Messageboard

About Giovanni from USA: Big music lover who loves Mimi.

Sweetheart (113,263) by Giovanni from USA Should have at the very least been an r&b hit. I had it on a loop today it's one of my favorites Mariah produced with JD. Her voice and vocals are perfect and there's nothing to complain about with this song. Of course if you don't like JD's part haha but I love JD so I like his verse. I hope they work together again for Mariah's next album. (Sunday 15 February 2026; 23:04)

MC's next album (113,258) by Giovanni from USA I agree, Butterfly was Mariah's escape from Tommy and she was able to be free and do the music she wanted. It's definitely probably her best album. (Sunday 15 February 2026; 00:24) this is a reply to message 113,254

MC's next album (113,254) by Lighty from China IMHO Butterfly, Charmbracelet, Memoirs are the three most personal albums from Mariah but Butterfly is and will always be "the" most personal one no matter what kind of album she puts out next. (Saturday 14 February 2026; 08:29)

MC's next album (113,253) by Giovanni from USA I hope we don't have to wait another 7 years for the next album lol. And as you had mentioned Nostalgic or Nostalgia would be a good album title. It's strong and makes sense if Mariah wants to make a record that reminds her remaining fans of her past work. HFIA had potential with IYF and NII but as I brought up recently it really doesn't matter how good her next album is if the voice doesn't sound good. I am hoping something changes and she gets it back in better shape ala Caution. (Saturday 14 February 2026; 02:57) this is a reply to message 113,251

MC's next album (113,251) by Bobby A from United States Do you think MC's next album will have to be her most personal album to date? I think MC needs to create a body of work that has a bold relatable album title that makes the non-Lamb scrolling on social media say, "Hmmm?" The album has to read like a personal diary with an infusion of jazz, pop, dance, and R&B. I want to hear more of the good, the bad, and the ugly next time. MC is going have to make a bold personal statement with her next album like Jill Scott did today. (Saturday 14 February 2026; 00:39)

Nodules (113,252) by Giovanni from USA I love the AI version of "My love", f you ask me it would have fit perfectly on the Butterfly album. I would have swapped out "Whenever you call" as it's one of the few songs from Mariah I don't care for. I imagine "Jesus I do" in Music Box voice or Emancipation voice. Speaking of "Jesus I do", I want Mariah to work with Kirk Franklin for another gospel number. I love "Jesus I do" and I love "Fly like a bird". I feel "Fly like a bird" is a personal song for Mariah and one most of us love. I also have a great love for "I pray" and wished it was longer and had made it on TEOM. I wish we had gotten a gospel album in 2015 instead of another greatest hits none of us needed. (Saturday 14 February 2026; 02:43) this is a reply to message 113,248

Nodules (113,248) by Stacey from USA Well said. There is an AI version of My Love (Butterfly era) floating around the internet. Wow. Check that one out. There is one thing, though, that does unite all these vocal eras - the songwriter. No matter how Mariah's voice has changed, no matter what era is used to create an AI version of one of her songs, there is one constant in all of this - the songwriter. Those lyrics are truly what makes her music so special. (Friday 13 February 2026; 18:16)

Nodules (113,245) by Giovanni from USA It's okay Stacey, I also listen to AI versions of Mariah as well. For me it's not so much me wishing she still sounded like her younger self it's just for fun. We all have our own fantasy Mariah song covers we wish she had covered. The AI version of IYF in Daydream voice is so addictive and amazing. I don't think there's anything wrong with wanting Mariah to get her voice back in shape I just think she doesn't care anymore. I'm still listening to Caution and HFIA regularly though. NIA has become of my favorites along with "Jesus I do". (Friday 13 February 2026; 06:04) this is a reply to message 113,242

Nodules (113,242) by Stacey from USA I absolutely love the messages from HFIA, song and album. But I'd be lying to myself if I wasn't a bit conflicted when listening to these songs given her current voice. It's just not the same. I feel like such a cop out seeking AI versions of HFIA, IYF and NII using Butterfly and/or Daydream vocals, preferring to listen to those versions sometimes. At the end of the day, I can't be too sad. I have such an amazing, unmatched by anyone catalog of music to listen to. (Thursday 12 February 2026; 17:32)

We belong together on GMA 2013 (113,241) by Giovanni from USA That's the Mariah I miss. Confident, singing live, happy and engaging with the crowd. She went off singing that song and I think that might be her best performance of the song. Oh and the hair and dress was on point. I'll never get over the disaster that was of that era. (Thursday 12 February 2026; 08:44)

Nodules (113,240) by Giovanni from USA I agree her voice was perfect and sounded so angelic that year. It seems like everything went down hill after her shoulder injury and after the divorce. One of Marian's problems is that she is surrounded by yes people and more and likely they don't care about her voice or legacy. (Thursday 12 February 2026; 07:43) this is a reply to message 113,235

Nodules (113,235) by Rashidi Rahim Rick from Malaysia If she stops drinking or smoking whatever purple taking her higher, she will gain back her voice. Remember when she was pregnant in 2010 and she performed One Child in Washington? Her tone of her voice for the first verse specifically the part "blessed baby boy" that was pure Music Box tone but the mature version. (Wednesday 11 February 2026; 14:51)

Mariah's voice (113,239) by Giovanni from USA I'm glad we're finally discussing the current state of Mariah's voice. There are many fans who are delusional and who are in denial. I really think Mariah doesn't care and has just accepted how she sounds and like Edward said it's sad. I really do like HFIA but it would be so much better and enjoyable if Mariah had her MOAIA or Caution voice. I appreciate her giving us another album but I believe there is something that happened or something that's going on and why her voice sounds the way it does. I read that medications can cause dryness and inflammation and that's what we hear. I feel so bad as I'm typing this because I feel as though I'm trashing her but I'm not. I just want her to sound good again and I refuse to believe that's not possible. (Thursday 12 February 2026; 07:37)

Nodules (113,228) by Giovanni from USA I doubt Mariah had her nodules removed. The success rate for nodules removal especially today is high. If anything she would sound better. Her problem is she doesn't take care of her voice like she used to like in her younger days. A lot of fans say she has vocal damage but I disagree it's definitely the champagne. Vocal damage can be fixed. One of the things I love about the Caution album is that her voice sounds very good especially in. Even during the pandemic she showed she was in a good place vocally. I don't wanna judge Mariah but I definitely think she turned to drinking to cope with something. A lot of people in the industry turn to drugs or drinking to cope with the stress life of being an artist or because of loneliness/depression. I sometimes think would she be in a better place emotionally had she and Nick still been together. Even with Bryan she looked very happy and alive which makes me believe she might feel lonely at times. I truly believe her kids help a lot and give her a reason to live. I hope whatever she's going through especially health wise is helped by God. (Tuesday 10 February 2026; 07:13)

John from USA (113,227) by Giovanni from USA There's a picture of Mariah with designer Fausto Puglisi he posted on his Insta and her hair there style looks different than when she hit the stage for her performance at the Olympics but that is how I like her hair styled. In fact I would love if she got a shoulder length cut and went brunette again. I like you am over the long hair it's so TEOM. (Tuesday 10 February 2026; 06:50)

What MC really needs moving forward (113,199) by Giovanni from USA I couldn't agree more. I have been wanting Mariah to write with Diane Warren since 2013. They could definitely come up with something good. As for a new manager I say bring back Stella. She would fix everything and put Mariah back on top where she belongs. (Sunday 8 February 2026; 06:42) this is a reply to message 113,189

What MC really needs moving forward (113,189) by Bobby A from United States I have been thinking all day about what MC needs for that "big moment" in the spotlight for at least 6 months before she drops a new album. First, she needs a Diane Warren collaboration theme song for an upcoming new movie or sequel. Second, she needs a JD and Johnta Austin follow-up to We Belong Together without repeating the same formula. Third, MC needs a high profile collaboration this year. Finally, she needs a young manager who can put her back on top with her current voice. (Sunday 8 February 2026; 00:35)

More youthful hairstyle please (113,198) by Giovanni from USA I agree I have never been a fan of the long hair and Mariah looks better with shorter hair. I loved her milf cut in 2013 when she sang "Looking in" in New York in her arm sling and her appearance on Jimmy Fallon also from the same year. I wish she would go back to being a brunette. (Sunday 8 February 2026; 06:37) this is a reply to message 113,188

More youthful hairstyle please (113,188) by John from USA If she insists on being a statue, at least get a style update. The Cowardly Lion Mane has to go. It totally ages and dates her, makes her even less accessible. Bring back the honey gold blonde hair with more volume up top and maybe even side-swept bangs. (Saturday 7 February 2026; 23:52)

Bill / Bobby (113,197) by Giovanni from USA Both of you are wrong. Mariah sang ABMB live in 2009 at iHeart radio, it's available on YouTube. She also sang WBT live in 2013 at GMA. The climax is up for debate but judging by her face at the end I would say it's live. She looked so mad and annoyed haha. Two very good live performances in case anyone hasn't seen them. (Sunday 8 February 2026; 06:33)

Grammys (113,131) by Giovanni from USA It's been a while since I've paid attention to the Grammys and boy did I make a mistake tuning in. It was probably the worst Grammy awards ever. It got way too political and the performances were awful. Bad Bunny winning album of the year was the shocker of the night for me. I really thought Gaga was going to take it. And Trevor Noah my guy you have no talent. (Monday 2 February 2026; 08:58)

MusicCares (113,130) by Giovanni from USA I'm sorry but I was not impressed with that tribute. It was all a big disappointment and a slap in the face to Mariah she deserved better. Where was Kelly Clarkson, Ariana, Bruno Mars, Yolanda Adams, Usher, Beyonce even Patti Labelle? I did surprisingly enjoy Kesha and Charlie Puth's performance. Billy Porter was awful and I don't think ABMB was appropriate for him. He was also giving me Whitney Houston in drag with that hair. If you're give a tribute to a legend like Mariah get some better singers. (Monday 2 February 2026; 08:47)

Mimi L. (113,129) by Giovanni from USA I've missed you so much and your post had me dying. I agree with you 100%, most of those performances were all a hot mess especially Billy Porter. (Monday 2 February 2026; 08:31)

Billboard speech (113,106) by Giovanni from USA She really did look straight out of 2005. I've never been a fan of the long hair but she rocks it well. I also loved the ensemble it was sexy. Mariah at 56 is still that girl. How many women can look that good at her age. She looks like she's watching her weight too cause she looks fit. Curvy but not fat. She was giving Emancipation Mariah at Billboard. (Saturday 31 January 2026; 07:55) this is a reply to message 113,099

Billboard speech (113,099) by Zachariah from Croatia She looked so youthful. Wow. And yes, very focused. I loved it. (Thursday 29 January 2026; 12:11)

Possible The Rarities II songs (113,087) by Giovanni from USA I'm still mad at Mariah for not finishing "Bring it on home" and putting it on an album. It's a great song that had potential to be another signature Mariah song. (Monday 26 January 2026; 08:19) this is a reply to message 113,081

Possible The Rarities II songs (113,081) by Bobby A from United States I thought I would look in my Mariah book to see what MC could possibly release as the The Rarities II tracklist. 1. Weakness of the Body 2. Lose Control 3. Reach For The Sky 4. Help Me Make It Through The Night 5. Right To Dream 6. Where Are You Christmas? 7. When I Feel It 8. Secret Love 9. Sprung 10. Imperfect 11. Skydiving 12. You and I - BET performance/Stevie Wonder Tribute 13. Last Night A DJ Saved My Life - VH1 performance 14. 2015 Diane Warren collaboration 15. 100% 16. Bring It On Home 17. With You I'm Born Again - duet with John Legend - VH1 performance 18. Thirsty ft. Rich Homie Quan 19. Goin Up Yonder - Richard Smallwood cover 20. Jesus I Do - Acapella 21. The Demo Tape 22. All My Life - Acapella 23. My Saving Grace - BET performance 24. Betcha Gon Know - Acapella 25. Metorite - QTip's original version 26. Looking In - MLB All-Star Charity event performance 27. Vision of Love - Grammy performance 28. Yours ft. Justin Timberlake (Sunday 25 January 2026; 08:46)

Third Christmas album (113,080) by Giovanni from USA Before 2025 I really didn't care for Christmas or Christmas music, I'm much more of a Thanksgiving guy but now I appreciate Christmas much more. Acknowledging and celebrating the birth of Jesus Christ. I consider myself both a liberal and conservative person when it comes to religion. I absolutely believe in God and have starting liking gospel and Christian music as of late. I really appreciate Mariah making both Christmas albums especially the second. In fact I like Merry Christmas II You much more. Her voice sounds mature and her tone and vibrato sound better. Mariah was taking care of her voice when she was pregnant. Her rendition of "The First Noel" is fantastic and beautiful. I would love a third Christmas album one day. Maybe we can get a duet with Roe. (Sunday 25 January 2026; 07:22)

I won't allow it (113,079) by Giovanni from USA I love the production on "I won't allow it" and the song shows what a sense of humor Mariah has haha. Thought it was about Brian but it's actually about Nick. I would love to have heard 2009 Mariah sing this song. HFIA reminds me so much of MOAIA. (Sunday 25 January 2026; 07:03)

In your feelings (113,078) by Giovanni from USA It's becoming a fan favorite I believe, needs a video. It had potential to be a hit if Mariah had a fan base that streamed her music. I also believe "I don't" could have been a hit if it was a solo. The video is terrible though in my opinion. I enjoy HFIA for what it is. Mariah proved she still can write and produce a decent record. All I want from her is to work on her voice and continue doing the music that makes her happy. What I noticed is that she seemed to get a little of her confidence back in some of her live performances. (Sunday 25 January 2026; 06:50) this is a reply to message 113,062

In your feelings (113,062) by Stacey from USA Me too. Such a classic Mariah sounding song. IYF could totally be on Daydream. I wonder if this song would blow up the charts during that era. Such a radio friendly song. (Wednesday 21 January 2026; 18:15)

Deep cuts album (113,076) by Giovanni from USA I'm still bothered as well about "Can't let go". It definitely should have hit number one. It's really something though that Mariah managed to score 19 number ones in her career though, I'm proud of her for that. (Sunday 25 January 2026; 06:36) this is a reply to message 112,990

Deep cuts album (112,990) by Stacey from USA Till the End of Time is one of those deep cuts that doesn't get enough credit (outside of this board). Absolute emotional masterpiece. Still annoyed at stupid Sony for denying Can't Let Go a #1 title. Ugh. So deserving of one. (Tuesday 13 January 2026; 15:50)

In your feelings (113,057) by Giovanni from USA I'm addicted to IYF. It's definitely becoming my favorite song from the album. It definitely sounds like a hit and deserves a video. (Wednesday 21 January 2026; 06:51)

Private performance for fans on Jimmy Fallon 2013 (113,056) by Giovanni from USA I still love to watch that live performance of Mariah singing to "Fly like a bird" and "The art of letting go". So epic and showing the world she still could sing while also having fun. I would love for her to do something like that again soon. Her voice was in such good shape in 2013. (Wednesday 21 January 2026; 06:49)

MC17 (113,055) by Giovanni from USA I definitely think Caution is better, it's better produced. It's a no skips album. Also "Nostalgic" is actually a very good album title and I think Mariah should consider it. It would need a good album cover to go with it. (Wednesday 21 January 2026; 06:36) this is a reply to message 113,005

MC17 (113,005) by Lainsky from Philippines I feel the same way, Giovanni, I prefer "Caution" over "HFIA". I've been dreaming about an album where Mariah Carey returns to her beginnings. I envision a sound reminiscent of her earlier work, similar to her first albums up to "Daydream". It would have a pop vibe with a touch of R&B, featuring elements like those found in "Fantasy" or "Dreamlover", as well as "Love Takes Time" or "Without You", and songs akin to "Underneath the Stars" or "Can't Let Go" Additionally, it would be great to hear another remake or duet, which has become a tradition on her albums. I hope she titles the album something like "Nostalgia", "Old School", "Back Then", or "Classic", something that fits the overall theme. (Wednesday 14 January 2026; 05:37)

MORE MESSAGES