Messageboard

About Robert-Anthony from United States: I have been a Lamb since 1990. I know Mariah. I love her music. I breathe her music.

I Don't (105,678) by Robert-Anthony from United States No way. Not I Don't too? They both sound completely live. Can you post the last time MC performed 100% live on network TV before The Distance in 2019? I am thinking when she performed I'm That Chick on the Victoria's Secret primetime CBS special. Right? (Friday 23 February 2024; 02:12) this is a reply to message 105,676

I Don't (105,676) by Xavier mariohmix from Spain Neither one is fully live. (Friday 23 February 2024; 01:18)

I hope Mariah never releases anything anymore (105,675) by Robert-Anthony from United States I feel really bad now about some of my recent comments. I remember during 2005-2008, I was telling anybody who would let me tell them about a new Mariah Carey song. I would always end the conversation, "That's my girl." I need to get back to doing that. Thank you JC. (Friday 23 February 2024; 00:31) this is a reply to message 105,674

I hope Mariah never releases anything anymore (105,674) by JC from United States This is suppose to be a Mariah fan board, all I've seen is negative uncalled for opinions on Mariah and her voice, you guys think she's a robot? I recently saw a video of twitter spaces, some lamb had the balls to tell Mariah that every time she performs the lambs wonder if she will hit a g7 or how high she will go. Meanwhile this lamb works at Burger King but thinks he knows everything about her voice. I noticed this was her last time on twitter spaces. You guys are ruining this for her, y'all don't know anything about her voice or what's going on, have some respect for the woman who supposedly you say saved your life with her music. I really hope she doesn't release anything new. Why would she? Just for you guys to disect and judge her voice condition. I used to love this board, before all the lambs became vocal teachers. (Thursday 22 February 2024; 23:19)

General public or bad decisions (105,663) by Robert-Anthony from United States Wasn't all of this silly behavior during the MIAM era? MC was not happy during this era. Plus, Crustella was running everything. (Thursday 22 February 2024; 11:18) this is a reply to message 105,660

General public or bad decisions (105,660) by Zachariah from Croatia Her PR. That was the main problem. She was always so nice. I became even bigger fan after 1997. I loved that sound and naughty image. But she kept emphasizing that goody two shoes role instead, for example, calling out Jennifer in an award ceremony for stealing sample for Loverboy. Publicly. Not just shading and whispering. Make a damn scene. Get mad. Not diva mad. Woman mad. Make an angry damn song and spit on everyone. Instead, she had idiotic people around herself spreading rumors that she doesn't walk on carpet, that she wants to be skinny like kids in Africa, being late all the time, demanding puppies in the backstage, being eternally 12 and etc etc. People remember that. And they roll their eyes and move on. (Thursday 22 February 2024; 08:42)

I Don't (105,662) by Robert-Anthony from United States I forgot that she did perform I Don't 100% live. She was having some fun and was happy during this era. (Thursday 22 February 2024; 11:11) this is a reply to message 105,658

I Don't (105,658) by enwar00 from usa I Don't always gets so much hate on this board. It's funny or maybe ironic because that whole era she sang live at ease and sounded fire, and now here we are some handful years later, the nightmare era is just a memory yet we're scared of her singing one verse live on TV. Yikes. (Thursday 22 February 2024; 06:53)

MC remix album (105,652) by Robert-Anthony from United States I love your idea. I know that she has some extra outtakes and vocal stems for most of the songs on the remix album. I would love to see David Morales add some "Stereo Experience" mixes for Dreamlover, Fantasy, and Honey like he did for It's Like That and add new club remixes for the radio remixes like My All/Stay Awhile, Heartbreaker ft. Missy Elliot and Da Brat, and ABMB ft. Xscape. I would love a new Butterfly club remix by Disclosure or Salaam Remi. By the way, why hasn't MC worked with Salaam Remi before? (Thursday 22 February 2024; 00:29) this is a reply to message 105,650

MC remix album (105,650) by jaker20 from US I'm sure this is going to cause a stir here, but I'm here for it. Like a vol 2 of her OG remix album, and add in new ones and new collabs. Mariah's now done 2 remixes and they're both bops, and it seems like an easy releases for her hardly lifting a finger lol, meanwhile her album is taking forever. Don't come at me, it's just an idea. What do you all think? (Wednesday 21 February 2024; 20:16)

I don't understand peoole from this board (105,651) by Robert-Anthony from United States Great post MH. We all want what is best for MC. (Wednesday 21 February 2024; 23:11) this is a reply to message 105,648

I don't understand peoole from this board (105,648) by "MariahHater" from Hell Come on guys. She is doing exposure if she will collaborate with Cardi or whoever mainstream [censored] there is. Why are the lambs so hyper in being critical? Lets learn to accept that we are way past the prime. We can have opinions yeah but most of the time people are dragging her nearer to the grave. So much for being a lamb. She can't give out what we want or desire vocally/personality/artistic choices. We all act like as if we are her mother. She is an old adult let her be. Btw just living for the music. Persona, career wise I don't care now. Ugh. Why is charting even created? Sad that art needs to be capitalized for money vs the real form for its consumption. (Wednesday 21 February 2024; 17:49)

General public or bad decisions (105,636) by Robert-Anthony from United States The respect your response Matty completely. I just feel MC's relationship with Walter A. ended in a very bad way. It has always been this what if in the back of mind. (Wednesday 21 February 2024; 11:30) this is a reply to message 105,626

General public or bad decisions (105,626) by Matty from Vancouver Canada Ohhhh Robert I don't think I've ever disagreed with you on this board, but if MC kept working with Walter, TEOM would never have happened. After Daydream Mariah would have been cemented in the Celine Dion, Barbra Streisand genre. Just like Michael Bubble will forever be in the Frank Sinatra genre. Mariah was lyrically doing art, and vocally doing art during her time with W.A, but I think even though it was amazing, it was commissioned art, not the art for the artist who wanted to express themselves. (Wednesday 21 February 2024; 01:28)

SNL (105,635) by Robert-Anthony from United States I am worried as well. SNL is not a show where viewers accept lipped performances (remember the Ashley Simpson failed backing tracking debacle). The social media will not be too nice the day after. The Distance performed on The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon in 2019 was her last completely live performance. Can MC do it? Maybe with vocal rest and some hot tea and honey. Maybe the Cardi B. collaboration is a summer bop and her team is waiting for June or July to unleash to the world. I hope Cardi B pokes fun at Nikki Minaj by calling Mariah's name in her voice the way Nikki Minaj did in Up Out My Face. I am predicting The-Dream co-wrote the collaboration. I haven't predicted in awhile. Lol. (Wednesday 21 February 2024; 11:25) this is a reply to message 105,633

SNL (105,633) by Shezz from Pk I'm a little worried about how she'll sound (if it is true). It's a lot of strained belting. Let's see how much is going to be live and how much lipped. I hope she puts in the effort to do it justice. Insiders are saying the Cardi collaboration will be her next step - which is bound to get more people mad here. (Wednesday 21 February 2024; 10:37)

Yes, And so close to top 10. Now or never (105,628) by Robert-Anthony from United States My bad. I thought the new charts are released on Tuesday. Is it Wednesday now? This whole thing of calculating chart numbers and the day new charts are released is so confusing to me. Lol. (Wednesday 21 February 2024; 02:16) this is a reply to message 105,621

Yes, And so close to top 10. Now or never (105,621) by jaker20 from US Tracking isn't done yet. That's for prior week. (Wednesday 21 February 2024; 00:57)

General public or bad decisions (105,624) by Robert-Anthony from United States MC lost her magic when she stopped collaborating with Walter A. She might have 26 #1 songs now if the two never stopped collaborating. That was a bad decision she has paid dearly for. (Wednesday 21 February 2024; 01:10) this is a reply to message 105,612

General public or bad decisions (105,612) by Jamie from UK I'm sat here and a thought came into my head regarding Mariah and her career. For the majority of the 1990's Mariah could do no wrong, she was America's sweetheart and had countless number one songs and albums. People took her into their hearts and adored her. From 1997 she made what some call a drastic change in musical direction and lost some of her core fanbase as a result. However she continued to have number one songs and albums even through a difficult time with Sony and Tommy Mottola. Why was it then that during her most difficult time in her life in 2001 did people turn their backs on her? Surely someone who they had grown to love had spent so long adoring her and buying her music would want to support her during this difficult time. Glitter and Charmbracelet failed to sell anywhere near what she would normally sell. My point is, is it the general public who turn on an artist so quickly, is it the music industry and media that set current trends what is a hit and what the people want or is it bad decisions made by Mariah the artist. For me it's just difficult to understand how such a quick switch in popularity can happen with someone who was literally a force of nature at one point. Firstly I don't think the whole Glitter film helped her persona one bit, 9/11 didn't help but the film just wasn't good enough 9/11 or not. The album or soundtrack is great but in hindsight should it have been left on the shelf once the film tanked to help control the damage from the film and save her also having a music flop too which was unheard of at the time. Would her next album then have been more well received by the public. For me I like Charmbracelet but it feels almost like a complete different body of work to the rest of her catalogue (present and past included) the whole vibe is just different. Were bad decisions made by Mariah creatively should she have come back with an upbeat track ala Fantasy/Honey mode and had less rappers on the album, it would be interesting to see if the Glitter album hadn't been released and she had come back with a stronger album (maybe a combination of Glitter tracks and new ones and called it something else) how her popularity would have been at that time and now. Or had the public already turned their backs on her and changed their view of her as a person. Obviously we had Emancipation but that was very short lived, and since then with the exception of Touch My Body and Christmas she hasn't got anywhere near the popularity she should have had. Do you think the general public just doesn't warm to her anymore, is it Mariah's decisions of music creativity or the way her persona has come across post 2001, or do you think it's the music industry making wrong decisions for her career? We can't change what happens but sometimes it's interesting to put a different spin on how we think things could have gone or been. Would love to hear your views and where you think things went wrong or could have been different for her. (Tuesday 20 February 2024; 17:36)

Yes, And so close to top 10. Now or never (105,620) by Robert-Anthony from United States It didn't make the top 10 this week. The original is down to #21. (Wednesday 21 February 2024; 00:35) this is a reply to message 105,613

Yes, And so close to top 10. Now or never (105,613) by jaker20 from US We don't know. It's going to be very very close. The remix should have more points than the original for her to get credit. Both versions together, it is at no.11 and went +49%. Assuming the original dropped like it did last week, then the remix portion of that should be more than 50% already, giving Mariah credit at this point already. There is no way the original went up after the remix is released, unless there is some shady stuff going on behind the scenes. The 3 new remixes released by Ariana's team complicates it slightly, but it's not doing any numbers currently. (Tuesday 20 February 2024; 17:43)

It just occured to me (105,597) by Robert-Anthony from United States It just occurred to me that it was very odd for MC to announce a Vegas resudency in the midst of recording a new album. 90s Mariah would have finished her album, released the first single and then done a residency. Something doesn't seem right after what she has talked about working on for the past 3 years. I am just saying, but what if she doesn't release MC16 this year. The business mind of MC seems to be out of alignment due to something that we are not privy to concerning her voice. Maybe I am wrong and I not really going to be patiently waiting this year. (Tuesday 20 February 2024; 02:30) this is a reply to message 105,592

It just occured to me (105,592) by jaker20 from US "Ariana stans aren't 100% on board with the song itself." I'm referring of course to the Yes, And original version. (Tuesday 20 February 2024; 00:22)

Stacey and Robert (105,586) by Robert-Anthony from United States Okay. As long as you don't take two weeks off. This board would not be same if you left us Edward. Hurry MC. (Monday 19 February 2024; 21:43) this is a reply to message 105,585

Stacey and Robert (105,585) by Edward from USA It's just little break. I'm not leaving board. (Monday 19 February 2024; 21:35)

Herd mentality (105,583) by Robert-Anthony from United States Don't leave Edward. We need you here. You have always supported me when the bully attacked me. (Monday 19 February 2024; 21:07) this is a reply to message 105,576

Herd mentality (105,576) by Edward from USA I do not follow the herd mentality. It's perfectly fine if 99 percent of people love the "Yes, And?" remix. I've always advocated for people expressing their opinions here, even if they differ from my own. I will respectfully express my views, even if they diverge from the prevailing consensus. I think it's time for me to take a break from this board. Peace to all. (Monday 19 February 2024; 17:29)

Writing (105,578) by Robert-Anthony from United States I would for MC to form a new R&B girl group that she sets on the road to stardom using her 30 plus years in the music industry. They have to be in their early 20s so that they will listen to MC's guidance and expertise. (Monday 19 February 2024; 19:02) this is a reply to message 105,572

Writing (105,572) by Tevin from USA I really hope within the next couple of years Mariah starts writing and possibly produce songs for other people. Whether for pop stars or rnb singers, up and coming or established. What singers would you love Mariah to write and or produce songs for? (Monday 19 February 2024; 16:38)

And yes, Mariah's sound (105,577) by Robert-Anthony from United States This is a hot topic today. MC should not keep us waiting for new music this long ever again. (Monday 19 February 2024; 18:56) this is a reply to message 105,575

And yes, Mariah's sound (105,575) by Edward from USA While you may not be a fashion expert, you still hold opinions on fashion, just as others may have opinions on medical matters. As I mentioned, these are simply opinions. While I might disagree with your opinion, I would never discourage you from expressing it. One need not be an expert to recognize when Mariah doesn't look great in certain outfits, just as one need not be a doctor to sense when something is amiss health-wise with someone. Speculation is something we can all engage in, regardless of our expertise. (Monday 19 February 2024; 17:14)

Let's get it to number one (105,566) by Robert-Anthony from United States Thank you Edward for the clarification. It's been so long since MC had a ride in the Billboard 10. All of these new chart rules are so confusing. Will we know Tuesday or Wednesday? (Monday 19 February 2024; 11:46) this is a reply to message 105,561

Let's get it to number one (105,561) by Edward from USA Both versions of the song are considered as one for charting purposes, with only the most popular version being displayed on the charts. This was the case with the Big Energy Remix; while it certainly boosted the original track's visibility, it didn't surpass its popularity. Consequently, Mariah's version didn't appear on the charts. It's not that she wasn't credited, she was, but the version she was credited for wasn't the most popular one. (Monday 19 February 2024; 01:52)

Yes, And, I Don't (105,565) by Robert-Anthony from United States Great post Jamie. At this point, I hope she gives us MC16. I would accept MIAM vocals and be happy. Her vocal decline is too far gone now that I think surgery on her nodules would not help at this point. Can she give us Fantasy type of vocals? Probably not. Will she be able to give us TMB or #Beautiful type of vocals? I think she will be able to that. TCOM Vegas shows will let us know the type vocals we can expect. However, I feel the shows will be 70% lipped to a backing track. (Monday 19 February 2024; 11:43) this is a reply to message 105,563

Yes, And, I Don't (105,563) by Jamie from UK I think this track is what it is, I like the song. I liked it when it was just Ariana. Having Mariah on it now singing up beat is music to my ears. Is it Mariah's best performance no, but is it really her worst? I'd rather have this over I Don't any day. I think we need to cut her some slack, she's never gonna blow us away as she once did, she's 54 this year and unfortunately has declining vocals which I'm sure she herself is very well aware of. I was actually quite happy with her vocals on this track, let's be honest we've heard worse over the last few years. For a long time now we've been asking for Mariah to get herself together, she's finally started to clean up her act, her public presence and persona is back up to where it should be, her PR is back to where it should be and she's getting lots of attention and respect from fellow artists. Yet we continue to dissect everything she does and bash her when she finally does something positive. I would love Mariah to have her full 90's vocals back and to some degree her personality, but unfortunately it's not gonna happen. Vocal decline has happened for various reasons and she suffered a major breakdown which has changed her as it would. Not forgetting she's been living this famous life for a long time now and as much as stars say they haven't changed. They always do over time one way or another, hey non famous people change over time believe it or not. Nobody is the same or doing the same things as they once did 25 plus years ago. But instead of tearing her down let's give her praise for still being here, making music and gracing us with her presence for nearly 34 years, I'd much rather have her still with us than not. The track isn't that bad and who knows what's in-store for us this year on her solo projects. Let's celebrate Mariah. (Monday 19 February 2024; 03:14)

Let's get it to number one (105,549) by Robert-Anthony from United States I was looking at the current Top 40 Mediabase Chart for radio impressions and the original version is sitting at #13. Is there a chance that the remix and original version will just be counted together for next week's Billboard Hot 100. Or will it have to be calculated like this? (Sunday 18 February 2024; 21:09) this is a reply to message 105,547

Let's get it to number one (105,547) by jaker20 from US I heard the Yes, And remix the other day. It was their big "new music this week" with a drumroll announcement. Don't be surprised if it gains some traction on radio, especially on the club radio stations. But expecting it to go to number one is too much to ask. I feel like it was just Mariah returning a favor to Ariana for appearing on stage with her and JHud last Christmas, and nothing more. They seem to enjoy each other and that's great to see. I just hope Mariah is more consistent with her releases. There is some buzz right now. She should have a follow up in 3 to 4 weeks, the same way that she should have a follow up immediately after BER blew up, and the same way she should have a follow up every Christmas on January. (Sunday 18 February 2024; 18:42)

Yes, And? lyrics (105,540) by Robert-Anthony from United States MC is trying to be young again or be a part of what is hip in today's music industry. Although she has done this collaboration, I don't think MC16 will follow in this direction. I believe she has a plan to get back on the pop charts. We have to trust her on this collaboration. She will make us proud soon. I want to hear that Clark Sisters song so bad. (Sunday 18 February 2024; 14:07) this is a reply to message 105,539

Yes, And? lyrics (105,539) by Bill from the UK Self-love and empowerment are better found in lyrics like Hero, Through the Rain, My Saving Grace, Fly Like a Bird and so on. It's a shame the woman who wrote lyrics like those found on Outside, Butterfly, My All, Looking In and Petals now sings about riding a D. I'll go back to playing Selfish on repeat all day. (Sunday 18 February 2024; 13:06)

TCOM promotion (105,537) by Robert-Anthony from United States MC will be doing her TCOM talk show promotional rounds here really soon. I sure hope she does more daytime tv interviews than late night. I feel she is more relax on daytime tv than late night tv. I would love for her to join The Talk with Jerry O'Connell and talk about TCOM and the 25th anniversary of the Heartbreaker video. If she does late night tv, I hope she stops by Stephen Colbert's show. Colbert and MC had me laughing so hard the last time she stopped by his show. (Sunday 18 February 2024; 06:48)

Choreo (105,528) by Robert-Anthony from United States I have never seen her dance like this since the Butterfly and Rainbow eras. She can do it again with lots of practice. (Sunday 18 February 2024; 00:36) this is a reply to message 105,522

Choreo (105,522) by Mimi L. from Empower Your Highlighter All we need is Mariah on a video recreating this, confirmed #1. (Saturday 17 February 2024; 21:29)

Let's get it to number one (105,527) by Robert-Anthony from United States Radio seems to be passing on the remix. I have checked other major radio stations' "Recently Played" section today and the remix is not being played. They are still playing the original. These radio programmers know if the remix is played what it would mean for MC. I am afraid it is going to be difficult for MC to ever get back to her 90s heyday radio airplay ruled by today's radio dynamic four of Doja Cat (I can't stand her music), Jack Harlow, Sza, and Taylor Swift. (Sunday 18 February 2024; 00:32) this is a reply to message 105,519

Let's get it to number one (105,519) by Mimi L. from Empower Your Highlighter Yus US Lambs please push this song hard. Arianators are apparently going hard with promo calling the biggest radio stations to play the song. It was played on Z100 which is huge. The Arianators want it to hit #1 so Ariana can have the gift of going #1 side by side with her idol. There have been people who listened to it the first time and didn't like it only to later like it upon further listens, so if it's played on radio and all it'll reach masses. (Saturday 17 February 2024; 20:59)

Signed copies (105,526) by Robert-Anthony from United States Facebook is tearing JLo apart for how bad her album is. Taylor's Target exclusive is going to top Midnights. She has become too big to stop now. I have never been a fan. (Sunday 18 February 2024; 00:21) this is a reply to message 105,521

Signed copies (105,521) by Mimi L. from Empower Your Highlighter JLo is out at the Bronx singing CDs at target. Bless her heart her 300m followers weren’t enough, but lol MC and Ariana should totally start selling signed copies to maximize the sales. Side note Taylor Swift has been revealing new bonus tracks here and there and her fans are kinda tired at this point of her capitalizing of them. She sold atleast 3 different versions of Midnights, then all the rereleases and now the new album looks like will have different versions too. (Saturday 17 February 2024; 21:12)

New short clip (105,499) by Robert-Anthony from United States MC is just looking very beautiful and happy these days. I love it. (Friday 16 February 2024; 22:29) this is a reply to message 105,488

New short clip (105,488) by Mimi L. from Empower Your Highlighter MCXAR shared this little video to promote the single. They look super cute together. No one can tell me Mariah isn't genuinely affectionate towards Ariana after seeing this. Not to mention MC thanked Ari for having her on the remix. Such a gracious queen. (Friday 16 February 2024; 17:25)

MORE MESSAGES