Messageboard

Re: AI producers (74,141) (74,142) by Mimi L. from Empower Your Highlighter To be fair, they also had had Ellen on the show as a judge before and she is in no way related the music industry. Mariah shouldn't have gone on the show, she was above it and also she isn't the type to criticize aspiring artists. But I guess she thought her role would be different. Oh well, whatever done is done, all parties should move on. This is ridiculous to be bringing this up now and stirring new drama because now everyone will be like "What did Mariah do?" (Tuesday 4 April 2017; 18:08)

AI producers (74,141) by Jono from USA How about the fact that you hired a hack to judge a singing competition. You have Mariah, the greatest pop vocalist to have ever existed on this planet, working with a clown who can't even hold a tune. This was beneath her, and you pulled a classic bait and switch trying to get Mariah on board. Stop it with this whole only female scapegoat. If that was really the case, Mariah would not have handpicked her to costar with her in a music video. The producers were desperate to revive sinking ratings and thoroughly enjoyed the controversy, drama, and ratings. AI became such an absolute joke when it started crowning mediocre winners with no viable commercial success. The hack had absolutely no right sitting on the panel judging a singing competition. (Tuesday 4 April 2017; 16:53)

Re: American Idol producers attack Mariah (74,139) (74,140) by RibbonB from USA I agree, they need to let it go. The show faded out and does not need to be revived. (Tuesday 4 April 2017; 15:18)

Re: American Idol producers attack Mariah (74,136) (74,139) by Mimi L. from Empower Your Highlighter True, all parties were at fault, AI should have been more clear about their panel selection decisions and also they can complain all they want about Mariah or Nicki but truth remains that they leaked the footage and they used it for promotions to get ratings. This isn't new, most reality shows feed off drama, so now for them to pretend that they are innocent and didn't use it to their advantage (or that they played no part in starting it) is a blatant lie. Second, Mariah's part. I've said this before, but the first dig at Nicki was thrown by Mariah on the first episode. I don't know if they had fights prior to that, but on the first episode, Mariah walks in an throws shade at Nicki's head piece. Mariah also could have used this AI opportunity to just simply teaming up with Nicki and making a statement that she doesn't feel threatened by anyone, you know, throw in a little woman empowerment moment. Lastly Nicki, now we know Nicki is this bratty loud mouth, and I think it was very inappropriate for her to talk about shooting Mariah or hitting Mariah, it's not cool. All in all they could have just resolved this by now, by just chatting up. But oh well, but ya AI needs to focus on putting a quality show up instead of trying to drag up a 4 year old feud. Lame move. I hope the reboot doesn't happen. (Tuesday 4 April 2017; 10:06)

Re: Source criticism (74,134) (74,138) by Mimi L. from Empower Your Highlighter It's a bad word when you use it as a bad word, same way if you call a heavy person a "cow" or a silly person a "donkey" or call someone a pig. This is assuming the word was a farm animal which someone we know is notorious for using. Context dahlin, context. (Tuesday 4 April 2017; 09:56)

Re: Something all great female artists have in common (74,133) (74,137) by this_is_qhm from the Philippines True. Ariana has some potential, and her latest album, as derivative as it is, still shows that. But it's one thing to stay silent and blow everyone away with the actual output, it's another to think you're the s***, hype your creativity up only to underwhelm in the end. And with Britney, I always feel protective of her because although she may not be the best singer, she still shares Madonna's great ear for what sounds cool, though to a lesser extent. To me, you can kick Rihanna off that list of greats. I love me some RiRi, I have most of her albums, but her impact and popularity has never even come close to the fever pitch that Britney had at her prime. (Tuesday 4 April 2017; 09:32)

Re: American Idol producers attack Mariah (74,131) (74,136) by Licia from USA I agree that AI should have been up front with Mariah about what they planned to do, but at the end of the day it really should not have mattered who the 4th judge was. I don't believe AI told her she'd be the only female judge. AI, Mariah, and Nicki are all at fault because they all could have handled it better. Everybody involved had their moments of acting like 3 year olds having tantrums. (Tuesday 4 April 2017; 03:09)

Re: American Idol producers attack Mariah (74,131) (74,135) by Lila from United States I think all of it is correct. No one's hands are clean. Hindsight being 20/20, everyone was dumb. AI should've never promised Mariah that she would be the only female judge on the panel. As a talent show, it would be a hard request to fill, anyway. Had that season not been such a nightmare, I could've seen Mariah returning for another season but what if something happened to another judge and they needed a replacement but could only get a woman who was willing to participate? There goes that little promise. They may have wanted her as a judge but they shouldn't have let that cloud reality. Mariah should've never asked to be the only female judge. Get your insecurities in check or stay home. Also, she should've just been a woman about it and step to Nicki, before things got out of hand, and told her that she didn't mean any disrespect, she was just trying to avoid any would be drama, it was nothing personal. I was really turned off by Nicki's actions at that time but, again, hindsight being 20/20, I can see where she was coming from. I highly doubt most women could say that they wouldn't have been taken aback, offended, or felt unwelcome if they found out a co-worker of theirs only wanted to be the only female on the team. Still, Nicki's a grown woman and she shouldn't have done the things she did either. Everyone was acting like children. (Tuesday 4 April 2017; 02:53)

Re: Source criticism (74,129) (74,134) by Mort from Spain It wasn't a homophobic word and not about the Nigel thing. It's overall about Mariah's "fans" bashing her for her life decisions. Btw it was a four letter word that apparently was a bad word. (Tuesday 4 April 2017; 02:27)

Something all great female artists have in common (74,133) by Edouard from France I believe Mariah, Mary J, Beyoncé, Janet, even Madonna, Rihanna and Britney Spears (whom I don't think is a great artist per say but I recognize her importance in the pop world and I like her as a person) all have something in common: they are opened to their vulnerability as much as they are strong, fearless and powerful. They are all humbled by their success and it took them years to fully own their status. Side note: I watched an interview about Ariana Grande today and I almost chocked when she bragged about her artistry and her songwriting like it was nothing. (Tuesday 4 April 2017; 01:14)

Article: Guess who's to blame for "American Idol" feud (74,132) by Robin Elkins from United States Bull hockey. (Tuesday 4 April 2017; 00:56)

Re: American Idol producers attack Mariah (74,125) (74,131) by Malcolm from Asia Part of me thinks that the whole mess was AI's fault because they allegedly deceived Mariah as the only female judge (they did it to JLo so why not?), but was it the responsibility of Mariah's team to assure things before she signs any contract? And if they really told Mariah (legally) that she's the only female judge and had Nicki as a last minute addition, does Mariah had the right to sue them or anything? But, part of me also thinks that if Mariah just dealt with it and can get along with anyone without drama, given the fact that she and Nicki had already collaborated in the past and for sure had "moments" together, it shouldn't have been a problem at all and that season could've been one of the great and funniest season AI had. (Tuesday 4 April 2017; 00:02)

Re: Source criticism (74,124) (74,130) by Mimi L. from Empower Your Highlighter Then I think we all know who it is haha. (Monday 3 April 2017; 22:02)

Re: Source criticism (74,126) (74,129) by Martyn from England, UK I didn't see the original post, but from what I gather it was casual homophobia directed at me because I'm not a deluded fan who turns a blind eye when Mariah is in the wrong. Go through my posts, I'm always positive about Mariah, but I also don't think it's right to criticise Nigel after everything Mariah has said about Idol since her time on the show. If it helps, she looked the best she has in years during that era. Positive enough for you? Oh Eric, I've just seen the posts lower down, feel free to not publish my previous post, I think I got my wires crossed. (Monday 3 April 2017; 21:28)

Idol producers (74,128) by Gee from U.S.A. (New York City) To be fair Mariah has made her unflattering comments about her days at Idols. But I really believe that the Idols producers have a motive here because just last week it was announced that they are planning to reboot the AI series and I really think that this is to drum up some sort of interest. Let face it I believe that the producers of Idol deceived Mariah to get her to become apart of the judging panel by telling her she would be apart of thre person panel and then went to Nicki to attract the younger audience and it backfired. So in all both parties are wrong. But I definitely feel all parties need to stop talking about season 12 of AI as it is done and over with. (Monday 3 April 2017; 19:41)

American Idol producers attack Mariah and Andrew (74,127) by Sheila from United States You crave my attention don't you? Your [sic] so sweet and kind, always looking for a fight. Girl bye. [The rest of the message was censored.] (Monday 3 April 2017; 19:17)

Re: Source criticism (74,120) (74,126) by Edouard from France I'm with you Hanna. Your earlier post made sense and I'm glad to see I'm not alone. Those who are positive on this board might not be as vocal as the naysayers because we basically have a life, a life MC has greatly influenced because she has taught us to be openminded and nonjudgmental. (Monday 3 April 2017; 18:52)

Re: American Idol producers attack Mariah (74,119) (74,125) by Licia from USA I heard about the reboot, but I just don't understand how bringing this up help. It's been years. Everybody involved from Mariah to the cleaning crew needs to stop talking about it and let it go. Lol. (Monday 3 April 2017; 17:57)

Re: Source criticism (74,121) (74,124) by Mimi L. from Empower Your Highlighter Just curious if the word started with a "G"? [Webmaster: Yes.] (Monday 3 April 2017; 17:51)

Re: Patricia Carey's "To Start Again" on YouTube (74,114) (74,123) by Musti from UK I was going to say the same thing. It's clear where Mariah got her sense of discipline from and it's easy to picture Pat leading the sing-along gatherings at home that Mariah has spoken of in the past. Maybe Mariah is much more "relaxed" now (to say the least) but she had a much more serious approach to her music in the early 90s. (Monday 3 April 2017; 17:28)

Re: Source criticism (74,121) (74,122) by Mort from Spain But that wasn't an insult to other fans of Mariah. I really glad you replayed [sic]. I'm also printscreening before posting and will do with this to. And that I'm happy to have done. Have a great day/night. (Monday 3 April 2017; 17:24)

Re: Source criticism (74,120) (74,121) by Webmaster Eric from the Netherlands If you insult other fans by calling them [censored], I will censor it. If someone uses a word that doesn't exist, I will write [...]. If someone writes a word wrong, I put [sic] behind it. If a message is complete nonsense or doesn't follow my rules, I will delete it. I don't look at the writer when I censor or delete a message. If you don't like my rules, too bad. (Monday 3 April 2017; 16:57)

Re: Source criticism (74,104) (74,120) by Mort from Spain This is a message mainly for you who run this site. Why did you censore the word [censored]? Since when has it been a cursing word? Why did you change the last sentence to [sic] in the middle? Just wondering. Many lambs that I've been in contact with tells me their messages been deleted or censored. And it has been both "Bryan and Mariah fans" and those who don't like Bryan. Curious if you have a legit reason or if the content doesn't fit you? (Monday 3 April 2017; 16:47)

Re: American Idol producers attack Mariah (74,115) (74,119) by Mimi L. from Empower Your Highlighter They're probably making these statements now because they are trying to reboot AI according to the rumors. They should just let it be. Just let it die, with no goodbyes, details don't matter. (Monday 3 April 2017; 16:05)

Re: American Idol producers attack Mariah (74,112) (74,118) by darrian liu from taiwan Maybe you should learn the art of letting go [...] man, this story is tired as hell. (Monday 3 April 2017; 14:18)

MORE MESSAGES