Messageboard | The Mariah Carey Archives

Only registrated members can post messages. Registration is free.

About karel from belgie:

Mariah Carey: why I miss the artist she used to be (114,763) by karel from belgie

I was a Mariah Carey fan for what many would call the "Classic Mariah" era. When I think of Mariah Carey, I don't immediately think of Christmas. I don't think of tabloid headlines. I don't think of viral memes, diva moments, or the annual return of All I Want for Christmas Is You. I think of Hero. I think of Dreamlover. I think of Fantasy. I think of Always Be My Baby. I think of Anytime You Need a Friend. Even the B-sides or the rarities. Those songs represent the Mariah Carey I fell in love with as an artist. Not because they were perfect, but because they reflected a rare combination of talent, authenticity, elegance, and accessibility. Looking back, one of the most remarkable things about Mariah's early career was how naturally everything seemed to fit together. The voice was extraordinary, but it never felt like she needed to constantly remind people of that fact. The image was attractive, but it never felt like the image was the product. People often talk about how Tommy Mottola supposedly prevented Mariah from expressing her sexuality. I have always felt that discussion misses an important point. Mariah had already proven she could be sexy. The difference was that she was also classy. Look at Dreamlover. She spends much of the video wearing a plaid flannel shirt and denim shorts. It sounds incredibly ordinary on paper, yet she radiates charm and confidence. Look at Always Be My Baby. To this day, I consider it one of the most effortlessly attractive music videos ever made. She is barefoot on a tire swing above a pond, running her fingers through the water, wearing fitted jeans and a casually unbuttoned blue shirt. There is nothing provocative about it, yet everything about it feels authentic and appealing. That was Mariah's gift. She never needed to try too hard. Even songs like Fantasy, Anytime You Need a Friend, I Still Believe, and All I Want for Christmas Is You projected the same energy. These were upbeat, positive, feel-good songs, but they were never cheap. She looked beautiful without looking manufactured. Attractive without appearing desperate for attention. Most importantly, the music remained the focus. Then something changed. I understand why many fans celebrate Mariah's post-1997 liberation. I understand why people see it as her finally taking control of her own image and career. There is certainly truth in that. But as someone who loved Classic Mariah, I can't help feeling that something valuable was lost in the process. For me, Loverboy was the turning point. Ironically, I actually like the original Firecracker version. It is festive, upbeat, and feel-good track from that period. The remix, however, represents much of what started to frustrate me. Too many guest artists. Too much focus on attitude. Too much emphasis on creating a trend rather than creating a timeless record. Even lyrically, it felt like a step backwards. Compare Loverboy to Hero. Compare it to Always Be My Baby. Compare it to Anytime You Need a Friend. The difference is impossible to ignore. The songs that once balanced commercial appeal with emotional depth were increasingly replaced by music that felt more disposable. The image evolved as well. Again, my criticism has never been that Mariah became sexier. She had always been sexy. My criticism is that the elegance gradually disappeared. The Mariah who once stood performing Hero in a simple black dress increasingly gave way to an image that felt less timeless and more tied to the excesses of its era. Whether that was bandanas, ultra-revealing outfits, or increasingly image-driven videos, I found myself paying more attention to the presentation and less to the music. And I don't believe I was alone. One uncomfortable truth that many fans refuse to acknowledge is that a significant number of casual listeners gradually developed a negative perception of Mariah during those years. Not because of her talent, but because the image often overshadowed it. As a result, one of the most gifted vocalists of her generation was increasingly judged through a lens that had very little to do with her actual abilities. Then came 2005. And to her immense credit, Mariah delivered one of the greatest comeback albums in pop history. The Emancipation of Mimi reminded the world that she was still capable of great songs. The lyrics improved. The songwriting improved. The balance between glamour and artistry improved. For a moment, it felt as though she had rediscovered part of what made her special. But even then, I never felt that the effortless elegance of the early years fully returned. At the same time, her voice was beginning to change. That is not a criticism. Every singer ages. The problem was that the conversation increasingly shifted from celebrating her voice to questioning it. Live performances became less consistent. The woman who once seemed capable of anything vocally now appeared to be in an ongoing battle with the expectations created by her own legendary standards. I remained a fan for many years. But somewhere around 2016, I realised something uncomfortable. I was no longer a fan of the current Mariah Carey. I was a fan of the Mariah Carey I remembered. The artist I admired was the one who recorded Hero. The one who sang Anytime You Need a Friend. The one who created the magical optimism of Fantasy and the emotional maturity of Always Be My Baby. Today, what saddens me most is not that Mariah Carey changed. Every artist changes. What saddens me is how much of her legacy has been reduced. Every December, the world celebrates All I Want for Christmas Is You. It is an incredible achievement and one she absolutely deserves. But I sometimes wonder whether newer generations realize who she was before that song became a cultural phenomenon. Mariah Carey should not primarily be remembered as "the Christmas lady." She should be remembered as one of the greatest vocalists in popular music history. She should be remembered for redefining vocal standards in pop music. She should be remembered for Vision of Love, Hero, Fantasy, Dreamlover, Always Be My Baby, Anytime You Need a Friend, and dozens of other songs that showcased extraordinary talent, songwriting, and emotional intelligence. Perhaps that is why I still revisit the Classic Mariah era so often. Not because I am trapped in nostalgia. But because that era reminds me of an artist who achieved something extraordinarily difficult: she made elegance seem effortless, sexiness seem natural, and greatness seem completely normal. And for a while, nobody did it better.
(Sunday 25 October 2026; 20:30)

Clown vs. Obsessed (114,538) by karel from belgie

"Clown" is for me, together with "Bringin' on the heartbreak" and "Boy (I need you)" the best songs on Charmbracelet. The guilty pleasure is "You got me".
(Tuesday 8 September 2026; 20:55)


this is a reply to message		114,537

Clown vs. Obsessed (114,532) by karel from belgie

Clown and Obsessed may both deal with a man whom Mariah believes has an inflated sense of himself and uses her name for attention, but the way she approaches that subject in each song is completely different.

In Clown, she takes a more psychological approach. Rather than launching a direct attack, she tries to understand why this person behaves the way he does, suggesting that his arrogance is really a cover for insecurity. The title itself is telling. She doesn't portray him as an enemy, but as a clown, someone who ultimately makes a fool of himself.

One of the things I love about the song is how she exposes him without ever sounding bitter or vindictive. She paints a picture of someone trying hard to appear important and intimidating, while making it clear that she sees right through the act. As a result, the song feels mature, intelligent, and quietly devastating. She doesn't sound angry. She sounds disappointed and mildly amused, which makes the criticism hit even harder.

Obsessed, on the other hand, takes the exact opposite approach. The entire song revolves around the idea that this person is supposedly obsessed with her. The hook repeats that message over and over, and the mockery is much more obvious. Where Clown allows the listener to draw their own conclusions, Obsessed practically spells everything out for them.

Musically, the contrast is just as striking. Clown is built around a smooth, understated R&B production that leaves plenty of room for the lyrics and the vocals. The focus is on what she's saying. Obsessed shifts the attention toward the beat, the catchy chorus, and the playful attitude. It's constructed as a major pop single, whereas Clown feels more like a personal statement.

What I find particularly interesting is how much Clown relies on irony. Mariah never has to outright tell the listener that this man is pathetic. You figure that out on your own through the way she describes him. In Obsessed, the judgment is much more direct and explicit. Because of that, the songwriting feels less sophisticated and more like a reaction in the heat of the moment.

Even vocally, the difference is significant. On Clown, Mariah uses a warm, controlled, and mature vocal performance. She sounds confident because she has nothing to prove. On Obsessed, the vocals become part of the attitude and humor of the track. The production effects and heavily processed sound fit the song's playful tone, but they also distract from what was once her greatest strength: her ability to carry a song through pure vocal expression.

"Clown" is Mariah dissecting her opponent with subtlety, observation, and intelligence. "Obsessed" is Mariah publicly mocking that same opponent through a catchy pop hit.

Or, to put it even more bluntly: "Clown" lets the listener discover why the man is a clown. "Obsessed" simply shouts it from the rooftops. And that's why I believe Clown is the stronger and more timeless song.
(Monday 7 September 2026; 23:14)

Daydream (114,531) by karel from belgie

For me, Daydream will always be the best album Mariah Carey has ever made. At that point, her voice was simply phenomenal: powerful, crystal-clear, velvety smooth, and at the same time incredibly fresh. Track after track, she sounded like she was at the absolute peak of her abilities.

Fantasy was the first Mariah song that I later realized was actually hers. I was thirteen years old at the time. Now, 31 years later, I still think it's a fantastic song. Always Be My Baby comes in at a very close second for me.

For many fans, Butterfly is Mariah's magnum opus, but for me, Daydream is the true masterpiece. Butterfly deserves all the praise it gets for its artistic freedom and personal growth, but vocally, Daydream stands on a higher level. On Daydream, you hear a singer who can do it all: the power, the agility, the range, the emotion, and that effortless clarity that very few artists have ever possessed. Butterfly may be the more personal and mature record, but the pure vocal magic of Daydream was never quite matched again.

In addition, Daydream strikes the perfect balance between pop, R&B, and adult contemporary ballads. The album feels timeless and contains virtually no weak moments. While Butterfly is often admired for its artistic significance, Daydream still moves me more as a listener.

The album also closes with one of Mariah's most personal and powerful songs, Looking In. In that song, she essentially describes herself as a caged bird in a golden cage, while making it clear that there is far more to her than the public image people see. Ironically, the song almost feels like a prelude to Butterfly, the album on which she finally spreads her wings.

Don't get me wrong: Butterfly is an excellent album. But if I have to choose between Mariah Carey at her artistic turning point and Mariah Carey at her absolute vocal peak, I will choose Daydream every single time. It was also the era when she still had that natural "girl next door" appeal. Starting with Butterfly, the diva image gradually became more prominent. And however you look at it, she already possessed extraordinary class, charisma, and talent without all the extra glamour.
(Monday 7 September 2026; 23:01)

New music (114,530) by karel from belgie

I think Mariah needs to move away from the predictable, slow R&B sound. Some of her best tracks have always been the house and techno remixes, so why keep those styles limited to remixes? Why not make them the main versions of the songs?

I'm currently listening to We Found Love by Rihanna and Calvin Harris, and honestly, I think Mariah could still pull off that kind of uplifting dance music. Her voice would work beautifully with that style.

It also reminds me of Now That I Know from Music Box. That song was such a breath of fresh air and showed a different, more playful side of her artistry.

And yes, I'm absolutely in favor of her finally releasing Someone's Ugly Daughter. That's the Mariah I miss: creative, adventurous, and willing to take risks. It's a shame she didn't release it alongside the Daydream anniversary celebrations. Imagine getting it as part of a Daydream 31 edition. Now that would have been something special.
(Monday 7 September 2026; 22:49)