Messageboard | The Mariah Carey Archives

Only registrated members can post messages. Registration is free.

Unpopular opinions (109,664) by Mirage_Nunez from America

Though I absolutely love some of the songs on Butterfly (Butterfly, My All, The Roof, Breakdown, Fly Away) and agree that it's probably the most important album in her catalog, as a body of work I connected with Charmbracelet, TEOM, and MOAIA way more on a personal level. Particularly Charmbracelet and MOAIA felt like the most vulnerable excerpts of her diary.

(Thursday 10 July 2025; 07:19)


this is a reply to message		109,657

Unpopular opinions (109,663) by Randy from USA

I think Bye Bye was a worthy second single and Migrate isn't an undeniable hit. I think the Candy sample is better than Firecracker for Loverboy. I think #Beautiful is really boring. MIAMTEC is MC's worst album by far. Did I Do That is a great song. Through The Rain is better than Hero. Right To Dream is the best lyric Mariah has ever written. GTFO is the best song on Caution. The Wind is boring. Memoirs is the closest album to a follow up to Butterfly. Whitney held back on When You Believe because she knew MC in her 1998 voice couldn't keep up. Mariah is at fault for the Nicki Minaj beef. JLo had no idea about Firecracker and didn't deserve MC's smoke. Mariah and Eminem went on a few dates and messed around once. Mariah was embarrassed by her performance at Divas 98 and that's why she keeps hinting at Celine over singing in Aretha's presence. I think Type Dangerous is boring. I think Oh Santa is a great song because of its insane amount of energy. Mariah has potential as an actress. The performance of You and I for Stevie Wonder is boring. Mariah has had vocal problems since she left Tommy and maybe that sequestering her in the castle kept her very sensitive voice protected. At the present rate Mariah will sound like Dionne Warwick sounds now in her late 60s.
(Thursday 10 July 2025; 03:50)


this is a reply to message		109,657

Unpopular opinions (109,662) by Haiji from United States

I appreciate your take on that song, Edward. I get what you're saying. I was around 12-13 years old when that song was released and I was always a huge fan but that song just didn't hit. I didn't understand the song at the time. Now as an adult, I get it but I still don't feel the words coming from that song particularly.
(Thursday 10 July 2025; 02:15)


this is a reply to message		109,658

Unpopular opinions (109,661) by Stacey from USA

When Fantasy was released, I was not a fan. So shocking, I know. I bought the album because I absolutely adored OSD. These days I hardly listen to OSD while Fantasy is on repeat, lol. Isn't it ironic, don't you think? Same thing happened with Merry Christmas. I wasn't too keen on MC's gospel flavored album. I didn't buy MC until years later. Now I love getting up and dancing to Joy to the World.

(Thursday 10 July 2025; 00:25)


this is a reply to message		109,657

Unpopular opinions (109,660) by Tevin from USA

Did I Do That is a good song, and other than Crybaby and Heartbreaker, it shows off Mariah's Rainbow era tone the best.

The remake of One More Try is one of the worst song remakes that I've ever heard.

I'd take a healthy Emancipation era voice or almost any prime era voice, minus 94-96 years. The richness, maturity and tone of Mariah's voice was incredible. Too bad it was too inconsistent and sort lived.

Last one, I'm glad Mariah's voice changed every two or so years, for good and for the bad. It made me appreciate her voice and artistry more, and it makes her more relatable, since we all have good days and bad days in life and with our skills and talents. We all are just trying to "do the best with what we got".

(Wednesday 9 July 2025; 22:52)


this is a reply to message		109,657

Unpopular opinions (109,659) by Zachariah from Croatia

1. I don't pay any attention anymore to albums before the Butterfly album and find them boring as hell.
2. Touch My Body has an annoying beat and I skip the song as soon as it comes on in my car.
3. Sometimes, I forget that album Me. I Am Mariah... The Elusive Chanteuse exists.
4. Merry Christmas II You is much better than Merry Christmas and after Butterfly, her best album ever.
(Wednesday 9 July 2025; 21:31)


this is a reply to message		109,657

Unpopular opinions (109,658) by Edward from USA

I think "Hero" is not only about a specific element, but a combination of things, one of them being the moment in which it was released. More than the lyrics, which are as cheesy as Regina's cheese fries, it's Mariah's then persona, relevance and delivery that give it that extra punch. The song wouldn't work if it were released today with what's left of her voice and the detached from reality diva persona she's assumed since 2009. To judge and understand Hero, you really have to put it in the context of when it came out. For most, if you weren't part of that time, you probably won't get it. I was a mere 2-year toddler, but I still remember that iconic statuesque princess-like figure singing it passionately and effortlessly at the Proctor's Theatre and the guy from the audience reaching multiple eargasms. It was simply epic
(Wednesday 9 July 2025; 19:42)


this is a reply to message		109,657

Unpopular opinions (109,657) by Haiji from United States

Regarding only songs or albums, what are some unpopular opinions you all got? "Hero" still hasn't grown on me yet. "Thank God I Found You" was not #1 worthy and based on how many song I listen to from each album, Caution is my least favorite.
(Wednesday 9 July 2025; 16:34)

Album titles (109,656) by Edward from USA

Mariah keeps trying to make "Oh Santa" happen, it's not going to happen. It's like she threw everything on it hoping something would stick.
(Wednesday 9 July 2025; 15:39)


this is a reply to message		109,655

Album titles (109,655) by Jamie from UK

Hahaha I'm lol at Oh Santa

that song is just far too busy.
(Wednesday 9 July 2025; 03:18)


this is a reply to message		109,649

Album title (109,654) by Zachariah from Croatia

16th Anniversary.
(Tuesday 8 July 2025; 23:38)


this is a reply to message		109,652

Album titles (109,653) by Lambi from USA

Reprimanded: The Art Of Hibernation
The Constipation Of Mimi
Gutter
Merry Crisis 2 U
Regretbow
Dayscream
Me. I Am A Chipmunk
(Tuesday 8 July 2025; 13:04)


this is a reply to message		109,649

Album title (109,652) by Lara from Middle East

Eternally 16
(Tuesday 8 July 2025; 09:20)

Fantasy vs. Honey (109,651) by Lambi from USA

I agree that Fantasy vs. Dreamlover is the more formidable competition. Fantasy would probably win though, simply because it had a greater impact, she essentially mainstreamed pop and hip-hop. Arguably, this is Mariah's greatest contribution to music outside of Christmas since all the pop girlies followed the blueprint shortly after.

A good comparison would also be Dreamlover and Heartbreaker, "dreamlover, come rescue me" parallels "heartbreaker, you got the best of me". They're melodically similar.
(Tuesday 8 July 2025; 05:13)


this is a reply to message		109,640

I Stay In Love (109,650) by Lambi from USA

I Stay In Love would honestly have been huge with better instrumentation. That repetitive, dizzying, synthesized sound ruined it. The reason why the masses ate up WBT is because of its simplicity. Just vocals, piano and perfectly crafted snares and bass.
(Tuesday 8 July 2025; 04:55)


this is a reply to message		109,644

Album titles (109,649) by Bill from the UK

Reprimand: Warranted

Memoirs of an Imperfect Elusive Charmbracelet-wearing Emancipated Chanteuse Squared

Merry Christmas T(h)ree (the third and final attempt to make Oh Santa happen)

You Can't Spell Mariah without A and I - The Return of the Genetically Engineered Voice

Glitter 2: Sylk's Revenge
(Monday 7 July 2025; 21:55)

I Stay In Love (109,648) by Shezz from Pk

Still one of my favorites from E=MC2.

(Monday 7 July 2025; 20:15)


this is a reply to message		109,644

I Stay In Love (109,647) by Zachariah from Croatia

Wasn't. It was supposed to be wasn't.

(Monday 7 July 2025; 12:06)


this is a reply to message		109,646

I Stay In Love (109,646) by Lighty from China

I thought that video was indeed directed by Nick.
(Monday 7 July 2025; 10:54)


this is a reply to message		109,645

I Stay In Love (109,645) by Zachariah from Croatia

That song would be such a bigger hit if only the video was made by Nick. The song is epic. Exactly that, classic Mariah.
(Monday 7 July 2025; 08:18)


this is a reply to message		109,644

I Stay In Love (109,644) by Mimi L. from Empower Your Highlighter

Ok so I was scrolling TikTok and I randomly happened up a snippet of ISIL and I don't know why that song was so hated, it's actually pretty nice and very classic Mariah. I know it was put in the trash can as a WBT dupe but I think it's a decent song with a great beat. Anyways just my two cents, justice for ISIL.
(Monday 7 July 2025; 00:00)

Album title (109,643) by John from USA

Baby Steps: The Re-Ambulation of the Skinny Legend
(Sunday 6 July 2025; 19:17)

Morocco improvisation 2012 (109,642) by Billy from Greece

This lives rent-free in my mind for years. I love everything about it, the tone, the musicality, the melody, the spontaneity, the vibe.
(Sunday 6 July 2025; 18:52)

MC16 Album title (109,641) by TJ from Norway

Lambs and Goats.
(Sunday 6 July 2025; 10:17)


this is a reply to message		109,639

Fantasy vs. Honey (109,640) by Rashidi Rahim Rick from Malaysia

The real competition would be Dreamlover vs Fantasy. Both song top the Hot 100 chart for 8 weeks. Both song are equals in terms of success. Honey real contender is Heartbreaker. Though both songs top the chart too but just for a couple of weeks. Too bad Loverboy cannot sit on the table with them. Maybe if they released Loverboy Firecracker version instead.
(Sunday 6 July 2025; 02:32)


this is a reply to message		109,635

MORE MESSAGES