Messageboard

Only registrated members can post messages. Registration is free.
LOG IN REGISTER

About D from United States: She’s an icon, she’s a legend, and she is THE MOMENT!!

The girl we fell in love with, the woman she became (114,772) by D from United States
Sorry. I was on vacation and had too much free time on my hands.
(Monday 26 October 2026; 13:30)
this is a reply to message 114,771
Anther correction (114,767) by D from United States
Giving Me Life not Bringing Me to Life. In the last paragraph. Sorry.
(Monday 26 October 2026; 03:41)
The girl we fell in love with, the woman she became (114,766) by D from United States
I’ve been thinking about the girl-next-door Mariah from her debut until about Glitter. Glitter must have been a much harder time for her than we can imagine because she went through a major death and rebirth. She was in her early 30s around the time of Glitter and Charmbracelet, so it makes sense that she would outgrow that girl anyway. But the ego death she experienced around that time made it even more intense. After that experience, she had to reinvent herself and Phoenix even harder than she would have had to otherwise. At the beginning, she was curated into the pop princess the machine knew we wanted. Everything about her was manicured and perfect. It worked because we loved it. We ate it up. . We’re still in love with that girl we fell in love with back then, almost 40 years later. But that wasn’t entirely who she was. It was the surface of who she was, so it wasn’t fake, but it wasn’t everything. If you look at old pictures of her before she was famous, she always liked to dress sexy. Like you said, she’s one of those people who don’t need to try because it’s in their aura. Her sensual vibe was always going to shine through, no matter what she wore. But she likes to dress sexy. I mean, she loves Marilyn Monroe, the ultimate sex symbol/goddess. And why is that wrong? Why do we make it wrong? None of us are the same person we were when we were 20, 32, 41, 55, 73, or 90. Our life experiences change us. It makes sense that she would adopt the Ginger persona. When she was little, she used to watch reruns of Gilligan’s Island like the rest of us. As a little girl, I wanted to be Ginger too, so I can relate. Ginger was like a living Barbie doll. She had the most beautiful clothes, and all the men swooned over her. She was mesmerizing. After feeling controlled and managed by her career for so long, Mariah went through a period of trying to find herself again. She wanted to be young, free, and sexy, and in hindsight, I love that for her. At the time, it was a little jarring and confusing for me that the media turned against her because she had always been their sweetheart. If we felt that way, imagine how she felt? Probably like the plane was going down fast. I look back at the publicity and songs and music videos Jennifer Lopez was getting back then. It made me see how having all the support and talented people on your side really does help a ton. When I see Jennifer Lopez in her Fly Girl days, I don’t think she was extraordinarily special. They made her extraordinarily special. When you have an above-average physical package and then get the best makeup people, hair extensions, videographers, designers, publicists, label plugs with connections who want to make you the next big thing, and talented people writing your songs and singing them for you, that helps. That matters. Jennifer was wearing revealing clothes too, but the marketing was on her side. So it was okay for her, but Mariah was labeled “slutty” and “crazy. ” Mariah was blessed with beauty, so we do admire that about her. But when we look at Mariah’s actual art, her voice and her music, it’s always been great. Mariah’s music has never disappointed me. It has evolved, but art is supposed to. I didn’t understand Butterfly when it first came out. I wanted something that was more easily digestible. I was young. But then I grew up, and when I finally got it, I REALLY got it. I love that she’s the Queen of Christmas. I love Mariah memes. I love memes in general. I don’t love tabloids, but it’s not like she’s going after them, asking them to write scandalous stories about her. The tabloid thing can’t be blamed on her. Famous people will always be targeted by the tabloids, and it’s up to the public to choose whether to pay attention to that or not. Also, another thought I just had: Why are men (and some women) so threatened by women who wear sexy clothes? In my opinion, it’s mostly men who want to control women and shame us into submission. It’s a different thing when it’s young women whose bodies are being exploited by older men. I’m not okay with that. But if it’s a 30-year-old woman wearing short shorts and a tube top in the summertime because it’s hot outside and she wants to feel unrestricted and comfortable, and it’s her own choice, I don’t think that judgment is warranted. Take Tate McRae, for example. She’s always scantily clad, but she’s a trained dancer, so that’s the kind of stuff she’s used to wearing. She looks comfortable, and it seems like it’s her own choice. So I don’t have a problem with her nakedness. (On a side note, I really love her and her personality, and I hope she has a long and prosperous career. ) Shakira has always seemed comfortable in her sexiness and her body too. But there are some artists where it doesn’t look comfortable or natural. It looks like they’re doing it because someone else told them to or suggested it. I don’t like that. The Loverboy remix and the abundance of guest artists: I think it works. If you didn’t like it, it’s probably because you don’t like rap music, and that’s okay. That’s why she has a version without the rappers. This just occurred to me: I think that’s why she makes the joke in Glitter about getting rid of the “superfluous shit. ” She knew what some people would say. Ha ha. Honestly, I’m not super into rap music either. I mostly only know the huge hits and what Mariah has shared with the world. The emphasis on attitude and the argument that the music became more disposable and less emotionally meaningful than her earlier work: She has deep, emotional tracks on all her albums, so I’m not sure why you say this. Historically, she’s had fun songs that are usually the main single. Fantasy, Dreamlover, and Heartbreaker weren’t deep or emotional either. They’re on the same level as Loverboy, Obsessed, and #Beautiful. On that note, I wanted to share something. I was watching Mariah Carey interview videos on YouTube while I was cleaning my house. A video came up where these guys were comparing Mary J. Blige, Janet, Whitney, and Mariah. One of the men had the nerve to put Mariah Carey at the bottom. . He said Mariah Carey is a singles/hit artist and doesn’t have any albums that are good as a whole. Tell me you’ve never listened to an entire Mariah Carey album without telling me you’ve never listened to an entire Mariah Carey album. . And a lot of people think this. . I was talking to a girl at my old job, and we were talking about our favorite artists. I said Mariah Carey. She made a face and said, “Oh no, not her. ” WTF. I was so shocked because this girl, my ex-coworker, is the coolest, most nonjudgmental person ever. It got me thinking that this narrative against Mariah runs deep, and it’s going to continue if something isn’t done. If you watch old interviews, she was so happy, confident, and free, and now she’s like a puppy that’s been abused. The media has been abusive to Mariah, so I understand it. She always has to be careful about what she says because everything can be twisted to fit a narrative. She probably wonders if it’s even worth it and checks out. I’m sure she only goes through with it partly because she knows there are some of us who still love her. And I feel like she still has hope that things will turn around and people will appreciate her creations again. On that YouTube clip I watched, one of the other guys told the naysayer that Mariah has a lot of good songs that have never been heard and that she wasn’t at the bottom. The older guy told him he really didn’t believe that. He wouldn’t even let him have his own opinion. Oh, and the guy just got up to go to the bathroom in the middle of the conversation and told everyone. It was a short clip, like 10 minutes, and I can’t find it now, but I wish I could so I could share it with you guys. To the guy who defended Mariah: I wish all the good things for you, sir. May both sides of your pillow always stay cool, and I pray you have more abundance and good fortune than you could ever imagine. The only thing I remember is that it was four Black men, and one was called Joe Budden. (I remember because it sounds like Joe Biden.) Anyway, Mariah has lots of good songs that are unheard of by anyone but fans. While I’ve been responding to this post, I’ve had a Mariah playlist of all her songs playing in the background, and every song has been a banger. Impossible. So Blessed. Yours. You Need Me. Where I Belong. Bringing Me Life. I am Free, I Wish You Well, You Don’t Know What to Do. My point is, she’s still great. She needs better marketing.
(Monday 26 October 2026; 02:47)
HFIA (114,757) by D from United States
Maybe you’re right.
(Sunday 25 October 2026; 08:18)
this is a reply to message 114,749
HFIA (114,746) by D from United States
A lot of times we pay for experience and skill, and that is valuable. But sometimes we can find people who have natural talent who won't charge a fortune because they're just getting started. A lot of the expensive music video producers charge a small fortune because they've already made it and have to maintain their expensive lifestyles. I'm not saying they're not worth it. These days, you pretty much need to be independently wealthy to even try to be any kind of artist. The equipment used to make good art is not cheap.

When I was young, I used to play the flute, and I had to stop because we couldn't afford to rent it anymore. I'm not saying I was ever going to be a famous flutist, but it was a hobby I enjoyed. It makes me wonder about the kids who actually do have natural talent that never gets the chance to grow and develop.

To be able to afford another video, they could go to an art school and ask the professor if there are any promising students. They could let them borrow equipment, have them come up with a concept, and make a rough demo. Whoever wins gets to make a low-budget video. The top candidates could win a $1,000 cash prize, and the winner could get more. It still wouldn't cost nearly as much as hiring a more established and experienced artist. I'm not even thinking top-tier schools, either. I'm thinking community colleges. That would be life-changing money for some people. They could invest it into buying equipment that would support and nurture their talent.

I know experience and skill do matter, and a lot of times that's what we pay for. But there are rare gems who are naturally gifted. We've all witnessed them. We're in a timeline where money can't be our main focus right now. She has made a lot of money off the people and could use this as an opportunity to give back.
(Saturday 24 October 2026; 03:07)
this is a reply to message 114,744
More thoughts about this (114,745) by D from United States
Whoever gets chosen to play Mariah in a movie would have to lip-sync. No one should even attempt to sing like Mariah. The reason I like Victoria Justice is because her cheekbones remind me of her, and she has that Bambi vibe Mariah had from her debut album up until Glitter. After that, the glamorous persona (Ginger) came out, and we never saw the girl-next-door again.

Early Mariah had a combination of innocence, vulnerability, sweetness, and quiet sensuality. She looked doe-eyed in interviews, then she'd sing those impossible notes like it was easy. Like a Goddess.

Whoever plays her would have to nail Mariah's mannerisms: the shy little smiles, the way she laughs when she's being cheeky, the hand gestures, and her slightly awkward, girlish humor. The voice can be dubbed, but the personality has to feel real. Who do you guys think could play her?

Also, Keke Palmer could play Whitney in the MC biopic. She captures her essence. I've read other people say Keke should play Whitney in a biopic about Whitney but I think she could play Whitney in Mariah's biopic too.
(Friday 23 October 2026; 15:57)
this is a reply to message 114,741
HFIA (114,742) by D from United States
They could have at least given us something to commemorate the moment, though. Not all music videos need to be high-budget productions. She probably spends more on a birthday party than what a low-budget music video would cost. In fact, she could have just filmed her birthday party and turned it into a music video. She could have even had her kids shoot some footage from an "icon's kids" point of view, like when Cathy and Christopher used to spy on their mom's extravagant parties in Flowers in the Attic. It sounded fabulous, and I was just reading about it in a book.

On that note, Sugar Sweet needed to go harder. It needs more bass. Can we get a remix? Can we get Wyclef Jean on the line? Ask him to make it sound more like Ghetto Superstar? I want my car to rattle.
(Friday 23 October 2026; 06:09)
this is a reply to message 114,739
Biopic (114,741) by D from United States
If there were a biopic about Mariah, I think Victoria Justice could do her justice. She's stunning, and I'm surprised she didn't become more famous. She's one of those people I never get tired of looking at when she's on the screen. Her speaking voice isn't as beautiful as Mariah's, not that it's unpleasant. Mariah's speaking voice is celestial.
(Friday 23 October 2026; 01:48)
Last Meals Show (114,740) by D from United States
I've been catching up on shows this past month, and I came across a YouTube channel called Mythical Kitchen. Celebrities come on and have their favorite meals prepared for them - the meals they would choose for their last day on Earth. I've watched several episodes now, and I've loved every one.

The host is gracious and asks great questions. It feels like you're just hanging out with friends. Nothing feels uncomfortable or intrusive. I'd love to see Mariah on this show.

After watching these long-form episodes, I feel like I know the guests better, but the episodes never feel too long. Some of these people I'd never even heard of before, but by the end, I found myself wanting to invest more time in getting to know them. I like the host just as much as I like Keke Palmer as a host. They're both naturals.

YouTube has some of the best shows out there right now, and it's one of the few platforms I feel is actually worth subscribing to. I only subscribe to YouTube and Prime. YouTube is also the only social media platform I feel is worth my time right now.

The thing about Mariah's interviews is that they've been boring lately because she gets asked the same questions over and over, even on good shows where the interviewer usually asks more interesting questions. I suspect they're given an approved list of questions. What I think they should do is let Chef Josh ask the questions he genuinely wants to ask, but maybe send them to her beforehand so she has time to think about her responses. That way, we might get to hear something new and have a more meaningful conversation.
(Friday 23 October 2026; 01:31)
Mariah as a mini-doll (114,728) by D from United States
I love it. You inspired me. I made a Billie Frank doll and she looks so good.
(Tuesday 20 October 2026; 14:25)
this is a reply to message 114,727
Article: Mariah Carey wins dismissal of brother's defamation lawsuit (114,725) by D from United States
Isn't it pretty easy to look up if someone has been "in the system"?
(Tuesday 20 October 2026; 12:25)
Gliiter cd (114,708) by D from United States
I have it on CD. I wanted to get the hot pink vinyl because it's my favorite color but I missed out.
(Monday 19 October 2026; 05:12)
this is a reply to message 114,707
Loverboy video in 4K (114,705) by D from United States
Actually, instead of a Christmas re-release, a Valentine's Day one. Date night or Galentine's Date Night. I love how camp and cheesy it is and the songs are all top tier. If they update it like they did the video it would look so good on the big screen. Critics will most likely talk crap about it but who cares. Movies aren't making tons of money these days but I still think it would be a good idea. It would be a fun nostalgic moment. At the time of the original release the public was told Mariah wasn't cool anymore so a lot of people went along with that and didn't watch it so this would be the first time watching for a lot of people. The movie is cheesy but so are a lot of beloved movies. We shouldn't hold that against it. It just needs more full length songs in it. And yes it would make it longer but who cares? Titanic was three hours long. Some people are always going to have something to complain about and that's just part of life. But it would be a fun moment for a lot of people too.

Also, they should change the title of the movie back to All That Glitters (for the expanded musical version) and release a Barbie Billie Frank wearing the pink outfit with the knee high boots and it should come with a red bandana. And a Barbie car but make it the purple car she rides in the music video. And they could sell the best outfits (for the Mariah Barbie) she wears in the movie like they did with the Barbie movie outfits. What else? Do they have more footage they can maybe work with that they didn't use for the original movie? Someone good would have to splice it together. I'm thinking I'm in the wrong line of work. Ha ha.
(Sunday 18 October 2026; 04:27)
this is a reply to message 114,701
Last Night a DJ Saved My Life (114,703) by D from United States
I love this one. She looks so beautiful and happy and alive. I wish it was in better quality. I wish I had good editing skills because I would make a video like the Michael Jackson one Don't Stop 'Til You Get Enough but with a mostly dark pink background.
(Saturday 17 October 2026; 16:44)
Firecracker (114,702) by D from United States
I also think they should rework the Firecracker version and make it better. Her vocals sound better on that version but I think the music could be better. The sample is really cool. They could play that version during the closing credits of the Glitter theatrical re-release.
(Saturday 17 October 2026; 16:30)
Loverboy video in 4K (114,701) by D from United States
It looks so good. Glitter needs a Christmas re-release and they should somehow add the Loverboy video to the movie and make it a musical. They should add all the music videos she made for the Glitter album to the movie. I wonder if there are any more we don't know about. Out Here On My Own? I know Never Too Far is already in it but they should all be in it. Total cult classic. Back then I was a goody two shoes and didn't love how naked she was but now that I'm older I appreciate how good her body looks in that era. She still looks good but there's nothing like being thirty, flirty, and thriving.
(Saturday 17 October 2026; 16:18)
Two focus points for MC17 (114,679) by D from United States
It's not impossible, but I think she burned bridges with people who could help her. Maybe in the moment, she chose to be right rather than trying to understand where the other parties were coming from, leading to hostility and tension and annoying or hurting the people she's in conflict with. She needs to decide what's most important: mutual progress or winning.
(Sunday 11 October 2026; 13:42)
this is a reply to message 114,675
Article: Mariah Carey's photo with "The Last Supper" painting (114,668) by D from United States
This picture looks like the meme of the little girl with the house burning behind her.
(Friday 9 October 2026; 06:52)
Article: Mariah Carey sends sweet video message to DWTS contestants (114,665) by D from United States
I think the If It's Over cover is the only one I loved.
(Thursday 8 October 2026; 18:14)
this is a reply to message 114,660
Article: Mariah Carey sends sweet video message to DWTS contestants (114,664) by D from United States
I wish Mariah would have given them a discount.
(Thursday 8 October 2026; 18:01)
this is a reply to message 114,662
Article: Mariah Carey sends sweet video message to DWTS contestants (114,658) by D from United States
I watched the performances on YouTube but they were not the original versions sung by Mariah. Were they her versions on the real show when it aired?
(Thursday 8 October 2026; 03:22)
Somebody's Ugly Daughter (114,657) by D from United States
I have an active imagination. I was thinking in the show (Elle) Liz could sing it in her voice like it's her song but then one day she gets sick so Elle has to take over and sing it one time in Mariah's original recording voice. One or two songs. So they can get heard without stealing Liz's thunder. We all know Elle eventually becomes a lawyer not a singer.

I like the Robyn Sparkles storyline in How I Met Your Mother because it's unexpected. Robyn can sing?
(Thursday 8 October 2026; 03:08)
this is a reply to message 114,653
Somebody's Ugly Daughter (114,653) by D from United States
I watched the series Elle on Prime video. It's Elle from Legally Blonde when she's in high school in 1995. I thought it was so cute. They have this part where they have little indie concerts at a carpet store. They could have one of the bands perform a couple of the songs. It would be Mariah's voice from the recording back then, but lip-sung. One of the main characters is a singer, but I don't know if she would want lip-sing. It would need to be an actress who can't sing and wouldn't mind miming the Mariah track. Some reviews I read said they didn't like the show but I really liked it. I'm not sure if they're having another chapter but if they did this would be a fun way to showcase the songs.
(Wednesday 7 October 2026; 09:05)
this is a reply to message 114,650
Here For It All (114,652) by D from United States
I'm really glad to hear the clouds are starting to lift for you. It sounds like you've been through a lot. I hope this is the beginning of a brighter chapter. Sending you lots of love and hoping you're back on your feet and feeling like yourself again soon.
(Wednesday 7 October 2026; 08:57)
this is a reply to message 114,629
Fantasy track list (114,610) by D from United States
I know inspiration doesn't always flow all the time for artists but I would be happy with an album of covers. A concept album of really good songs from the past that fit her current voice. She always makes the songs she covers her own and puts so much emotion into them. I'd like to hear more in her lower range too.

For this, I wouldn't even want huge publicity around it. It could be an album (or albums) she releases quietly. I know I'm greedy in regards of Mariah but I can't help it. She's already given us so much, but I want more. I really liked My Prayer and think she could travel down that vein more.

My track list:
Unforgettable - Nat King Cole
It's Magic - Dinah Washington
Stardust - Nat King Cole
I Only Have Eyes for You - The Flamingos
Just My Imagination - The Temptations
Summertime - Ella Fitzgerald
Life Is but a Dream - Dion
Since I Don't Have You - The Skyliners
Smoke Gets in Your Eyes - The Platters
Unchained Melody - The Righteous Brothers
The Impossible Dream - Roberta Flack

Bonus: not like the others, but I love them:
The Sound of Silence - Simon & Garfunkel
Bittersweet Symphony - The Verve
Lover, You Should've Come Over - Jeff Buckley
(Wednesday 30 September 2026; 02:35)

MORE MESSAGES

Only registrated members can post messages. Registration is free.
LOG IN REGISTER



If you want to leave a message, there are a few rules you must follow:
1. This is a Mariah Carey messageboard, so the message must be related to Mariah Carey.
2. Only messages in English will be posted. And please try to write understandable English, with the proper use of dots and capitals.
3. Messages with all capitals will be ignored.
4. Messages that are insulting (to Mariah, other artists or members of this messageboard) will not be posted.
The webmaster has the right to refuse any message he doesn't like.
© MCArchives 1998-2026 (28 years!)
NEWS
MESSAGEBOARD