new message login create account edit account

Name: BFF
Country: United States
Hero live MSG 2022 (101,853) by BFF from United States
(Friday 16 December 2022; 15:15)
In the late 1990s, she used to talk about how she liked singing "Hero" live because it was easy for her to sing and because she could mix things up. Watching that clip makes it clear that something is really wrong.

Has she rehearsed or prepared her voice at all? Part of me wishes she had not ended her Vegas residency, those shows were not perfect but having that obligation in place ensured that she had to put at least some effort into preparing. I get that the pandemic contributed some to this, but plenty of other artists started doing shows again much sooner than Mariah.
4 likes reply
This is a reply to message 101,849 by Bill from the UK
(Friday 16 December 2022; 11:51)
Toronto shows (101,812) by BFF from United States
(Tuesday 13 December 2022; 13:04)
I agree with Terna, Bill and others who are putting forth honest assessments and critiques of Mariah's performances. It is not hateful or demeaning to point out what is objectively true: Mariah is not training/exercising her voice. She is not taking care of her physical health. She is relying heavily on pre-recorded tracks and altering those tracks from time to time to disguise the lip syncing.

We do not need to be in the audience at these shows to know what's going on. Many of us have been following her for years and know all of the tricks she has used to disguise the lip syncing since the late 1990s... back when she did it more sparingly.

Mariah needs honest people in her circle to tell her the truth. Sometimes the kindest thing someone can do is to tell the truth rather than to go along with the charade.
11 likes reply
This is a reply to message 101,808 by Terna from Nigeria
(Tuesday 13 December 2022; 10:45)
Toronto shows (101,803) by BFF from United States
(Tuesday 13 December 2022; 03:00)
It really makes me sad that their duet was pre-recorded. "Away In a Manger" is not a difficult song to sing, and it feels so wrong to have Monroe in on the pre-recording grift.
3 likes reply
This is a reply to message 101,789 by Bill from the UK
(Monday 12 December 2022; 15:24)
Toronto shows (101,793) by BFF from United States
(Monday 12 December 2022; 17:38)
I think Mariah should take personal responsibility like Linda Ronstadt did and retire from live performing. Ronstadt stopped performing in the late 2000s because she was uncomfortable charging people money to see performances in which she was basically just shouting. Linda Ronstadt has a degenerative condition - progressive supranuclear palsy - that rendered her unable to sing.

As far as we know, Mariah has no such condition and just chooses not to train and exercise her voice and take care of her physical health the way she needs to. The constant lip syncing, the altering of prerecorded tracks to disguise lip syncing, the shout-singing, the mediocre vocal performances are impossible to ignore and are really disrespectful to the people who pay good money for the shows. This would be okay with Janet Jackson, Madonna, Britney Spears, et cetera who are mostly about choreography, but it's not okay for someone known for singing.
8 likes reply
This is a reply to message 101,782 by Terna from Nigeria
(Sunday 11 December 2022; 15:46)
Mariah on Colbert (101,765) by BFF from United States
(Friday 9 December 2022; 19:38)
I thought it was great. Her vocals were great, and I could tell she did not pre-record them. They sounded like Daydream era. And she sounded so witty and articulate talking about being mixed, dah-ling. She looked like a skinny legend. I love hearing her tell the same stories over and over, and how dare anyone on this board criticize her for it.

I cannot wait to hear the pre-recorded tracks she's using for her Christmas shows and cannot wait for the repeated breaks for tea, champagne, wardrobe changes, and hair and makeup.
9 likes reply
This is a reply to message 101,752 by Randy from USA
(Thursday 8 December 2022; 06:21)
Charmbracelet - 20 years (101,730) by BFF from United States
(Sunday 4 December 2022; 15:53)
I remember thinking that Mariah looked great, happy and healthy during 2003, especially during the tour. I found the album itself pretty underwhelming because I felt Mariah's singing on it was too restrained. The production and lyrics on most of the songs were really good, but I couldn't understand why Mariah did not let loose on every song the way she did on "Bringin' on the Heartbreak". I remember the Rolling Stone review of the album commenting that the Def Leppard cover was the best moment on the album and kind of agreeing with that.
3 likes reply
This is a reply to message 101,727 by Randy from USA
(Saturday 3 December 2022; 23:26)
QOC (101,713) by BFF from United States
(Wednesday 30 November 2022; 22:33)
Bill, I'd like to remind you that pointing out anything that is unflattering to Mariah is insulting and demeaning. All posts must be reviewed by Mariah's team of expert sycophants to determine if it's flattering to Mariah. If it's flattering, we will allow it to move forward as "facts". If it's not flattering, the information cannot be mentioned.
5 likes reply
This is a reply to message 101,709 by Bill from the UK
(Wednesday 30 November 2022; 14:28)
Article: Drama with Donna Summer (101,687) by BFF from United States
(Sunday 27 November 2022; 14:29)
Unfortunately, that kind of behavior tracks. If true, Mariah had a lot of nerve to come at Donna Summer like that. On a more positive note, Donna Summer sounded great singing "Reflections" on that show. Too bad she got pushed out of the Supremes medley portion, though she probably would have out sang both Mariah and Diana.
3 likes reply go to article
This is a reply to message 101,683 by Jimmie from USA
(Saturday 26 November 2022; 16:45)
Irene Cara (101,685) by BFF from United States
(Saturday 26 November 2022; 21:27)
I know, right? I love Irene Cara and think it's unfortunate she never had any big hit albums. Most of her musical success came with songs she recorded for soundtracks.
4 likes reply
This is a reply to message 101,684 by Terna from Nigeria
(Saturday 26 November 2022; 18:17)
Macy's performance (101,678) by BFF from United States
(Friday 25 November 2022; 21:25)
Bill, she's on "vocal rest" in preparation for the pre-recording of tracks to lip sync to for her "Merry Christmas to All" shows. You're being so unfair.
4 likes reply
This is a reply to message 101,673 by Bill from the UK
(Friday 25 November 2022; 15:19)
Macy's performance (101,672) by BFF from United States
(Friday 25 November 2022; 13:57)
Randy, I have no idea what you're talking about. Mariah lip syncs? That absolutely never happens. She's just performing the "album version" like she did with "We Belong Together" on NYE 2016. I thought everyone loved the album version? Why would you ever expect Mariah to sing live any way? The cold outdoor air hurts her vocal cords and she can't hear herself with the crowds. As a medical expert in the field of vocal chord trauma, I recommend that Mariah complete all performances from home via Zoom call in a room full of humidifiers with a full team of sound engineers. We must also allow for 30 minute breaks every two songs for tea, makeup and wardrobe changes.
10 likes reply
This is a reply to message 101,669 by Randy from USA
(Friday 25 November 2022; 04:21)
QOC (101,649) by BFF from United States
(Thursday 17 November 2022; 22:19)
I don't understand why Mariah insists upon doing tacky stuff like this. It makes her look incredibly narcissistic, selfish, and vain. I wish she would just stick to the holiday music, performances, movies, books et cetera.
14 likes reply
This is a reply to message 101,641 by Edward from USA
(Wednesday 16 November 2022; 16:34)
In honor of "It's Time" (101,632) by BFF from United States
(Sunday 13 November 2022; 22:34)
10 Favorite Mariah Holiday recordings (not ranked)

1. When Christmas Comes
2. O Holy Night
3. God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen
4. Joy to the World (Celebration Mix)
5. All I Want for Christmas is You (1994 Original)
6. Jesus, Oh What a Wonderful Child
7. Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)
8. Jesus Born on this Day
9. Miss You Most (At Christmas Time)
10. Santa Claus is Comin' to Town

10 Great non-Mariah Holiday recordings:

1. Please Come Home for Christmas - Charles Brown
2. Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree - Brenda Lee
3. Someday at Christmas - Stevie Wonder
4. Last Christmas - Wham
5. The Christmas Song - Nat King Cole
6. Christmas (Baby Please Come Home) - Darlene Love
7. Don't Save It All for Christmas Day - Celine Dion
8. Run Rudolph Run - Chuck Berry
9. Feliz Navidad - Jose Feliciano
10. Winter Wonderland - Aretha Franklin

Honorable Mention: Where Are You Christmas? - Faith Hill. I imagine Mariah singing it and get very mad at Sony and Tommy Mottola re: Mariah's version not being the one in that film.
4 likes reply
Alternative playlist (no #1's or #2's) edition (101,586) by BFF from United States
(Wednesday 2 November 2022; 15:52)
1. Fly Away (Butterfly Reprise) [Def B' Fly Mix]
2. If It's Over
3. Anytime You Need a Friend
4. Underneath the Stars [Drifting Remix]
5. Never too Far
6. Right to Dream
7. Meteorite
8. Do You Know Where You're Going To?
9. Loverboy [Firecracker Version]
10. When I Feel It
8 likes reply
This is a reply to message 101,564 by Matty from Vancouver Canada
(Thursday 27 October 2022; 21:55)
Concert in Saudi Arabia (101,563) by BFF from United States
(Thursday 27 October 2022; 19:54)
What are you talking about? Mariah cares *deeply* about women's rights. She's woman and it's her civil right to sing poorly for dictator cash.
2 likes reply
This is a reply to message 101,553 by TJ from Norway
(Wednesday 26 October 2022; 22:35)
Concert in Saudi Arabia (101,543) by BFF from United States
(Tuesday 25 October 2022; 16:49)
What are you talking about? "Vision of Love" sounds just as good as it did in 1990. There's nothing wrong with Mariah's voice. She sounds amazing. Yas queen.
6 likes reply
This is a reply to message 101,518 by Randy from USA
(Sunday 23 October 2022; 14:05)
Re: Just another Side Effects (101,396) (101,398) by BFF from United States
(Tuesday 4 October 2022; 19:33)
I remember that. I love Joni Mitchell, and I actually really like a lot of the songs on "Misses".
2 likes reply
Re: Just another Side Effects (101,394) (101,395) by BFF from United States
(Tuesday 4 October 2022; 15:43)
What about "Triumphlop"? Or Mariah's best music video of all-time "I Don't"?

I think Mariah should release a compilation album called "Greatest Flops" just for us fans.
5 likes reply
Re: The Pitchfork lists (101,384) (101,386) by BFF from United States
(Sunday 2 October 2022; 21:44)
It's not bitterness as much as it is skepticism. Pitchfork didn't even bother to review a Mariah Carey album until 2014 when "Me I Am Mariah" was released. The publication didn't pay much attention to any genre other than indie rock during the 1990s and 2000s and has always had an elitist Brooklyn hipster vibe. So my question is "Why now?" after years of ignoring Mariah and other artists deemed "not cool enough".
3 likes reply
The Pitchfork lists (101,381) by BFF from United States
(Saturday 1 October 2022; 15:09)
I'm glad to see Mariah getting some love, but, to me, it feels a little forced at this point. I mean, how many years did most of us on here spend loving Mariah when it wasn't cool? How many of us went out on 9/11 to buy the "Glitter" album because we knew there would be some gems on there? And do we really need Johnny come lately hipsters to tell us how great of an album "Butterfly" is?

And as much as I love "Fantasy" with ODB and "Always Be My Baby", Mariah has far better songs in her catalogue. I honestly think the ODB collaboration is a bit overrated and that songs like "Breakdown", "Crybaby", and the "My All" So So Def Remix are better examples of Mariah's genius integration of hip-hop into her style.
10 likes reply
Re: Global Citizen (101,323) (101,343) by BFF from United States
(Tuesday 27 September 2022; 03:01)
I'm going to try and be as positive as possible about the performance. The dress looked nice. The Metallica joke was funny. Her pre-recorded tracks sounded good.
3 likes reply
Re: Global Citizen (101,293) (101,300) by BFF from United States
(Friday 23 September 2022; 15:23)
Songs she should not perform:
1. Shake it Off
2. Touch My Body
3. Obsessed
4. I Know What You Want

Songs I'd like her to perform:
1. Fly Away (Butterfly Reprise)
2. Honey
3. Make it Happen
4. Vision of Love
4 likes reply
Re: Another taste of honey (101,266) (101,276) by BFF from United States
(Tuesday 20 September 2022; 16:34)
Yeah, how do you call a 6-minute interview a documentary? I don't think fans found out much about the video that we didn't already know.
5 likes reply
Re: My All (101,258) (101,263) by BFF from United States
(Sunday 18 September 2022; 23:55)
Agreed. I remember listening to most of those #1 songs from 1998 over and over and over. I know R. Kelly is an unsavory character, but I quite liked that Celine/R. Kelly duet. My grandma really liked Celine Dion, so thinking of that song reminds me of her. "The Boy Is Mine" was also a huge favorite. And that song "Too Close" was super catchy but incredibly inappropriate for me to be listening to when I was 10 lol.
4 likes reply
Re: If Butterfly single was released (101,240) (101,244) by BFF from United States
(Saturday 17 September 2022; 15:03)
I think it could have had a chance at #1 if they timed the commercial release correctly. It was getting quite a bit of airplay for a song without an official release. The Elton John single was #1 mostly based on single sales. "Butterfly" may have only gone to #2, but I still think it should have been released. It is one of her best ballads, and "Fly Away (Butterfly Reprise)" is excellent and adds a whole different dimension to the song.
7 likes reply
1 2 3 4 5 6
© The Mariah Carey Archives 1998 - 2024