Messageboard

About MusicfanJ from Germany: I'm a fan of Mariah since Daydream came out.

Article: Mariah Carey's rare demo tape hits auction (112,387) by MusicfanJ from Germany Yes, the good old poster days. My room was full of it. Lol. Kids today almost miss everything that was so much fun back then. I have every album (incl. best of, remix cd, greatest hits, the Rarities, anniversary edition of Music Box, Christmas editions) from Mariah on CD, every single since 98, some from "Music Box" era, the debut on vinyl and "Daydream" on cassette. Plus the released DVD's and VHS in Europe. And a lot of "rare" songs and mixes on self-burned CD's. As Bill said, digital will never beat psychical. Never. (Friday 14 November 2025; 13:20) this is a reply to message 112,386

Article: Mariah Carey's rare demo tape hits auction (112,386) by TJ from Norway I remember the 90s when posters was a big thing. Kids miss out on that these days. (Friday 14 November 2025; 06:26)

Article: Mariah Carey's rare demo tape hits auction (112,383) by MusicfanJ from Germany Yes to hear her original demo is on my list too. I have a physical collection with a sound system and I love it. I'm a typical collector and 90ies kid. I also have a portable cd-player (a new one) mostly for the home. I was happy that Amazon still sells them. The mp3 player is often played for sports or the household work. Lol. (Thursday 13 November 2025; 18:42) this is a reply to message 112,381

Article: Mariah Carey's rare demo tape hits auction (112,381) by TJ from Norway I just wonder if she will ever release that demo? That is something I really would love to add to my collection. It's on the shelf collecting dust, but it's mine. I could never get rid of that collection, but I don't play cds that much because the cd player is not in the living room, and I really need a new sound system at home. How about you guys? Do you still have a physical collection? Maybe you never had a collection at all? (Thursday 13 November 2025; 16:06)

Article: Mariah Carey's rare demo tape hits auction (112,380) by MusicfanJ from Germany Absolutely. Plus her look, it's almost too much, that someone can look like Mariah and has the voice, talent and her early charisma/aura. A combination which is very rare, unique. When I saw the pic of the demo tape, I though it's like the "holy grail" of pop music. It's music history. (Thursday 13 November 2025; 15:08) this is a reply to message 112,373

Article: Mariah Carey's rare demo tape hits auction (112,373) by jaker20 from US This is a real piece of history. It really shows how Mariah's break out is like no other. He said: "She writes like Madonna and sings like Whitney, I've discovered gold" is how he described her and he was mind-blown. This is why there will never be another Mariah. There will be a lot of great voices, and lot of great lyrics, but there will never be another one who mixed the two in a way she has. I love how the comments are saying "give it back to her". (Wednesday 12 November 2025; 18:28)

HFIA review (112,344) by MusicfanJ from Germany I think NII is very radio friendly and it has the most "single potential" with Sugar Sweet. Plus NII suits perfect for this season, the end of the year, thoughtful moments. (Tuesday 11 November 2025; 13:53) this is a reply to message 112,338

HFIA review (112,338) by Lambi from USA Hate to say it but they probably are. The roll out was heavily banked on, probably the best publicity of all her albums. (Butterfly and TEOM didn't even get her a VMA.) She toured the dang world and let everyone know about it. She quite literally couldn't do anything more. But still by PTS, the hype pretty much died out. Maybe if someone picks up NII for a movie, it might have a resurgence, I doubt it though. But to completely fair, there isn't one ground breaking single. I'm still not going to count Mariah out. She shocked me with With You and A No No, I just know melodies come to her way too naturally, and it only takes one song that'll break through the cracks to bring her back on top again. (Tuesday 11 November 2025; 02:49)

HFIA review (112,330) by MusicfanJ from Germany I'm also pleased if this is a farewell album because it's so good. Of course I hope we get another one. By the way when I read here about "passing", Mariah is not that old. People around their 70ies are here called "best-ager". Mariah's still in the middle, people get older and older. Except they are ill, have a heart-attack or have an accident. What I want to say is, I hope Mariah gets real old. Do you know Iris Apfel from New York? She was a fashion lady and got 102. I found her so funny, a great inspiration to live a dream as long as possible. Have a good week everyone. (Monday 10 November 2025; 12:58) this is a reply to message 112,327

HFIA review (112,327) by Xavier mariohmix from Spain By vocal acrobatics I meant the belting. On Caution it was more consistent and regular in the usual last section of the songs (if I remember well, it's been so long since I listened to that album). However, "Me. I am Mariah..." was the last time we had real huge belting (the one we have always been used to) like on "Supernatural" or "Meteorite". On the other hand, the whistle register is always there and used very wisely aesthetically, as usual. And you're so right to say that "her vocals remain steady and buttery throughout the album", and that's what makes it consistent. Vocally, I still love her voice just because she's capable of doing so many things with it and creating so much beauty sonically with plenty of nuances. For me that's outstanding. One thing I didn't mention in my review: the lyrics. She's a real master. She knows we pay real attention to that, and, apart from being something natural in her, she puts a lot of effort into it. "Play That Song" feels like a film when you listen to it and close your eyes in order to imagine the scenes. When somebody commented on this album being possibly her last one, I felt like I was going to cry, but it felt right because of what it is like. Still I hope it won't. (Monday 10 November 2025; 00:29)

Alzheimer's (112,324) by MusicfanJ from Germany Luckily "cancel culture" seems to go away or at least recognized for what it is. It's a dangerous "weapon" against free speech, opinions and thoughs. But back to Mariah I also think it's only because of her meds. Of course I don't know. But I wish she wouldn't take/need them. Even if you're a normal person you need a doctor you can trust. There are bad ones out there like in every other profession, but with all the money Mariah has, you guess there should be a real good one. But who knows. (Sunday 9 November 2025; 21:56) this is a reply to message 112,316

Alzheimer's (112,316) by Edward from USA I agree. The thing is that some people here get triggered by anything, you can practically feel the bitterness through the screen. Nobody is trying to diagnose Mariah; people are just free to speculate. That whole "cancel anything I don't like" mentality was used as a weapon for way too long. Thankfully, we're finally moving away from that and some common sense is returning. Alzheimer's never even crossed my mind when it comes to Mariah, if anything, it seems more like it could be related to her bipolar meds. (Saturday 8 November 2025; 20:47)

The arrogance (112,271) by MusicfanJ from Germany Two questions: Standing up for what is right, who decides what is "right"? "She is actively earning money with some of the most evil people currently on the world stage today." Which evil people? I don't understand who you mean. I've never heard about Sephora (I'm not interested in luxury brands). Lol. Google says it's a beauty brand. And it has a boycott because of politics and currents events. It's a boring trend nowadays to scream boycott. Of course you can boycott if you want. Maybe next year you'll like her it's time video better. What brand would you like? I like her video. I'm happy about every Christmas spot. It's my favourite time of year. We have the Coca Cola tv-commercial and trucks here, very popular and joined by many. The Christmas song from Melanie Thornton, "Wonderful Dream" is very popular in Germany which started with a commercial too. And I will have Mariah's two Christmas cd's on repeat. I even have the animated movie with little Mariah plus the "soundtrack". But I won't buy Mariah cookies. I bake cookies, it's affordable and yummy. Take a mulled wine or kinder punch and enjoy the season. (Thursday 6 November 2025; 11:31) this is a reply to message 112,268

The arrogance (112,268) by Geronimo from USA You seem to be attempting to miss the point in public on purpose. Standing up for what is right is non-negotiable - especially when the public is bringing your betrayal to your attention while you try to hustle religious songs at Christmas about love, joy, and peace. If she had any foresight at all, she might want to consider canceling her Christmas charade this year - especially since her latest album stands as a very public statement regarding the difference between what is happening on stage and what audiences will be hearing. Entertainment is all fine and good. But, when the time comes to step up, you either step up or be counted for what you are. If all Mariah sang about was "panties to the side", then perhaps addressing her as a moral being would be a moot point. Not everybody has to say everything, every time, about every issue, but Mariah Carey is making money endorsing a company whose CEO is using the money that Mariah Carey is making for Sephora to donate millions of dollars intended to directly support a racist, apartheid state currently committing a live-streamed genocide I believe Mariah Carey has used the public airways to the show pictures of Nelson Mandela in her deluxe apartment in the sky, no? Then, it's relevant to hold her accountable for the fact that all you have to do is Google "Sephora boycott" and the first three stories that pop up have to do with a Christian woman who sings songs about Jesus, but is dedicating her talent to the people who are destroying the lives of the people born where he lived and was literally executed by the state because he was committed to being an authentic enough version of himself that he became a threat to the goals of the Roman empire. Mariah Carey, who is not broke, chooses to use what she calls her God-given talent to enrich people "making large donations to former President Donald Trump's 2024 presidential campaign" while she sings "its tiiiiiime" to listen to her lip sync "glory to the newborn King" and "peace on earth". While she partners with Sephora, company owner Bernard Arnault invests hundreds of millions in Israeli companies while that nation is actively committing what everyone whose opinion counts has acknowledged is a genocide. She sings about diamonds and comments in public that she doesn't understand why some people don't "like" diamonds, all the while Sephora founder, chairman, and CEO Bernard Arnault - who invests hundreds of millions in Israeli companies, including Lusix, an Israeli diamond company - donates millions of dollars to companies from the country whose diamond exports fund over $1 billion of the Israeli Occupation Forces budget annually. LVMH's Sephora stores retail products from Ahava, one of the top 8 companies on the BDS boycott list for stealing Palestine's natural resources, eviscerating its environment, and operating in illegal settlements. So it matters that Mariah Carey is either too ignorant, too greedy, or both to make a morally intelligent decision at her age. With all the capacity she has to know better and do better, she is actively and willfully doing far less than people who have with far less but are, themselves, putting their lives and careers on the line in order to be the kind of witness to peace and love that Mariah only sings about in her songs - her notable charitable contributions notwithstanding. And let's not forget, in her personal life, Mariah Carey made the choice to date James Packer - a man who (allegedly) gave war Benjamin Netanyahu a key to his home - also the man whose gifts to Benjamin Netanyahu are the reason why Benjamin Netanyahu is currently up on corruption charges. These are her choices. She is not simply failing to burn her bra on stage and release a protest album. She is actively earning money with some of the most evil people currently on the world stage today. That matters - and saying so has nothing to do with "arrogance". If Eartha Kitt can do better, Mariah Carey can do better. If Aretha Franklin, Nina Simone, Billie Holiday, Sinead O'Connor, Lauryn Hill, and the artists formerly known as the Dixie Chicks can do better (and they certainly did), then Mariah Carey can at least Google herself and recognize that she is being exposed as a fraud (again) and do something about it now. And yes, I still love "Confetti and Champagne", because she's a phenomenal singer, a very clever songwriter, and the song is super cute. But it sounds a little different right about now. (Thursday 6 November 2025; 03:29)

3 albums (112,258) by MusicfanJ from Germany So true. "The songs had a charm and innocence to them, genuine melodies and interesting arrangements." I see it the same way. The early recordings with Ben Margulies are so soulful, pure and unique. A wonderful sound. I also love her darker, rich voice on the debut. (Tuesday 4 November 2025; 20:52) this is a reply to message 112,225

3 albums (112,225) by Bill from the UK There's a magic to the debut that was never recaptured (if I could recapture). Everyone always bleats on about working with Walter again, but I've always wanted her to collaborate with Ben Margulies again instead. Every Walter song had a similar style and structure. Same for the JD productions, and the C&C collabs. Every Carey/Margulies composition was unique and different to the one before it. The songs had a charm and innocence to them, genuine melodies and interesting arrangements. She's never had that with anyone since and it is, along with the exceptional voice, what makes the debut such a standout and my favourite. (Monday 3 November 2025; 17:53)

Christmas (112,257) by MusicfanJ from Germany Exactly. I still read newspapers and books by the way. But I also had to google what Sephora is. Lol. I've never heard of it too. And I missed the add thing as well. I just thought the it's time video is fun and looks good. I also didn't get what it has to do with Amazon? That the Christmas season is also used for commerce is nothing new too. (Tuesday 4 November 2025; 20:27) this is a reply to message 112,248

Christmas (112,248) by TJ from Norway One of the biggest problem in 2025, beside social media, self diagnosis and allergies, is that people don't read the news. Everyone is just a Google search away from all kind of information, but doesn't know how to sort out what's real or not. I didn't know about the Sephora boycott because we don't have that chain here, I even missed out on the add thing. We've said it before, and I say it again. I think Mariah have made some strange decisions over the years, singing for dictator and so on. I don't think it will prevent her from reaching the number one spot, but we never know. (Tuesday 4 November 2025; 06:40)

3 albums (112,221) by MusicfanJ from Germany I also love her debut so much. It was so hard to only choose three, so I had to pick others. But the debut also has a special place in my heart. (Monday 3 November 2025; 10:11) this is a reply to message 112,211

3 albums (112,211) by Terna from Nigeria Easy "Mariah Carey", "Butterfly" and "The Emancipation Of Mimi". These three album are the main anchors in her discography, each detailing very important eras in her journey - Her introduction, growth and freedom, then legend status when she finally gained the respect from the industry. A worthy mention is "Daydream" which is so very important in her journey too, I didn't pick it as it is actually the true beginning of her growth as an artist that culminates with "Butterfly" so these two albums are intertwined to me although very different and honestly her true core and identity as an artist. (Sunday 2 November 2025; 15:54)

It's time... (112,212) by MusicfanJ from Germany I'm still a bit "sad and angry" that the "One sweet day" record got broken. If it was at least an outstanding song, then maybe I could tolerate it. Lol. But with "Old Town Road"? There's nothing special about it to be that long on number one. (Sunday 2 November 2025; 18:40) this is a reply to message 112,210

It's time... (112,210) by Edward from USA Yes, 19 weeks is the all-time record, Lil Nas X's "Old Town Road" set it in 2019, and Shaboozey's "A Bar Song (Tipsy)" tied it in 2024. "AIWFCIY" is now at 18 weeks, just one week away from matching the record and two from breaking it. She's right on the verge of making making music history. More than her 19 #1 songs, I was always more obsessed with her keeping the "One Sweet Day" record forever. Every time somebody came close to breaking it, I was on edge, lol. So this one would feel freaking great. I'll stop talking about it though. (Sunday 2 November 2025; 12:58)

Michael Jackson collab (112,209) by MusicfanJ from Germany I grew up with "Dangerous", Micheal was the first superstar I had a poster in my room. But "Thriller" is on another level. Quincy Jones and Michael were the best duo. They made music history, no one will ever come close. Alone the hit singles Beat It, Thriller and Billie Jean make the album outstanding. Billie Jean is my all time favourite. I can't sit still when I hear the first seconds of the song. And yes the live version of it when he showed the moonwalk for the first time, I can only imagine how that changed everything. Funny side note, as a little kid I always wanted to watch the full "Thriller" video on MTV. I finally were allowed to watch it with my mum. I loved it, but of course I was so scared of the zombies and Michael at the end. Lol. The dance is more than iconic, and can go on and on with praising. Michael was simply the best when it comes to entertaining and singing. He and the King of Rock and Roll changed everything. (Sunday 2 November 2025; 12:01) this is a reply to message 112,199

Michael Jackson collab (112,199) by Bobby A from United States I remember growing up in 1983 and Thiller and MJ merchandise was in every retail store imaginable. People were just obsessed with the album. His performance of Billie Jean and the moonwalk dance on the Motown 25th Anniversary special just solidified Thiller's success that year. (Saturday 1 November 2025; 12:41)

It's time... (112,201) by MusicfanJ from Germany I love it. The cat behind the window and Miss Liberty, how cool. The elf boy and Mariah saying you can't cancel Christmas. What a great it's time video. Only Mariah has something like this. (Saturday 1 November 2025; 17:18) this is a reply to message 112,193

It's time... (112,193) by Lighty from China This year's It's Time video. It surely looks big budget. (Saturday 1 November 2025; 05:03)

Michael Jackson collab (112,200) by MusicfanJ from Germany For me almost every MJ-song is a classic. From his debut to "Bad" every song is classic and perfect. The Dangerous album has a lot of classics too. How I miss his music. "You're not alone" with Mariah would be a dream duet too. But there are so many possibilities. The King of Pop with the Queen. I hope the hidden song will be released one day. (Saturday 1 November 2025; 17:01) this is a reply to message 112,179

Michael Jackson collab (112,179) by Anonymous from USA I remember the 25th Anniversary of Thriller, I ran to Target the day it come out to buy it. I still have it but haven't played it in a while. It is such a good album. Thriller would've been my first pick too for a collaboration. I think MJ has quite a few songs that would be considered classic, not just one or two. (Friday 31 October 2025; 18:54)

Non-single deep cuts playlist (112,169) by MusicfanJ from Germany It's a great list for sure. Haha secret weapon, absolutely. I have to copy your playlist, it has a lot of my favourites on it. (Friday 31 October 2025; 13:25) this is a reply to message 112,157

Non-single deep cuts playlist (112,157) by Lambi from USA A playlist I use as a secret weapon for pulling people deeper into MC's discography. It's a thrill seeing them secretly shazam it. It's made up of non-single deep cuts from each of Mariah's album (excluding holiday): 1. Vanishing (MC) 2. So Blessed (Emotions) 3. Music Box (MB) 4. Underneath The Stars (Daydream) 5. Close My Eyes (Butterfly) 6. Bliss (Rainbow) 7. Reflections (Glitter) 8. The One (Charm) 9. Joy Ride (TEOM) 10. Love Story (E=MC2) 11. Inseparable (MOAIA) 12. Dedicated (MIAMTEC) 13. One Mo' Gen (Caution) 14. Nothing Is Impossible (HFIA) Curious what would yours look like? (Friday 31 October 2025; 09:39)

3 albums (112,168) by MusicfanJ from Germany It's really tough. I would pick: Music Box, Daydream and Butterfly. (Friday 31 October 2025; 13:21) this is a reply to message 112,166

3 albums (112,166) by Edward from USA This is a tough one. I would keep "Daydream", "Butterfly" and "The Emancipation of Mimi". (Friday 31 October 2025; 12:54)

Anthony fellow lamb (112,109) by MusicfanJ from Germany Happy birthday. Enjoy your day. Cheers. (Sunday 26 October 2025; 17:49) this is a reply to message 112,101

Anthony fellow lamb (112,101) by Bobby A from United States I am still here, Libra Lamb. I just wanted to change my profile name to celebrate my 20 years plus on the board. Time flies by so fast. I turned 53 years old yesterday. (Sunday 26 October 2025; 09:45)

Confetti and Champagne (112,093) by MusicfanJ from Germany Absolutely. All the long time fans/lambs did buy her new music. So it's not because of "us" that it sold weaker than "Caution". Casual listeners don't care at all for her nowadays, that's it. The teens have there own "stars", so what's left are her long time fans. I also like "HFIA" better than "Caution". Yeah, maybe a gospel or jazz album could generate more listeners because it's a special genre. (Saturday 25 October 2025; 16:40) this is a reply to message 112,088

Confetti and Champagne (112,088) by Edward from USA Saying the "lambs" never support or show love to her evee is unfair. The truth is, there just aren't that many of us left in the US anymore. We've always shown up for her. She sold what she sold because of that loyalty. Unfortunately, the casual listeners don't seem as interested these days, and they're the ones who really drive major album sales. Personally, I bought one copy, gifted another to my sister, and still stream it from time to time. (Saturday 25 October 2025; 05:39)

Falsetto (112,074) by MusicfanJ from Germany The song grows on me by each listen. It's such a beautiful song. The best on the album with "My Love" and "Nii". I love the piano, her voice on it and even the change to the "praise" part. Such a special song. It was good to name the album after this song, Mariah knew why. The album brings so much joy. (Friday 24 October 2025; 10:44) this is a reply to message 112,065

Falsetto (112,065) by Giovanni from USA That falsetto note Mariah is hitting at the end of "Here for it all" during the "you got to praise him" verse is amazing, because I don't think I have ever heard Mariah do a falsetto like that ever. Patti Labelle and Beyonce are the queens of falsetto notes in my opinion and that falsetto reminded me so much of Patti. Mariah should have done more especially in her prime. Monica is another who is known for them as well. "Here for it all" is the favorite song on the album by most of the people I know. I think it's her best ballad since "Portrait" but "Portrait" is still my favorite. (Friday 24 October 2025; 01:41)

New tour date alert: February 2026 (112,073) by MusicfanJ from Germany Yeah, that was my second thought. They have money and will pay a lot to get a "name" like Mariah's there. (Friday 24 October 2025; 10:32) this is a reply to message 112,062

New tour date alert: February 2026 (112,062) by TJ from Norway There's alot of countries I would avoid in the Middle East to hold a concert just because of human rights and such things, but there's money down there, and obviously money talks. (Thursday 23 October 2025; 19:41)

New tour date alert: February 2026 (112,072) by MusicfanJ from Germany You're right. I didn't think of that. Does anyone know if it will be a smaller venue or a bigger one? I'm still surprised that she's doing another concert in February. (Friday 24 October 2025; 10:27) this is a reply to message 112,060

New tour date alert: February 2026 (112,060) by Lara from Middle East UAE has mostly expats. (Thursday 23 October 2025; 19:13)

New tour date alert: February 2026 (112,058) by MusicfanJ from Germany "Middle east"? The Asia concerts made sense because of her huge fan base there. But middle east, I highly doubt there's a huge fan-base. Hmm, a bit strange indeed. (Thursday 23 October 2025; 18:13) this is a reply to message 112,055

New tour date alert: February 2026 (112,055) by T from USA Mariah already has a new concert booked in the middle east for early February next year. I don't understand, does she need the money that bad? Or is her so called team going to run her into the ground like Amy Winehouse? Either way, the lamb followers are going to make excuses and call it a "one off" or "just for the fans" but the truth is these enablers are going to end up killing her. (Thursday 23 October 2025; 15:43)

Which song would've you picked? (112,056) by MusicfanJ from Germany I always thought Mariah should write and sing a NYC themed song. Like the "Empire State of Mind". Just for fun, imagine a Sinatra cover from New York, New York. I remember a little clip from a restaurant in Italy where she sung some parts of this famous song in 2003 or 2004. (Thursday 23 October 2025; 17:01) this is a reply to message 112,038

Which song would've you picked? (112,038) by Lambi from USA Felt like the wrong choice but I guess Mariah really is "New York" as JD said. She is hip-hop. From this data, not counting the 3 singles just to even out the playing field (they were out longer and had better launchpads), lambs daily streamed In Your Feelings and Mi the most. Lighty said NII could've been this album's TTR and I agree, not sure if Mariah will go with a ballad as the launching single ever again but I still hope she does something special with it. Countries like Brazil and Philippines love ballads and this was a solid one. But out of the 3 singles, I felt Sugar Sweet was the strongest. It's the better melody. It would've been awkward launching an album with 2 other ladies so I see why she didn't pick that. It's actually quite a dilemma picking the first single, maybe I'll come back and change my answer. (Wednesday 22 October 2025; 22:21)

Hi Lambily (112,054) by MusicfanJ from Germany Please post more. I also love to read about meetings from fans/lambs with Mariah. I allready enjoyed your post. (Thursday 23 October 2025; 15:00) this is a reply to message 112,033

Hi Lambily (112,033) by Gabrielle Demetriou from UK I wanted to share something that's lived in my heart for years - the day I met Mariah Carey in Manchester on March 18, 2016. I was heavily pregnant at the time, and what unfolded that evening has stayed with me ever since. Mariah was radiant - regal and real - surrounded by warmth, laughter, and that unmistakable glow that only she has. When she turned to me and asked about me, it was one of those rare, human moments that you never forget. I wrote a reflection called "Here For It All" - a personal piece about that meeting, how her music has shaped my life across generations, and what it means to me as a mother to pass that love on to my daughters. Mariah's music has been the golden thread through my life - in joy, heartbreak, and everything in between. She's been my comfort and my courage, and writing this felt like a love letter to the woman whose songs have always been there. Please comment whether you'd like to see the unpublished story. (Wednesday 22 October 2025; 19:19)

Which song would've you picked? (112,051) by MusicfanJ from Germany I love "I Won't Allow It". One of my favourites from the album. Such a cool, fun song. When you think the song ends and then Mariah huh, and the song continues. So fresh. (Thursday 23 October 2025; 11:36) this is a reply to message 112,042

Which song would've you picked? (112,042) by Anonymous from USA I Won't Allow It probably has the most potential. It's fun. It's dance. It's silly. It's relatable. There's so many good songs but the lead single should be a fun uptempo. Just my two cents. (Wednesday 22 October 2025; 23:57)

MORE MESSAGES