Messageboard

Time review of #1 To Infinity (53,611) by this_is_qhm from the Philippines This is probably one of the best reviews of any Mariah album I have read, not because it was favorable, but because it is impressively well balanced and complete, effectively summarizing Mariah's entire identity as an artist, her highs, her lows, her flaws, her artistic output, etc. It may as well be written by a fan, but it still manages to be straightforwardly honest without ever being offensive. Much respect to the writer for being able to achieve such delicate balance. (Thursday 21 May 2015; 9:43)

MC appreciation (53,610) by Jono from USA I just wanted to take time to appreciate how much MC has done for us in the past 25 years. If the most "controversial" thing Mariah can do nowadays is 1) wear skimpy outfits and 2) not sound like 1990, then we really have it good. Other singers/celebrities try so hard to stay in the limelight by generating unnecessary and tacky controversy, and in general setting a terrible example for young kids. Of course I think an artist is entitled to artistic freedom and expression, but you can tell when something is done with intent vs something done to create cheap press. We can count on MC to never randomly make out with someone, bare her ass to the world, or start twerking just because it's in. I would be embarrassed as a fan if she did those things. So here's to MC, who will always let her talent speak for itself. (Thursday 21 May 2015; 6:42)

Celine and Mariah (53,609) by Ardis Logic from Earth I think Celine is a sweet person. I love her voice, and like a few of her songs. Maybe her and M could get together for dinner or something. Or even have a little play date for the kids. She seems like a really loving positive person. I wonder what it would be like if they wrote a song together? That would get some attention for sure. (Thursday 21 May 2015; 2:14)

Shelly / Fantasy (53,608) by Bill from the UK Shelly, regarding your question about Fantasy, there were several remixes that differed slightly, all of which can be found across the two CD singles issued in the UK. The original #1's, The Remixes and The Collection all feature the "Bad Boy with ODB" version. #1 To Infinity features instead the "Bad Boy Fantasy" version which retains the chorus from the original. There was also the "Bad Boy Mix" which removed ODB's rap, "Puffy's Mix" which is nearly identical to the ODB remix but the only difference (that I can hear) is the removal of the echo from the "jump jump" line. Finally there was "Puffy's Club Mix" which removed the acapella intro. I love the Fantasy singles and the remixes. Those Bad Boy Mixes coupled with the divine Morales club versions was just brilliant. The "Sweet Dub Mix", 8 minutes of MC cooing and ad libbing, still remains one of my favourites to this day. (Thursday 21 May 2015; 0:19)

Bill thanks so much (53,607) by Deedre aka MiTodoChop @HBF from Canada For taking the time to write out the notes for the EU tracks. Meant a lot to be able to read them. (Wednesday 20 May 2015; 23:57)

Mariah (53,606) by B from USA Jimmy Kimmel was amazing. She sounded so confident. I loved her interactions with the fans and her singing The Roof. I also enjoyed her interview. I'm looking forward to her Kelly & Michael appearance this Friday. I think Michael loves himself some MC. I don't care what media outlets say about Mariah. She really has nothing left to prove at this point. (Wednesday 20 May 2015; 23:09)

Lee (53,605) by Dove from USA "If most of the major media outlets said that she did good enough, why should we care what some little radio show thinks?" Just to be clear: I don't agree with their assessment and MC is great enough for me. The reason I mentioned it was because I think this is what the GP thinks and if we want MC to sell, the public perception about her needs to change. Blogs and comment sections on the internet have said the same things. I posted what's being said in my neck of the woods in case MC's marketing team reads this site so that they can work on it if they feel the need. What the GP thinks about a brand is important when you're trying to sell something. Sometimes people agree with what others are saying because they're too tired mentally to think for themselves. Look at what happened with Michael Jackson. Negative public image translated to a decline in sales when he wasn't "cool" anymore. (Okay back to work. Last post of the day for real.) (Wednesday 20 May 2015; 22:04)

Shelly (53,604) by Bill from the UK Thank you so much Shelly. Here's the UK tracks: Without You: My mother used to sing Harry Nilsson's "Without You" to me when I was a baby. I think she even sang it when she was pregnant with me. Years later I heard the song when I was sitting in a restaurant and realised that it could be a worldwide hit all over again for a new generation of people who had not heard it yet. That's where the idea to remake "Without You" came from. Endless Love: I remember hearing "Endless Love" when I was a little girl, and I loved the duet between Diana Ross and Lionel Richie. It was an honour to sing with the great Luther Vandross. Against All Odds: "Against All Odds" was one of my favourite songs growing up. Phil Collins is a fantastic writer and an incredible artist. I was very happy to perform the song with Westlife. I remember recording in Capri, which was one of the first times I met Simon Cowell. He saw me producing in the studio and we worked very well together, all of us there in the beautiful studio in Capri where I recorded so many songs. I'm really proud of the fact that this song went to number one in England. (Wednesday 20 May 2015; 21:55)

Bill / TGIFY (53,601) by Dove from USA Thank God I Found You: I worked with Jimmy Jam and Terry Lewis who are incredible producers and I was honored to work with them. We collaborated in a way that was not one of your typical collaborations. The songs and the interludes from this album are some of my best work. This was a collaboration of my voice mixed with Joe, one of my favorite R&B singers ever and the boys from 98 degrees. I am very grateful for the success of this song. Thank you Bill, I would love to know what she wrote about the songs that weren't included in the US release. (Wednesday 20 May 2015; 21:13)

More Vegas (53,599) by NHYTG from nyc More Las Vegas performances announced for February 2016: 2, 5, 6, 10, 13, 14, 17, 20, 21. Tickets on sale next Friday. (Wednesday 20 May 2015; 20:03)

Re: Adam (53,598) by Warrior Butterfly from USA Hello, I don't have scans but I do visit discogs.com and a great Japaneses site to see what is out out there I give a it a week or two before things start popping up. I went digital a few years ago so I was upset to see this release did not have a digital booklet, not even a special iTunes edition. That would have been a neat interaction all the videos and liner notes. (Wednesday 20 May 2015; 20:01)

Shelly (53,597) by Bill from the UK Thank you for transcribing for us Europeans Shelly. Would you also be so kind as to let me know what she's written about Thank God I Found You, as that also got ousted from the EU version. If you'd like to know what was written about Without You, Endless Love and Against All Odds then let me know and I'll return the favour. Good to see you back. (Wednesday 20 May 2015; 19:19)

Jimmy Kimmel (53,596) by Abraham from USA Mariah did good with "VOL". I think she could give another spectacular performance like she did on BET. She just needs to keep vocal training and to always be confident. As far as LA Reid is concerned, don't really care for him. Never have, he seems like one of those selfish people who only cares about money. Mariah can most definitely have another hit song. I am really looking forward to the next album. Even though I hate "Infinity" I still believe Mariah can do better and deliver with great songs like on "MIAM". Which is still a great piece of work. (Wednesday 20 May 2015; 18:42)

With all due respect (53,595) by Terri from USA Contrary to some of the negative comments about MC's BBA performance, she still was good. I was concerned that she would lip sinc or not hit the high notes. I sat close to the TV timing her breathing, lipping, and sound. They were in sync. You could distinguish her actual voice. Are her vocal acrobats as sharp and on point like back in the day? No. But it's still the best out there. Patti LaBelle on DWTS and Chaka Kahn a while back, have both adjusted there changing voice abilities. It's evitable. But all three can still out-sing today's top poppers. I bet not one who would want to be on stage with either of the 3. When radio folks and journalists knock her singing and even her emotional and mental stability, I ignore them. Just as many media outlets also praised her performance. Did I bemoan her cancelling a show knowing the fall out and possible impact of attendance on her future shows? Yes. But that's MC. As her fans she can make us a bit nervous. However, she always comes back. Her accomplishments, even now, "#1 to Infinity" climbs the charts (in spite of LA Reid's predictions?), her business acumen, writing talents, and ever growing net worth, she can laugh all the way to the bank. About JLo, the media wants a firestorm. On American Idol she's often spoken highly of MC. On BBA: maybe she was thinking, "Damn, she's still got it" or "Will I be able to carry a Vegas show?" or "I wish I could just stand there and sing half as good." That's my take, dahlings. (Wednesday 20 May 2015; 18:39)

I am not worried (53,594) by Lee from USA If most of the major media outlets said that she did good enough, why should we care what some little radio show thinks? The moon never answers the dog when he howls at it. (Wednesday 20 May 2015; 18:32)

Tabloids arent hurting #1 to Infinity (53,593) by Travon..SweetSweetFantasy from USA Mariah is killing it on worldwide iTunes, considering the BBMA sales surges everyonce received and it's Wendsesday. From Kworb.net: #2 Hong Kong #2 Saudi Arabia #4 Indonesia #4 Philippines #4 Turkmenistan #4 Zimbabwe #5 Malaysia #6 Taiwan #7 Japan #7 Singapore #7 South Africa #8 Egypt #8 Nigeria #8 United Arab Emirates #9 Luxembourg #9 Vietnam #10 Qatar #12 United Kingdom #14 Trinidad and Tobago #15 Spain #16 Israel #16 Turkey #18 Cayman Islands #20 Nicaragua #21 Kazakhstan #23 Thailand #24 United States (Wednesday 20 May 2015; 18:01)

#1 (53,592) by Bino from Mariah is #1 at least in "lyric intelligence" in pop according to this site. "Pop actually holds its own pretty well with Mariah Carey scoring higher than anyone in the other three categories. Bravo Mariah, bravo." (Wednesday 20 May 2015; 17:10)

#1 to Infinity booklet scans (53,590) by ADAM from USA Can someone please advise where I can find scans or comments from Mariah about each one of the song's history? Many thanks (Wednesday 20 May 2015; 16:58)

More thoughts (sorry, last post today) (53,588) by Dove from USA I forgot to add that when the radio host made those comments I switched to a different channel and they were talking about MC too. They were a little bit kinder but still negative. It's a man and a woman. The man said, "It's so sad. What a gift she had." And the woman said, "I think she is a troubled woman and she has always been a troubled woman." She said more but I don't remember. Then they brought up the article that said Mariah was stuck in a cage of her own making. Then the man repeated that it was truly sad that she lost her voice because MC had one of the best voices of the past 30 years. Oh and they also mentioned from the article (NYT I think) that the reviewer said she would prepare to go for the high note and then not (in Vegas). The male radio host said, "That's what it sounds like is happening here (BMA sound bite)." (Wednesday 20 May 2015; 16:40)

Ethan (53,587) by Dove from USA The nameless one is TNO is Jennifer Lopez. I was too upset to say her name but I'm okay now. (Wednesday 20 May 2015; 16:09)

A story (53,586) by Dove from USA I think being kind to people and maintaining good relationships is so important. The day after the BMA's I was listening to my regular morning show on the radio and they were talking about the BMA's. It's two woman and two men. They played a clip of MC's performance and one of the men said, "She recovered in the end." But one of the women said, "No, she shouldn't do that anymore (the high note at the end)." When Infinity came out, they were talking about it and the same woman said, "I can't understand anything she's saying." And started talking about something that happened the night before. I can tell by the way the one female host talks about MC that she doesn't like her. I'm thinking either MC or someone in her camp was rude to her or she's believing the tabloid stories. They love JL though. JL has called in to the show and she's always super nice and open when asked questions. This reminds me of something that happened with two Drs I know. A woman filed a malpractice suit against Dr A. Dr A is brilliant, he is one of the smartest people I've ever encountered, but he doesn't have great people skills. He's autistic. It turns out it wasn't his fault and when the woman found out it was Dr B's fault, she dropped the suit. Dr B has amazing people skills, he looks people in the eye and makes them feel amazing. People will forgive a lot if they like you. MC should call the big radio stations to give 15 minute interviews. And be nice and open. Just answer the questions. (Wednesday 20 May 2015; 15:46)

Grammy (53,585) by OGmattyICE from US It just occurred to me Mariah should have a Grammy award named after her. When they come to the podium it should read: "And the Mariah Carey award for best pop/hip hop collaboration goes to..." I mean she really did spark that genre. (Wednesday 20 May 2015; 15:37)

Re: Someday and I Don't Wanna Cry (53,578) by MC1989 from Spain (53,584) by Dove from USA Someday: This was one of my favorite songs when I was writing it for my demo. I remember being a kid and listening to it over and over on the subway after studio sessions. I wish I could press rewind and delete some moments from the video and some of the overproduction on the debut album. That's why I included the version from MTV Unplugged on this album. I Don't Want to Cry: This song was my first collaboration with Narada Michael Walden. The label was very excited for me to work with him because of his collaborations with hugely successful vocalists. We wrote I Don't Want to Cry together and it was very important for me to keep my identity as a songwriter. I was very grateful to him for the work we did together. (Wednesday 20 May 2015; 15:18)

Infinity video (53,583) by Musti from UK I'm getting a little frustrated too with the video release. But perhaps this is a good tactic to give the song its best build-up before they hit the market with the video. All these public appearances have clearly helped push the sales of both the album and the song. The more exposure they get, the more likely that the video will be picked up by viewers when it is finally released. By the looks of it, it will be her best video since Obsessed. In my opinion it was the video (more than anything) that helped make Obsessed popular. I'm trying my best not to be critical of Epic's moves as I do believe they genuinely want to make Mariah popular again. As a few of you have already mentioned, even LA's remarks can be seen as downplaying Mariah's diva behaviour and making her likeable again. I have good hopes from this video. I can't wait to see how it all plays out. (Wednesday 20 May 2015; 15:10)

US vs European album track list (53,582) by HeatSeek from Yeah, I'm not liking the European track list either. I'd rather Sony had released the same track list as the US version. Oh well, guess we don't always get what we want. (Wednesday 20 May 2015; 14:22)

MORE MESSAGES