Messageboard

Remix (55,836) by Cgee54 from Usa I suspect that Bieber's verse was actually meant for Mariah to sing because he came last and jumped in the song. Do I hate the song, no but do I like it, so so. Mariah's issue is that everyone expects her to do music the way she did and realistically I don't think that's possible because how the music scene has changed. Yet I suspect if she did go back to the old way of doing things she will still be bashed. (Saturday 8 August 2015; 22:23)

Why You Mad (55,835) by Jake from New Zealand Is a mess. French Montana's verse is trash. T.I.'s even worse. Justin's is ok. The only good things were the beat and the new Mariah vocals. The end was abrupt. I don't understand how the same person who gave us MIAM released this mess. I don't even understand the need to remix the original. Which is probably the worst song ever released by Mariah, after Don't Stop. Mariah needs to stop collaborating with rappers and start with singers. (Saturday 8 August 2015; 22:14)

Best live vocal moments of final show (55,834) by 123 from USA This YouTuber put together her best live vocal moments of the final show. I'm shocked that she actually sang the second verse of Honey live. She also went for a note in VOL that she avoided the whole show. Her voice sounded crystal clear. I hope she continues to improve and continue to sound this good. (Saturday 8 August 2015; 21:35)

Why You Mad remix (55,833) by Nick from USA I'm just going to appreciate it because this will probably be the last new "song" we get for a while. The remix is alright, I just wish she was in it more. I would talk more about it but there really isn't much to say regarding the track. (PS: I love the new layout of the site.) (Saturday 8 August 2015; 21:20)

And just when we thought (55,832) by Marcus from Brazil Well, "Triumphant" would be the equivalent of "Butterfly" compared to "Why You Mad Infinity Mess-mix". It is an epic mess. The "Triumphant" remixes were great, I burned the Vintage one at the gym, but this "Infinity" saga keeps getting infinitely worse. I remember when I first heard that snippet of "Heartbreaker", my heart stopped of excitement, but this remix? God have mercy. I don't think Mariah should try to replicate "Fantasy", but some people are not telling it like it is. We can be in "Lambily Land" saying it is acceptable, but this is a mess. (Saturday 8 August 2015; 21:16)

Why you mad? (55,831) by Ardis Logic from Earth I hate to say negative things about MC, so I will keep it short and sweet. I don't love it, but I don't hate it. Justin's part was ok, Frenchy and TI sucked. I liked the new vocals. It sounds like it had the potential to be really good, then they all got drunk and lost the vision. Love the new layout by the way. It's stellar. (Saturday 8 August 2015; 20:49)

Why You Mad? (55,830) by Dove from USA I like it. It sounds like something I would listen to on my way to work. I listened to the version posted on TMZ. (Saturday 8 August 2015; 20:08)

Why You Mad? (55,829) by LC from USA Why you mad? I guess that's a question that applies to more than one person. I actually really like the remix. I made the mistake of reading through fan comments on this board and other forums before actually listening, and from what was said, I was really expecting that it was the worst song Mariah has ever released. But, as usual, lambs overreacted and had meltdowns over nothing. I think it's a good song. I think it's current, has a nice flow and is a vast improvement over the original. The beat is very radio friendly, the chorus is memorable as ever, and the added verses/raps give the song an edge that the original was missing. Though I wish Mariah gave herself more parts, instead of being a hook singer on her own remix, I liked each section and danced along to the beat. It knocks. It's not the best remix she's ever done, by a stretch, but it's definitely not the worst. It has radio potential. And that's coming from a teen who is actually in touch with current music. Mariah gave us the 90s/Emancipation moment we all wanted last year with MIAM, but many treated it like trash. Let's let Mariah try something new. Again, why you mad? (Saturday 8 August 2015; 19:35)

Remix (55,828) by Nick from Maryland I feel like if she wanted to go the rent-a-rapper route there were some better choices, people that the younger people are really into right now like Fetty Wap etc. Bieber being on the track is a good thing because of his huge fan base. (Saturday 8 August 2015; 19:35)

A mess, but I'm not surprised (55,827) by Marissa from USA The song sounded junky. Period. Team too much. Mariah has been chasing a Fantasy ODB-level remix since 95 and she seems to be getting further and further away from it. Leave all of these "here today, gone tomorrow" artists alone and choose one (caps) artist who has the potential to be a legend to be on the track. (Saturday 8 August 2015; 19:11)

Remix (55,826) by Luke from United Kingdom I actually don't mind it, the beat seems a lot more catchier than the original. The only thing I don't like is that it's like Mariah takes a back seat. I wish she had put in the line "Is it lack of ice got you so cold?" Oh well, hopefully mixing with different people like Justin will open her up to a new audience which is what it looks like they may be doing. I like that she's exploring different things, even if some might not be that successful. That's what a real artist should do. I would rather her try a new sound on Infinity and it not work instead of trying it on a new song and it goes down the drain. She could easily churn out Vision Of Love / We Belong Together type songs that we're used to and love but that isn't going to get her anywhere. To evolve she has to take a risk and try different sounds and work with different people. The thing is, unless she collaborates first I doubt any singles of her alone she would chart in anyway because not enough people know her or have forgotten her. They need to expose her more and think that's what this might be all about. (Saturday 8 August 2015; 18:32)

Remix (55,825) by Stella Lewis from USA I just read the comments on TMZ and wow, everyone is bashing Mariah so hard. No one seemed to like it, calling it a hot mess etc. Honestly, I kinda agree with them. It was sub-par by Mariah standards. I would rather her not release a song at all, than release one that is terrible, because at least then she'll have her integrity in check. (Saturday 8 August 2015; 18:30)

On the bathroom floor (55,824) by Mimi L. from Empower Your Highlighter I see a lot of lambs around various boards disliking the song. One comment made me laugh out loud because of how the person described the ending. He/she said that the ending sounds like they all forgot their lines at a point and someone just pushed the stop button on the recording. I actually agree with the comment. It does sound like that. It was so abrupt. (Saturday 8 August 2015; 18:13)

Re: Bleh (55,808) (55,814) (55,823) by Mimi L. from Empower Your Highlighter Lol Licia I love how you are still in denial and hoping we are getting "punked". Trust me, I am hoping for the same. As for "Triumphant", I adore that song. One of my favorites. This song is a mess. (Saturday 8 August 2015; 17:53)

Infinity remix (55,822) by Darryle from USA The remix is okay. It's not terrible but it could be better. The beat is hot and Mariah's resung vocals sound really good. I just don't understand why Mariah insist of playing chorus girl own her own song. She should have taken out French Montana and T.I. and left her raps in. This remix had a lot of potential but it was spoiled by the uneccesary rappers. (Saturday 8 August 2015; 17:42)

TMZ (55,821) by Mimi L. from Empower Your Highlighter Lol so this is what TMZ said about the article. I mean on their Facebook "Click here for the premiere of 'Why You Mad' with Justin Bieber, Mariah Carey, French Montana & T.I. This song is gonna be huge." I am dead. Since when does TMZ "premiere" songs and I laughed hard at them pushing the song by declaring it will be huge. I will be happy for Mariah if the song does become a hit because she needs one right now. Plus like I said it's possible to do it via deals and a well planned promo plan. But the song remains below Mariah's standards. Maybe there is a reason they are so confident about it, let's wait and see. (Saturday 8 August 2015; 16:45)

Infinity remix (55,820) by Liz Archer from Sweden I am not a fan, it's same song again but with just more rapping. I don't like that it's not a new song. The only good addition to the song other than Mariah was - surprisingly - Justin's part. Especifically I guess I don't like the flow of the song. It's very messy with strange arrangements of sounds. No real flow in it. (Saturday 8 August 2015; 16:33)

Why You Mad (55,819) by darrian liu from taiwan Idk what to feel about this. I really like the re-sung parts because they actually show that her voice is gradually coming back to form. They're really good. T.I's part actually add something to it. Would've preferred if only MC and T.I. work on it together. But JB's part are like, downright bad. Flat lyrics and his nasal voice really sounded horrible with that autotune. French's parts were blech too. Again, they sound patchy in production, just like the original. I love some parts of Infinity and some parts of the remix. It's like if they're combined, it would make a super solid song. But what happened to those magical remixes like My All/Stay Awhile and I Still Believe (Pure Imagination)? But after hearing the re-sung parts, I wanted Mariah to do an appearance on TV and you know, strip down Infinity and sing it with just a piano or a guitar and improvise a lot. It would be pure magic if she does that (considering if she warms up her voice for an hour or two before it and rehearses), just like the SNL performance of Vanishing. (Saturday 8 August 2015; 16:09)

Remix (55,818) by Deedre aka MiTodoChop @HBF from Canada I adore Mariah but this remix not my bag. (Saturday 8 August 2015; 15:58)

Re: Justin (55,812) (55,817) by Mimi L. from Empower Your Highlighter Haha Lee darling, I love you too and while we'll have to agree to disagree about Justin, however, I agree with the rest of your post. Your shade was so heavy, you basically buried Eric Hudson haha and I am with you 100%. If this is what he has to offer for Mariah, then I am not interested in them working together in the future. J.D. remixes are gold. This song like you said is not memorable and why bother releasing a remix (for a 3 month old song) when it's not a killer track. I don't get the point. "Whyyy?" *said like MC* (Saturday 8 August 2015; 15:30)

Re: Bleh (55,808) (55,816) by Licia from USA Triumphant was better than this. I'm disappointed. The remix didn't bring me on to the Infinity train. She should have just left it alone. (Saturday 8 August 2015; 14:53)

Re: High school reunion (55,790) (55,792) (55,800) (55,815) by Licia from USA i totally agree with you Mike. We as fans know she's joking, but the general public does not. She has to work on winning them back and saying stuff like this does not help. I totally get where you came from. (Saturday 8 August 2015; 14:49)

Re: Bleh (55,808) (55,814) by Licia from USA Triumphant was better than this. I just can't. Hopefully this isn't the final version. Mariah is still punking us. (Saturday 8 August 2015; 14:46)

Why you mad? Infinity remix (55,813) by Billy from England, UK This remix is one hell of a mess. It's horrible. (Saturday 8 August 2015; 14:41)

Justin (55,812) by Lee TS from USA I love you Mimi but I disagree about Justin. His verse was so generic, the lyrics were weak and his singing was such a try hard. He tried it. But it's a no dahling. To my surprise I actually liked French's part, it brought something new to the song. I do agree about the mixed mashed up thing. Maybe she should've gave JD a page for a proper remix. The song is not horrible but not memorable. It proves one thing though, I hope she doesn't work with Eric Hudson again, maybe his parents will do. Catch the shade. (Saturday 8 August 2015; 14:15)

MORE MESSAGES