Messageboard

To LC from USA (51,783) by Otti from Belgium I love reading your last post. "Number ones to Infinity" is the "Charmbraclet" of this era. It's gonna clean the way for a huge comeback. I hope "Infinity" is gonna marks Mariah's 19th number one. I love how she is back on track with her communication. (Tuesday 14 April 2015; 2:22)

Such a corny, increative album cover (51,782) by jaker20 from US It is good MC is doing Vegas, because I don't see this album going anywhere saleswise or gaining any fans. MC has lost any or whatever creativity remained in her. She's stuck in this type of tired old album cover. With all her success, she's still unable to break out of her insecure shell. That is a terrible photoshop hack job if you ask me, the same hack job done on MIAMTEC and Memoirs. Come to think of it, her last truly creative effort ("effort" meaning project she actually spent some time thinking) was Emancipation. That is 10 years of fail. Now she's just whatever. Again, I'm glad she's doing Vegas because I see her officially entering the has-been category. I don't see her coming back into mainstream pop again. Therefore she should milk every ounce of whatever lamb remains and serve them with concepts from 20 years ago. (Tuesday 14 April 2015; 1:56)

Marketing theory (51,781) by Taylor from USA At first I was disappointed with just one new song, but this album is really geared towards everyone as a reminder of the incredible feat of obtaining 18 #1's. The one new song is a catalyst for the release that would be just an ordinary compilation album. Yes, the previous #1's album had more bonus tracks, but Mariah was at a cruising speed back then so there was no need to remind everyone of her greatness. This time around, I believe the team is trying to build momentum from the recent setbacks. One new song to catch and reel the people in is actually smart because we have all seen the haphazard releases of so many different songs that never caught on. Once the public is hooked again with Infinity, I believe new materials will start flying out. Infinity is like the Trojan horse. Mariah needs to penetrate the fortress the public has built against her before she can conquer all over again. (Tuesday 14 April 2015; 1:30)

Track list / Someday (51,780) by Skip from United States I get why there's only one new song on this CD. I imagine they figure most people who buy it will be doing so at her store inside Caesar's Palace after seeing her perform these very songs in concert. And upside is, if they're only including this one song, they will be putting their all behind it to give it promotion. There is no "second single" to fall back on. That said, my disappointment in this track listing is in the version of "Someday" included. The MTV Unplugged version never hit number one. It wasn't even a single. I'm guessing this version was included because Mariah, ever concerned about appearances, felt the original version's production was embarrassing to her, just as she included live versions of her early songs as music videos on the original #1's DVD. But I absolutely love the original version of "Someday". If nothing else, including the 7" Jackswing single version would have been both more true to what actually hit number one as well as creating a bit of enticement for the fans, as it hasn't been released on CD since 1991. Including the live MTV version just destroys the truth of this legacy chronology, and therein lies my disappointment. (Tuesday 14 April 2015; 1:19)

Andrew, others and art cover (51,779) by Fulvio from Belgium I'm sorry you guys but I must agree with Andrew. I really love Mariah's music and I do think she is still relevant. But she needs to keep it together. Come on, only one more song? We are not criticizing her talent at all, but why buy the compilation? The fans already have the tracks. As for the new generation, well let's be realistic. Mariah is just "too old" to be related to. The younger and talentless singers are all over radios. The same happens with other artists (Madonna, Celine). Having said that, I can't wait to hear Infinity. As for the photoshopped art cover, let's just say it is a brilliant idea. It creates buzz and people now know she is releasing new material. Mariah is a true businesswoman and she knows how marketing works. (Tuesday 14 April 2015; 0:55)

Chill (51,778) by peterpaul from Ireland I'd love a beer. (Tuesday 14 April 2015; 0:40)

I Wish You Well (51,777) by B from USA I'm was listening to E=MC2 and decided to acknowledge how brilliant this song is. I'm listening to it and thinking of you (you know who you are, as Mariah would say). I hope you use your so called superiority to find some semeblance of happiness. Bitterniss will consume your soul. (Tuesday 14 April 2015; 0:36)

#1 to Infinity (51,776) by LC from USA At first I was a little disappointed that Mariah only included one new song on the compilation because it seemed like she would release more. However, I decided to look at the positive side of this release. It seems like LA Reid and Epic are marketing Mariah as the legend that she is, while showing that she can still make relevant, successful new music. This album is not just for the fans, the way MIAM was, but for the public. It's a reintroduction and a reminder that despite her missteps and setbacks in recent years, which have dented her image to many, she is still, without a doubt, one of the most successful and influential artists the world has ever seen. This album, along with her residency, is a slap in the face to IDJ and her detractors. It serves as a reaffirmation that she is Mariah Carey and that she deserves to be respected. Don't you think it's very gutsy to include "Infinity" in an album filled only with her 18 number 1 hits? Epic obviously has a plan for her and this single. It all depends on how well they execute it and how much Mariah wants to succeed. And as seen with the success of Reveal Mariah, which was a worldwide trend for 8 hours, I think Mariah's new team is pretty on top of things. Much more than IDJ. If "Infinity" is a huge hit, it will be the perfect way to come back. I really don't care if that sounds "insane" or too optimistic. I'd rather surround myself with happiness than with the shroud of negativity some of you seem to have. Be blessed. (Tuesday 14 April 2015; 0:19)

Andrew (51,775) by Bill from the UK You just can't stand to see her fans happy can you? You wanted to put a downer on the launch of a new era, and you succeeded. Congrats and thanks for once again spoiling the good mood of the board. I still cannot fathom why you waste your time coming here when you are not a fan of Mariah Carey. You criticise her look, her voice, her manner, her lifestyle choices, and now her music. (Tuesday 14 April 2015; 0:13)

Pow (51,774) by Abraham from USA Another spot on post by Travon. These posts are giving me life. Keep them coming. (Tuesday 14 April 2015; 0:12)

The general public (51,773) by Deedre aka MiTodoChop @HBF from Canada There will be a lot of people going to the Vegas shows who don't consider themselves to be "lambs" and do not own a copy of the original #1's album from 1998. I love going to live shows. Not that I go to them a ton, but on the handful of occasions where I have, I like to grab a keepsake from the show. That to me is what #1's To Infinity is catering to. I plan on buying a copy of the album. I do consider myself a "lamb". While it is true I already own all the songs. they are not available together on one compilation. For example, I have DFAU, but it is on the CD single ect and I have a similar scenario with TGIFY. It's nice to have them on one album as a collection without having to pop in the Rainbow album. I really don't think Mariah puts out projects to be disrespectful to audiences/fans. Yes, some who already own everything might consider this album a waste of money - that's cool. Everyone has a choice in terms of what they want to do. I honestly think this is more a memento for the Vegas shows. (Tuesday 14 April 2015; 0:06)

Bye Bye (51,772) by Billy from England, UK I love how flawless she looks in this video and also wish this would have been a #1. What a amazing song. (Monday 13 April 2015; 23:59)

New album cover (51,771) by Billy from England, UK I don't know why a lot of people are moaning about that photo of Mariah, yeah she looks slim on it and she maybe be a bit bigger in real life now but she ain't going to stay that size, she will get back to her weight size she loves to be, like in the Bye Bye video or something. People seen she was getting back to her slimmer size when she released #Beautiful and she sure will look like that album cover soon enough, I know it. (Monday 13 April 2015; 23:54)

Criticar por criticar (51,770) by MC1989 from Spain It's ridiculous to spend time every day of your life coming to a forum to critizise an artist. Grow up. If you don't like Mariah just stop following her and her record company's moves. Remember the Mariah you liked, because that legacy will always be there on your CD collection and in your childhood/teenage memories. But you're not that child anymore. And Mariah is not the same because we all change. Being disrespectful and overjudging a singer that you don't even know (if she drinks too much) won't help to bring back the Mariah you once fell in love with. We all can express those things we don't like from her, I don't consider myself a "lamb" but a fan who's been admiring and listening to her for many years, and I can tell many things I do not agree with and that I didn't like in these last years, but since you're critizising even her music, and saying she doesn't give a shit, why continue following her? She has just released an album last year. By the way, for all of you who feel so disappointed, I understand, but don't be so negative about the album success, do you know how many artists have done the same re-releasing strategy to promote a single? From Michael Jackson to many others, and in many cases it did work. (Monday 13 April 2015; 23:47)

Will she ever be good enough? (51,769) by Luke from United Kingdom I honestly think some fans need to let go of her. If nothing she is doing is ever good enough then just forget and move on. It honestly isn't healthy getting so wound up over such minute things with something you cannot control. Or atleast learn not to take everything so seriously. She isn't going to spend ample amounts of time on an album made to support a residency. I actually think what she has done with this album is more than what I expected. It's simple, to the point and sleek. She isn't perfect, nobody is, but let us appreciate that she has come this far and stayed so strong without anyone's opinions affecting her. Whether they're her "fans" opinions or the constant critics. A lot of people on this board discard anyone who is positive and names them "enablers". Carry on, but just remember you happen to be a follower of an extremely postive woman who would not have got so far in life if she wasn't so. (Monday 13 April 2015; 23:46)

Andrew / Shelly (51,768) by Travon..SweetSweetFantasy from USA Andrew, it's not your place to make issue with Shelly and what she buys. It's her money. She is well respected on this board and is very respectful to you. Don't be an a** because clearly what you said to her as being "revered minded" can also be said about you and your choice for how you present yourself on this board. Everytime you speak, I skip because of the ignorance of your delivery. Shelly is respected. You oviouslly are not, given most people here can't stand your comments. Please learn that being optimistic enough to support an artist is not being "revered minded". It's common sense to buy something you like. There is no limit to supporting someone or their music. Shelly, to me, is radiant and confident in who she is. Respect is what she gives and that same respect is something you clearly lack. [...] Shelly don't respond to ignorance and impatient people. Like Mariah says, "do you and everything will be alright". (Monday 13 April 2015; 23:41)

#1 To Infinity (51,767) by Lee TS from USA I'm sorry but she did say from #1 To Infinity and that's exactly what we're getting haha. I don't love the cover but I don't hate it either. I'm just going to be excited for the new single, new video with Brett, and the Vegas extravaganza rollout. This is just a taste of it, I don't think M signed with Epic for just one compilation album. More to come after this era. (Monday 13 April 2015; 23:36)

Rene (51,766) by Abraham from USA Your post was spot on.Thank you. (Monday 13 April 2015; 23:21)

New number one's album (51,765) by Abraham from USA I understand many being upset or disappointed that there is only one new track. I am too but I'm still excited that the new song might be her next 19th number one. This album is promotion for Vegas. After she'll release a whole brand new one. Imagine "Infinity" going to number one. Then her first or second single from her new album also going to number one. Wishful thinking but it could happen. What could be better than Mariah breaking The Beatles' record. Let's just support her and hope she does well with her Vegas shows. (Monday 13 April 2015; 23:16)

To the complainers (51,764) by Marissa from USA Can we take a moment to be grateful that we are no longer in the trainwreck era that was MIAM? This time last era we were dealing with album pushbacks, no album artwork, Mariah nowhere to be found, scatterbrained interviews, etc. Things may not be perfect but they are moving in the positive, cohesive direction now which is what many of us were begging for. At least acknowledge that progress has been made. (Monday 13 April 2015; 23:14)

Last cent (51,763) by Musti from UK To add to what I said earlier, as Mariah's releases since Memoirs have shown us, the music buying public isn't likely to buy a Mariah album of entirely new material. On the other hand, if Infinity really is a smash, a hit of that caliber would of course carry the compilation onto the charts, especially with a little help from her older #1's. I don't think much production cost has gone into preparing and releasing an album which was already released 17 years ago. To me the album seems more like a vehicle for the single and of course her residency. There can be no flop here. I just hope the single is amazing. (Monday 13 April 2015; 23:07)

Shelly (51,762) by peterpaul from Ireland I was joking, it's all good. (Monday 13 April 2015; 23:05)

Reality (51,760) by Rene from US Sanity and reason ebb away here. Even if Mariah included 6 extra songs on the #1 to Infinity, I assure certain people would complain. I could just hear "I don't like the beat on this song, she sounded hoarse, that's a stupid concept". The "ironic" part is questioning someone's sanity, when some fans here have been complaining for years of how Mariah is messing up. How long until these people realize Mariah will only "change" when she wants to "change". Mariah is being Mariah. If you cannot handle it, stop questioning her sanity, and start questioning yours instead. (Monday 13 April 2015; 23:03)

The music / "Infinity" and beyond (51,759) by Edward from USA I don't care much about whether the cover is photoshopped or not, I do care about the music. The original #1's offered not only the 15 songs that had gone to the top spot back then, but also a few new/reworked tracks to entice people to buy it. In an era where most people are not buying physical CD's/singles anymore, I doubt people will hurry to download songs they already have. I'm only buying lossless digital songs, flac to be exact, so I don't think I'll be buying songs I already own for the sake of supporting Mariah just for one new song. I'll definitely be buying "Infinity". Only if she releases a deluxe version with at least three new tracks, I'll be buying the whole thing. People should remember this is not a new album, but a compilation. Just buy "Infinity" if that's what you like. And stop setting ridiculous expectations, that's how people get disappointed. I think there will be deluxe version, so let's wait and see. (Monday 13 April 2015; 22:42)

I'm not dissappointed (51,758) by Deedre aka MiTodoChop @HBF from Canada I can sort of understand people wanting more new tracks on the album, but she literally just signed with Sony. It would be a different story if she had been with them for months, but she hasn't. I think it's a good sign she had one track to include, honestly. She's putting a show together, switched labels, overhauling her representation. Let's at least give it some time for the dust to settle, before writing the whole thing off as a big flop. This album is clearly to promote the Vegas show. It's not your traditional "album era". I'm already observing a huge difference in quality from her team, professionalism on her website in terms of updates and promotion. I get that people have concerns, but these things do take time, effort and people to get done. I'd rather have 1 quality song with a polished promotional effort than 5 rushed tracks, sloppy remixes and zero effort for promotion. (Monday 13 April 2015; 22:30)

MORE MESSAGES