monday 28 April 2025; 20:37)

When You Believe (108,585) by Randy from USA

I saw this performance of [When You Believe] a few years ago and I had forgotten how much Mariah and Whitney's personalities matter to a song. Sure you can hear Whitney breathing and Mariah's rasp but I would take the two of them singing imperfectly over the two perfect [Broadway] girls version any day.
(Thursday 17 April 2025; 23:27)

My one TEOM track is (108,538) by Randy from USA

Circles. It's so 70s and fresh at the same time. She's straining but it adds to the emotion. I really thought Circles was strong enough to follow Shake It Off without a re-release with new songs to keep momentum going. There's a lot of strong songs on TEOM, whereas E=MC2 is the more consistent album. I actually feel like Memoirs is more consistent too but the best songs on TEOM are like nuclear weapons.
(Wednesday 9 April 2025; 16:25)


this is a reply to message		108,532

I just don't share y'all's anticipation (108,510) by Randy from USA

I swear I have a degree in English. Look, on MC's birthday, sorry Robert A, anniversary, I put her on shuffle and there were songs I heard I hadn't played in years. You're Cold, Your Girl, Bye Bye remix with Akon and Lil Wayne, Supernatural, You Need Me. Listening to ya'll talk about no new music, I realized MC has a lush, plentiful, diverse catalogue. Even when I consider my favorites, I have more than enough music to satiate me. And if I really am honest, MIAMTEC is awful, when you speak comparatively to Butterfly and Daydream. Caution is only a hair better. Do I want her to continue in that vein? New music is good, I guess, but I'm just not panting for it.
(Friday 4 April 2025; 13:30)

Favorite Mariah Hip-Hop collaborations (108,496) by Randy from USA

John, it took me ten minutes to realize what you were talking about. I don't know why but I have always liked that song although it is cheesy af. For those who didn't get it we are talking about Mariah's sole rapping credit, Prisoner. I'll see you lata cuz. You're just a playa. That's not my fault. And imagine if MC had her way and saved Love Takes Time for her second album and the first album ended on Prisoner. Scary, huh.
(Monday 31 March 2025; 22:32)


this is a reply to message		108,492

Favorite Mariah Hip-Hop collaborations (108,488) by Randy from USA

You all are missing out on the best version of Fantasy. It is the Bad Boy Mix which I think is track 4 on the maxi-single. It has both the pop hook and ODB on it. It's the only one I listen to. I love Honey with Mase and The Lox. I hate the Jermaine Dupri remix. I love Gucci Mane on Obsessed. I love both The Roof extended Mobb Deep and Breakdown extended Bobe Thugs. I love the Nicki Minaj verse on Up Out My Face. My All/Stay Awhile with the rap is also a favorite.
(Sunday 30 March 2025; 04:50)


this is a reply to message		108,483

Happy birthday MC / What y'all playin? (108,470) by Randy from USA

Yes you are 56. But you barely give 40. What three MC songs are y'all listening to these days? Me: GTFO, Right To Dream and Languishng.
(Thursday 27 March 2025; 18:32)

Article: Brother accuses Mariah of orchestrating YouTube video (108,469) by Randy from USA

You know one of the most interesting things to come out of the Oprah interview in 2020, was when they talked about the duality of famous people's relatives feeling both entitled to handouts and hateful jealousy that their family member doesn't deserve what they get. I really feel as though MC would've given her family the world. Now I will happily say MC loves yes people, sycophants around her. With family she just wanted a degree of loyalty and I think Pat, Alison and Morgan disappointed and hurt her deeply. I hate to see him put her through this.
(Thursday 27 March 2025; 18:30)


this is a reply to message		108,468

Ribbon (108,436) by Randy from USA

I disagree about E=MC2 not being a vocal high, especially Thanx4Nothing, I love that octave change and sustained note at the end. You can't tell me I can't sing when I'm belting that out. And of course, y'all are tired of me saying it, but the final chorus and ad libs of y'all least favorite single Bye Bye are legendary to me. I will give you 5 points for Mine Again which is beautiful.
(Wednesday 26 March 2025; 00:59)


this is a reply to message		108,428

Emancipation & Daydream (108,425) by Randy from USA

Daydream: Underneath The Stars, Always Be My Baby

Emancipation: Circles, Don't Forget About Us

P.S. Eric were my jokes really that mean? [Webmaster: Yes, I thought they were racist.]
(Tuesday 25 March 2025; 16:23)


this is a reply to message		108,414

It's divas week (108,403) by Randy from USA

Uh-oh, break out the hairspray, sequins, booze. It's divas week. Birthdays: 3/23 Chaka. 3/25 Aretha. 3/26 Diana. 3/27 Mariah. 3/31 Celine. But today we start with our original Dorothy from The Wiz - Stephanie Mills. Now you all say I'm mean, so this week Ima be kind. Did y'all know that she has another talent besides singing?
(Saturday 22 March 2025; 23:57)

I don't Heart (108,375) by Randy from USA

Thank you Shezz and Edward for reading my message and understanding what I was trying to say. You know, if you ask an average person on the street who the great singer songwriters are, they will say Joni Mitchell, Carole King, Jewel maybe Alicia Keys, Sarah McLachlan, Lauryn Hill, Paula Cole. The reason why I care about the way MC carries herself image wise is because she is lumped in with the vanity songwriters. Madonna is a songwriter. Janet Jackson is a songwriter. Beyonce is a songwriter. Do you really think MC is on the level of the three I just mentioned? But to the general public and the music industry it's like "yeah yeah yeah you write songs". If I could get an earth-wide loudspeaker and closed captioning in the sky, I'd play Close My Eyes, Languishing, Petals, Butterfly, Vanishing, My All, Outside, Looking In and Right To Dream for the world. But since I don't have those means the most I can do is scream on this board, MC you're making a fool of yourself and tarnishing your legacy. Check out this exchange here. And of course there will be those who insult Wendy and downplay what was said. But if Mariah talks about lighting, ensembles, says she's eternally 12, and has a man to carry her umbrella, is anyone gonna believe she writes the best kcufin songs ever recorded? Oh and let me address the bitter old queen remark. I can't say what I want to say because it won't get posted. You could never, on your best day, with AI assistance, outwit me. I have a resume and a CV. Find yourself a schoolmate with a chipped tooth and peanut allergy to play with. I'm the principle principal up in this bitch. That's all.
(Wednesday 19 March 2025; 19:34)

I am trying (108,361) by Randy from USA

People have called me evil, a monster and Satan on this board for years. I really said I would start being more positive once I realized what we do to our superstars i.e Whitney, Prince and Michael. But when I saw MC talk about the lighting and her ensemble at the beginning of her speech last night, I was devastated. At a time I'm trying to make everyone around me take her, her catalogue and artistry seriously for the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame vote, I just felt like a fool. And what burned me up even most was all the 'Yass queen, slay' in the YouTube comments. Do they know the genius that once resided in that hollow shell? I'm tryna get people to take her as seriously as Joni Mitchell because I really believe in her talent that much. I have to wonder was she high or drunk last night. I just feel so stupid for blaming Stella for that era or Jermaine Dupri for MIAMTEC's rollout. A lot of Mariah's problem is Mariah. Get some help. PS I did enjoy her mentioning Pat. Oh and I guess she and Anderson Paak are a thing. Eric where's the barf emoji?
(Tuesday 18 March 2025; 15:20)

Always Be My Nodules (108,348) by Randy from USA

So, I'm doing some insomniac strolling through social media, and I see a video of Monica talking about why she has sounded a mess as of late. She had surgery and went back to singing and didn't listen to her doctor's instructions. I did some digging and found out she had surgery on her nodules. My jaw was as wide as Kelly Price's at Thanksgiving. Monica had been sounding awful according to clips I saw on Tik Tok and I just passed it off as maybe she wasn't as talented as I once thought. I even went so far as to declare the boy now belonging to Brandy. Monica is of little consequence to me because she was never vocally on MC, Celine or Whitney's level. But what this means for MC speaks volumes. Maybe she heard about the risk and was like "Nah, I'm good." What if they told her she could lose her whistle? That's part of her brand now. Although, side note, I'd rather the high chest belts more than the whistle. She uses that as a crutch to prove she still has "it". She now whistles more than a thousand gay tea kettles in London. But seriously, Monica was talking about a four month rehab and recovery. We all know discipline is the arch-nemesis of Mariah Carey. Even if she had the surgery, you think she would listen to instructions? I really want y'all to weigh in on this. Not you Kelly Price. I just can hear MC singing to her nodules, "You'll always be a part of me."
(Saturday 15 March 2025; 17:26)

Rock and Troll Hall of Fame (108,342) by Randy from USA

Robert grow a pair. You are the balance this board needs. Do not pay attention to whoever that said whatever. I haven't paid attention to her since she used to be popular. I used to say all the time we need you, Terna, jacker20 to balance the equation. My job, and when Andrew was here's job was to unbalance it. Anyway, to bring us to all back on point, I don't mind MC being last out of Mary, Madonna, Janet and Whitney. I mind the constant rejection, if it happens again. I could care less she married the Svengali that discovered her, that her live performances are as inconsistent as JLo's love life or that she'd rather appear a ditz obsessed with lighting than a living legend. MC is the best singer songwriter combination of all time. She has the record sales, lyrics, melodies and fans to prove it. This industry is biased against her and it shows. PS this is an industry that has given Britney Spears and Nicki Minaj MTVs Video Vanguard award before Paula Abdul, who hasn't received it. Think about that.
(Thursday 13 March 2025; 01:14)

Rock and Roll Hall of Fame (108,330) by Randy from USA

Y'all know I've been critical of MC due to lip syncing and such but this Rock and Roll Hall of Fame thing is getting me down. All of her peers, and I mean all of them, are in there. Mary, Whitney, Madonna and Janet. This is exactly in line with a lot of us have been saying for years. The industry doesn't respect her or her accomplishments. Look at her tributes. Look at her award count. Like this kinda matters. But ok. I'm beating another dead horse as y'all point out with me constantly.
(Monday 10 March 2025; 19:10)

Free music (108,279) by Randy from USA

You know MC wouldn't be in this situation if we still had "the CD". I hate to sound old like a Generation X-er but there was a magic to going to the store, tearing the cellophane off, ripping that annoying plastic tape off the top and opening a disc. Reading the producers, songwriters and thank you's. Mariah could be making music and making money from that. But now that everything is free once it hits the internet she has to tour. In a way, I was glad because the record companies were greedy. Refusing to issue singles in the late 90s to force you to buy a whole album that may suck. Natalie Imbruglia anyone? But ultimately digital music failed the artists most. There's a coupe of great documentaries on it too. Oh well. I like retelling the experience to my nieces and nephews about how I was in Sam Goody buying Glitter when the towers fell. They look up and ask Uncle Randy, why were you buying supplies to make arts and crafts?
(Thursday 27 February 2025; 17:00)

The issue I have (108,274) by Randy from USA

I can't be mad at Mariah for giving bad performances on miming. It's something everyone should expect. She's been doing it consistently since Charmbracelet when I saw her. If you go to a Mariah Carey or Anita Baker concert, you'll know they don't want to be there. Lauryn Hill and Madonna are always going to be late. Chaka Khan is gonna be high or drunk. None of this is news and yet people still shell out hundreds of dollars to see them? And then complain. These are karaoke artists. You go to sing and bask in their presence. Not to be entertained.
(Wednesday 26 February 2025; 20:20)

Remaining Vegas shows (108,242) by Randy from USA

I didn't know she signed with Live Nation. What bothers me about that is she's never been much of a performer. Even when she had the voice. I get record companies aren't handing out piles of cash to sign her but what about her past royalties? They're not enough to keep her afloat? I remember when she and Nick filed for divorce and some of the financials leaked. It surprised me that MC only made $4 million one year. For me, that would set me for retirement. But for her, the overhead, dahing. Trey Lorenz's sparkly blazer dry cleaning bills, Mary Ann Tatum's vocal coach studio rent, Evian with gold flakes for the dogs, Kristopher Buckle's contouring techniques copyright use, the squire who holds her iPhone, the squire who holds her Android, the rhinestone encrusted Suburban she is carried around in. She needs to seriously scale it back or sell her catalogue in one of those ridiculous publishing deals, if she plans to live at her present level. Maybe she should've married Packer. I kid. I kid.
(Friday 21 February 2025; 16:58)


this is a reply to message		108,241

Remaining Vegas shows (108,239) by Randy from USA

The clothing and perfuming offerings are bad ideas RA. The market is saturated. But you are definitely onto something with the writing and producing for other artists as an artist. Mariah can write circles around Kandi Burruss, Montell Jordan and Neyo. Look what they've done for others. And she could definitely write as well as those I consider close to her league Lauryn Hill, R Kelly, Babyface and Kanye. Again, look at what they've done for others. She could've written for Olivia Rodrigo, Sabrina Carpenter, Harry Styles or any other new artists that sell a lot of records and she could do a live festival once a year.
(Thursday 20 February 2025; 02:01)


this is a reply to message		108,238

Remaining Vegas shows (108,234) by Randy from USA

I just don't see the fire. Mariah has been like this off and on since Stella. It would scare me more if she moved around the stage, had banter and wasn't singing along to her own voice in the background. I 100% get she doesn't want to be there but that's common knowledge and people will still go see her because she's an icon. My concern is it does reek of financial trouble and not necessarily, I love to perform so much I don't know when to bow out gracefully. Mariah is fine. She is gigging to make sure she can keep Kristopher Buckle, Mary Ann Tatum, Trey Lorenz, Daniel Moore, the umbrella holder, the rental in LA, the G5, the upkeep on the NYC pad and the house in the Bahamas taken care of. I don't see Whitney Houston's decline. I see more of a Joan Crawford, Judy Garland thing here. "I'm Mariah, dahling. I can't be broke."
(Wednesday 19 February 2025; 05:04)


this is a reply to message		108,232

Rock and Roll Hall of Fame (108,210) by Randy from USA

I voted and I asked my Facebook to vote and my gay Facebook group to vote. I guess I am a Stan. I think I'm pissed that all of her peers (Whitney, Janet, Madonna and Mary) are in and she's not. Down the road if Celine gets in before MC, it would mean some things about the industry's feelings about her that a lot of us aren't willing to face.
(Thursday 13 February 2025; 18:28)


this is a reply to message		108,207

Mariah doesn't need no man (108,181) by Randy from USA

I don't think she was ever in love with Tommy. I think she was in love with Luis and she was in love with Nick. The rest are companionships. Her issue right now is what her issue has been since birth. Insecurity. It is hard being in the world eye when you are considered one of the best vocalists who have ever lived and are having problems with your voice. It is hard when you come out and meet your idols Aretha, Patti, Olivia Newton John and Diana. Now you are their age and the girls that are popular are on the charts and winning awards are Ariana Grande, Sabrina Carpenter and Olivia Rodrigo. MC hates touring but needs the money to keep the umbrella holder and her three homes. Tanaka may have been a comfort but he's not the reason she's in pieces. MCs real problem is that she is under pressure about vocal ability, aging and finances.
(Tuesday 11 February 2025; 19:58)

MORE MESSAGES