Messageboard

About Edward from USA:

Much ado about nothing (107,173) by Edward from USA Mariah is clearly relying on lip-syncing to pre-recorded tracks quite a bit. She might sing a few words live here and there, but the lipping is at an all-time high. When you compare footage from different shows, the only thing that changes are her spoken or talk-sung parts; everything else seems to be pre-recorded. Additionally, she frequently appears a dazed, whatever medication she's on seems to be affecting her movement, speech, and even the parts she sings live. I'm not criticizing her; she needs to take her meds to manage her bipolar disorder, but it's evident that she's on some strong stuff. (Saturday 10 August 2024; 16:50) this is a reply to message 107,171

Much ado about nothing (107,171) by Scott from USA I'm a little confused about the comments here in this one. Yes, she looks a little stunned at times (has for a while). But at the same time that fans are saying she seems to have no idea walking around the stage and trouble with the cues she's also not had trouble singing the lyrics on time? I might be wrong, but haven't seen her looking like she's lip syncing. So my point is, I for one think she's singing a lot more love than people on this board make out and if she can do that, things can't be that bad. Also, if she is lip syncing, things can't be that bad with her if she's at least getting that right. (Saturday 10 August 2024; 12:49)

The girl who lipped wolf (107,120) by Edward from USA Celine has never jumped on any trend wagon. Stating facts is not idolizing her. She has managed to maintain a likable image ever since she entered the music scene by being herself. She hasn't shied away from showing us her human side, making her relatable. I consider myself part of Mariah's core fanbase, but I'm realistic. If Mariah were more dynamic on stage and did more than just stand there and lip-sync, people wouldn't mind as much whether she's singing live. It was acceptable when she could still carry a tune, but now she should compensate for her vocal limitations by putting more effort into her performances and updating her tired productions. She should drop those male dancers and revitalize her shows. (Tuesday 6 August 2024; 03:43) this is a reply to message 107,111

The girl who lipped wolf (107,111) by Alexis Carrington-Colby from United States Let's not go overboard with the sudden Celine worship. She has always been ripped apart for her artistry and seen as the lest cool of the divas up until she became a fashion icon. Why do you all make it seem like Mariah was obsessed with #1 hits? Which popular artist isn't keeping an eye on the charts? Celine was chart watching just all of them were in their prime. (Monday 5 August 2024; 03:35)

Merry Christmas anniversary want list (107,118) by Edward from USA Wait a minute, did Normani finally release her debut album? If she did and it flopped, it shouldn't surprise anyone. She took a long time. (Monday 5 August 2024; 20:02) this is a reply to message 107,116

Merry Christmas anniversary want list (107,116) by Bobby A from United States Okay, but Cher announced her Christmas in early September. I always refer to Metacritic's new album list for each month. Billboard just released their new album list for August-October. There is not one Christmas album listed for October. At least there would be somebody major on the list for October. Maybe no one wants to release a Christmas album this year because so many albums flopped from Dua Lipa to Normani to Camila Cabello. I think MC has Christmas this year without any distractions like what happened with Brenda Lee. (Monday 5 August 2024; 12:37)

The girl who lipped wolf (107,109) by Edward from USA Celine was smart, she never focused too much on achieving number-one hits, yet she managed to earn widespread respect. She has always been consistent, endearing herself to fans and the general public alike. Like Barbra, she has maintained a loyal core fanbase that she can always rely on. Although she doesn't sell as many albums as she once did, she continues to sell concert tickets, and they are certainly not cheap. One thing about Celine is that she's a true performer and entertainer; she never just stands there, and she can walk without help. (Monday 5 August 2024; 02:09) this is a reply to message 107,101

The girl who lipped wolf (107,101) by Bobby A from United States I wonder if MC and Celine both are in the top ten for top grossing Vegas residencies. (Sunday 4 August 2024; 19:01)

How I became a fan (107,079) by Edward from USA When "Daydream" was released I was a toddler. My mom used to play "Open Arms" to me when I couldn't sleep, that's how I became a fan. About five years later, when I was being a lil a*hole, my mom would punish me by playing "Did I Do That" repeatedly until I apologize. By the time JD started inserting himself on every track, and knowing I wouldn't have survived him on repeat, I became a lovely child. When I write my memoir, I'm considering calling my mother by her first name. (Friday 2 August 2024; 05:04)

Can't Let Go (107,075) by Edward from USA The fact that we're all here means we can't let go of her. At least we're becoming more realistic. As I've stated before, I don't expect Mariah to sing like she did in the 90s, but I would love some consistency, that's all. Her songwriting is half of the equation, and she can certainly deliver on that part if she wants to. I was listening to "Portrait" the other day, and for some reason, the song hits differently now. It's definitely "Looking In" part two. (Thursday 1 August 2024; 21:36)

Merry Christmas (107,068) by Edward from USA "Merry Christmas" is turning 30 this year. She should go all out with something special, especially since "All I Want for Christmas Is You" seems to have lost some of its initial momentum while other holiday songs have gained popularity. She shouldn't rest on her laurels, particularly during the season that brings her the most redvenue. I don't know about you, but I feel a bit neglected. What's the point of keeping her core fanbase in limbo? It doesn't make sense to me. She could have released a 6-track EP without worrying about high sales. With today's technology, she doesn't even need a record label. CDs can be produced on demand now. (Thursday 1 August 2024; 01:28)

MC16 (107,064) by Edward from USA I think she'll release a few more "Rarities-type" albums, but I don't expect her to release any new studio albums after MC16. Even though Caution was critically acclaimed, she mentioned that her voice wasn't in good shape during its recording. If it wasn't in good shape then, what about now? I would be fine with MC16 being her final album. She shouldn't count on it being a huge success in terms of sales though, Caution was released six years ago and has sold around 200k copies. (Wednesday 31 July 2024; 22:06)

Back to Mariah (107,057) by Edward from USA Do you guys think MC16 will Mariah's final album, and how would you feel if it were? (Wednesday 31 July 2024; 14:16)

Stacey (107,041) by Edward from USA It baffles me how some people throw around the word "transphobic" without cause. The term has lost its true meaning. I don't think Stacey would be scared or disrespectful to a transgender person just because they are transgender. It's ridiculous, and it's why our community has become a joke. Things have gotten so bad that if a gay man doesn't want to have sex with a trans man, he's labeled transphobic, as if we're supposed to ignore our sexual orientation to please a few. Lesbians have it even worse; some have been kicked out of lesbian dating apps for stating they're only interested in vaginas, not penises. Tell me you're in a cult without telling you're in a cult. (Tuesday 30 July 2024; 21:43)

Mariah, Anita Baker and Lauryn Hill (107,024) by Edward from USA She thought she would have a huge tax break so she started popping out kids as if they were popcorn. By the time baby #6 was born, she realized her math wasn't mathin and she ended up owing $1.8 million in back taxes. She thought another baby would save her, but Nick Cannon made change her mind. Later she moved to Indiana and now shows up late to all her shows. (Monday 29 July 2024; 21:25) this is a reply to message 107,023

Mariah, Anita Baker and Lauryn Hill (107,023) by BFF from United States Lauryn isn't late. She's just waiting "until the energy is right". That's also why she has only released one studio album. The energy just hasn't been right since 1998. That's also why she didn't pay $1.8 million in taxes between 2005 and 2007. The IRS' energy just wasn't right. (Monday 29 July 2024; 20:32)

Celine, Mariah and lip synching (107,008) by Edward from USA She's never going to do that as long as she's milking the cow because she would have to admit to the gimmicks and incessant lipping. I was telling Randy the other day that I miss the old Mariah, the passionate one. She was so adorable when she was humble. But somewhere along the way, she lost herself in her diva persona, which alienated much of her fanbase too. (Sunday 28 July 2024; 22:18) this is a reply to message 107,006

Celine, Mariah and lip synching (107,006) by Jamie from UK As long as Mariah is putting out music and standing on that stage she owes everyone everything. If she isn't bothered then go and live off your back catalogue. But she is still putting herself out there, so she should be giving 100%. Celine has children also and I don't see her giving half hearted performances. When Mariah came on to the scene she was so passionate, would screw her face up on stage as long as she hit those notes and didn't care what she looked like. Now it's a case of if I look good nothing else matters. As I've said in previous posts she changed personality from 2001 and it's progressively got worse. Now I don't think even Mariah knows who she is. She needs to strip it all back get to know herself again, drop the diva act and concentrate on being an artist with passion again. And if she can't do that then step down and stop taking peoples money. Celine this weekend has proven she is a true artist, her craft is so important to her and she works at it to ensure it never falters. I don't listen to Think Twice and think where is that woman now I miss her. But I do when I listen to say Can't Let Go and that is sad. I never ever thought I would be saying these things ever. Mariah was phenomenal her voice and her whole persona was intoxicating. And as a dedicated fan I want to know what happened and I know I'm not the only one. (Sunday 28 July 2024; 21:18)

Celine, Mariah and lip synching (107,007) by Edward from USA Dear Jamie, I hope you didn't take my post seriously. I was just playing the role of a blindly devoted dumb yass queen fan. Those are some of the ridiculous excuses that some people like to post here. We're supposed support Mariah and her with our coins and not have a say because she is Mariah Carey. The fact that she doesn't even seem to care is disrespectful to those of us who have been there with her through thick and thin. (Sunday 28 July 2024; 21:57) this is a reply to message 107,006

Celine, Mariah and lip synching (107,006) by Jamie from UK As long as Mariah is putting out music and standing on that stage she owes everyone everything. If she isn't bothered then go and live off your back catalogue. But she is still putting herself out there, so she should be giving 100%. Celine has children also and I don't see her giving half hearted performances. When Mariah came on to the scene she was so passionate, would screw her face up on stage as long as she hit those notes and didn't care what she looked like. Now it's a case of if I look good nothing else matters. As I've said in previous posts she changed personality from 2001 and it's progressively got worse. Now I don't think even Mariah knows who she is. She needs to strip it all back get to know herself again, drop the diva act and concentrate on being an artist with passion again. And if she can't do that then step down and stop taking peoples money. Celine this weekend has proven she is a true artist, her craft is so important to her and she works at it to ensure it never falters. I don't listen to Think Twice and think where is that woman now I miss her. But I do when I listen to say Can't Let Go and that is sad. I never ever thought I would be saying these things ever. Mariah was phenomenal her voice and her whole persona was intoxicating. And as a dedicated fan I want to know what happened and I know I'm not the only one. (Sunday 28 July 2024; 21:18)

Celine, Mariah and lip synching (107,004) by Edward from USA Mariah doesn't owe anyone anything. If she chooses to stand there and lip-sync poorly, it's up to her devoted fans if they want to pay for it and pretend she's singing. She has two young children who need her full attention, and she doesn't have time for extensive rehearsals. Caring for her babies is demanding, so don't be so judgmental. It's clear she doesn't care much, so why should you? She wants her money now, and there's nothing wrong with that. Has it occurred to you that maybe Mariah is just preserving her voice so she can still hum when she's 58? As real fans, you should buy multiple tickets and celebrate her now that she can at least still walk on stage and smile. Leave your negativity at the door, please. (Sunday 28 July 2024; 18:59) this is a reply to message 107,001

Celine, Mariah and lip synching (107,001) by BFF from United States I was looking at some videos from the last few nights in Vegas as well. Mariah's lip-syncing is pretty shameless in them. If she's going to do it, she definitely needs to practice making it look more convincing. Her lips are barely moving in some of the songs. Is there any segment of this show in which she is singing live? What a sad spectacle. (Sunday 28 July 2024; 16:05)

Celine (106,997) by Edward from USA I was in tears, to be honest. It was a true return to form - almost miraculous considering what she's been through with that awful syndrome. She has maintained a loyal fanbase, just like Barbra. She might not sell as many records, but her concerts are always sold out. She's earned that respect. (Sunday 28 July 2024; 02:21) this is a reply to message 106,989

Celine (106,989) by Jamie from UK Having watched her performance again, it is one polished and well executed performance. One thing about Celine is that she has always stayed consistent and true to herself. The Celine of the 1990's is the same Celine now. She is truly respected as an artist and still has her original fan base. I often have trouble relating to Mariah now as it's like she's a completely different person from the 1990's. That's not to say I don't like both but it's why I think she has lost a lot of her fan base and why she's not as respected as much. Celine knows her craft and what her fans want, and isn't at a point in her career where she's having to think of new styles to get peoples attention again as she already has the respect. Obviously Mariah is a different artist with a different personality but I think she could have learnt a lot from how Celine has controlled her career and her reputation. (Saturday 27 July 2024; 22:30)

Celine returned full force (106,996) by Edward from USA Wow, Celine killed it at the Olympics. After everything she's been through, I doubted she would recover, but she returned with an incredibly powerful performance. I'm so happy for her. It's been over a decade since I've seen her sing like that. I only hope Mariah can deliver a similar performance one last time for the world to see. I can't believe it. I'm so happy for her and her fans. (Sunday 28 July 2024; 02:09)

Favorite Rainbow track (106,733) by Edward from USA Robert-Anthony, I am pretty sure if Mariah released a compilation of her farts on vinyl, you would buy it and find different nuances and real background harmonies on them. I admire your devotion for Mariah Carey. (Monday 17 June 2024; 20:39) this is a reply to message 106,732

Favorite Rainbow track (106,732) by Bobby A from United States There For Me (Acapella) does something to me when I listen to it. It belongs on K Love's playlist right now. (Monday 17 June 2024; 17:55)

Rainbow 25 (106,715) by Edward from USA It seems that Mariah had some good vocal days here and there during the recording process of the album "Rainbow". While there are some great vocals on the album, the quality is not consistent throughout. (Saturday 15 June 2024; 23:12) this is a reply to message 106,712

Rainbow 25 (106,712) by Alexis Carrington-Colby from United States AAO and TGIFY were recorded in the same period though. (Saturday 15 June 2024; 22:28)

Rainbow 25 (106,708) by Edward from USA I agree. Unlike her solo versions of "Whenever You Call" and "Against All Odds", Mariah wasn't in her best vocal form during this period, and it shows in these previously unheard vocals. I'm not particularly impressed, but I'm not disappointed either. She has given us some real gems on "The Rarities". (Saturday 15 June 2024; 17:08) this is a reply to message 106,700

Rainbow 25 (106,700) by Lee from UK The Mariah Only TGIFY sounds to me like it was always intended to have featured artists. The new Mariah vocals sound like demo cuts of Mariah indicating what she wants the featured artist to sing. (Saturday 15 June 2024; 12:01)

Remaster who? (106,667) by Edward from USA Ever since digital audio remastering became common, the usual approach has been to simply crank up the volume. In some cases, this remastering process can strip away the original feel that some albums once had. If remastering cleans and improves the audio quality, such as in recordings where static noise is prevalent, I'm all for it. However, if it merely increases the volume, I don't see the point. I'm more excited about the remixes and the possibility of new tracks. (Friday 14 June 2024; 00:36)

Just some Dolly Parton facts (106,611) by Edward from USA I don't know much about Ms. Parton's music, except for "I Will Always Love You" and "9 to 5", but we can all agree she's the true definition of a Southern belle. She's classy, lovely, just the true epitome of an icon. She has never let her looks overshadow her talent; she proudly embraces her style, and even her iconic girls exude ginormous class. I loved her in "Steel Magnolias", one of my favorit movies. The cemetery scene was epic. (Friday 7 June 2024; 17:37) this is a reply to message 106,607

Just some Dolly Parton facts (106,607) by Bobby A from United States Dolly will release album #50 on November 15th. Her last album was released on November 17, 2023. She began her career in 1955. This lady looks like she is 50 years old right now. Dolly does not slow down. Everyone loves Dolly Parton. This last fact really made me laugh. Her own label is called Butterfly Records. How funny is that? (Friday 7 June 2024; 02:03)

Rainbow25 (106,595) by Edward from USA Mariah should release a Rainbow remix everyday during Pride Month. At the end of Pride Month, she should shock us all and release a physical CD containing the best of those 30 remixes bundled up with a Mariah Barbie doll, with the head tilted to the right of course, It would be so epic and festive. Can you imagine if the Rainbow remixes were titled Rainbow Extensions 1, 2, 3 and so on? People would go crazy. It would definitely be her next number one. (Tuesday 4 June 2024; 05:42)

Funk queen (106,588) by Edward from USA They certainly gave Chaka Khan and her iconic big hair a run for her money. Rumor has it that they were all fired and never seen again after that performance. (Monday 3 June 2024; 00:50) this is a reply to message 106,584

Funk queen (106,584) by Terna from Nigeria They killed this song but it seems the backup vocalists ran out of steam a lil bit or not? (Sunday 2 June 2024; 20:57)

The remix (106,484) by Edward from USA I'm not trying to be negative, but the "Made for Me" remix feels pointless. If this is the best studio magic can do, it's disappointing. Now I understand why there hasn't been any new music for such a long time. In a new album, she would need to bring her voice to the forefront in all the tracks, and that’s what’s missing. What happened to her beautiful whistle tones? They were pristine on MIAM. I'm really sad about this. (Thursday 23 May 2024; 00:07)

Article: Mariah spent Mother's Day weekend in Westchester (106,440) by Edward from USA Patricia not staying married to Alfred is Tommy's fault. I thought you knew, it's all part of the Truwoman Show. Everybody knows that. (Sunday 19 May 2024; 13:49) this is a reply to message 106,439

Article: Mariah spent Mother's Day weekend in Westchester (106,439) by Bobby A from United States I wonder, does MC blame her mother for not staying married to her father? She has never written a song about her mother. Alfred Roy had one song written about him and an honorable mention in another song. (Sunday 19 May 2024; 04:25)

MORE MESSAGES