Messageboard

Only registrated members can post messages. Registration is free.
LOG IN REGISTER

Mariah vs Brenda (104,344) by jaker20 from US
I'm responding to your post about you saying "the music industry does not have much control over anything anymore" which is incorrect. And everything you explained contradicted yourself.

(Saturday 2 December 2023; 21:51)
this is a reply to message 104,341
Mariah vs Brenda (104,343) by Edward from USA
I think Mariah reaches the top next week for such a small margine. Airplay, streaming and sales are all going to blow up from next week forward, it's a tight race, but Mariah is still ahead.
(Saturday 2 December 2023; 21:25)
this is a reply to message 104,339
Emotions formula (104,342) by Bobby A from United States
MC was going for a more polished than over-produced second album. I think that she accomplished that. Tommy probably was not too happy with the end result and album sales. I am sure he told MC after MTV Unplugged that she needs a huge pop album for her third album. Hence, Music Box was created and fulfilled Tommy's desires. Her creativity just got better and better after MB. She better bring it with MC16.
(Saturday 2 December 2023; 21:20)
this is a reply to message 104,340
Mariah vs Brenda (104,341) by Edward from USA
Being triggered is one thing, but basically sabotaging an artist so they won't be number one is a different monster. Brenda's team's making sure she is promoting, she has a new video, she's giving interviews, she's on Tik Tok, she has an EP with different versions of the song. They are just making sure the song has the best chance at hitting the top spot, it's business. Just like Mariah has been doing it for years.
(Saturday 2 December 2023; 20:51)
this is a reply to message 104,337
Emotions formula (104,340) by Jamie from UK
[If it's over] weak. I think not.
(Saturday 2 December 2023; 20:49)
this is a reply to message 104,335
Mariah vs Brenda (104,339) by Bobby A from United States
I understand now. Oh well, it's going to be a victory or a sad day Tuesday.
(Saturday 2 December 2023; 20:47)
this is a reply to message 104,333
Emotions formula (104,338) by Jamie from UK
Emotions is one of her best albums. Full of soul and maturity. I'd chose this album over the debut any day.
(Saturday 2 December 2023; 20:44)
this is a reply to message 104,316
Mariah vs Brenda (104,337) by jaker20 from US
Everyone's jealous. That's all it is. Yes, Mariah's resurgent success has triggered a lot of people, even fans of more current pop girls. Labels, music media, execs, artists, industry people. They are seething. That's how you know that she’s doing something right.

Mariah [has] the best career. Having dominated an era. And then after her peak, comes a classic that will outlast everyone. No one has that combo, not Elvis, not The Beatles, not anyone. That's triggered a lot of people, the media, labels, execs, artists, industry people. Because that pushes her career above and beyond.

I think with her 18th no.1 15 years ago, she got a bit scared about actually beating [The Beatles]. Everyone's coming after her. I think she was unsure if she wanted it. But after AIWFCIY, she actually realized it's very achievable, and if she does the world won't implode. And if she doesn't, someone else will. I think Taylor will attempt it.

But I don't think Mimi cares about her critics anymore. She seems like she's just enjoying all of the icings on the cake.

As for Darlene, I was hoping that they would collab for Christmas BPCH. I was so sure it would be a classic.
(Saturday 2 December 2023; 20:17)
this is a reply to message 104,329
Mariah vs Brenda (104,336) by jaker20 from US
Um Spotify has its own version of digital payola, with reduced royalties for some kind algorithmic boost via playlists. And Brenda's team have been very aggressive this year, having multiple versions included in playlists and having it strangest playlists like pop and teen playlists. These are Spotify curated playlists.
(Saturday 2 December 2023; 20:15)
this is a reply to message 104,333
Emotions formula (104,335) by Terna from Nigeria
Let's count the fillers on "Emotions" shall we?
1. "And you don't Remember" - I rarely play this song, it just isn't strong enough and is indeed one of her weaker ballads with a high note thrown in just because.
2. "So Blessed" - I personally love this song, but I also recognize it ain't no classic and quite forgettable. Even Mariah herself was like "oh please which so blessed" when the lambs made her pick an absolute favorite in a versus format a few years back.
3. "You're So Cold" - Oh my, what a waste of space a better song would've occupied and it was 5 whole minutes long, hideous. Skipped every single time.
4. "If it's Over" - Another weak ballad with a high note thrown in. This song actually is sort of disjointed, as its feel doesn't match the lyrics. It is a breakup song that sounds Gospel. With the gospel sound, one expects to hear an uplifting lyric or inspiring one, but this is dark. She got it right with "I am free" and "Anytime you need a friend".
This record was also kinda what turned the general public off her high notes because the placements came across as "just because", and with such a display on the title track, the rest should've had it toned way down in the background like on "Can't Let Go". The saving grace for this album are her vocals which are top notch capturing just how powerful her instrument is.
(Saturday 2 December 2023; 20:06)
this is a reply to message 104,317
Emotions formula (104,334) by Terna from Nigeria
"E=MC2 is definitely a better record than The Emancipation of Mimi." I didn't bother reading the rest. Sit down Andrew.
(Saturday 2 December 2023; 19:25)
this is a reply to message 104,323
Mariah vs Brenda (104,333) by Edward from USA
Robert-Anthony, the music industry doesn't have much control over anything anymore. The music industry as we knew it, it's forever gone. They can't influence streaming platforms to block users from playing the music they like, radio just goes along with what's trending or they stay out of the game. Fans have more control, instead of calling like crazy to request, we just go and stream, everything is way different. As I have stated, these two songs have legs of their own, the one that makes it to number one will be based on its own merit and promotional push on big events. AIWFCIY is a pure number 1, people keep buying it after all these years, they keep playing it and streaming it, no gimmicks. If Mariah really wanted, she could break The Beatles' record, just three great collabs with Drake, Ariana and Taylor Swift should take her there. I don't really care for that record though, the way things are, Taylor will eventually top them both.
(Saturday 2 December 2023; 17:48)
this is a reply to message 104,329
Emotions formula (104,332) by MusicfanJ from Germany
So true. My my mother has the "original" debut vinyl from 90, she bought it right after hearing the phenomenal "Vision of love". I didn't know she had her debut. But when I became a fan with Daydream, she told me she loved "Vision of love". She also loves Sade, I have my musical taste from her.
(Saturday 2 December 2023; 15:17)
this is a reply to message 104,322
Mariah vs Brenda (104,331) by BFF from United States
Brits sent the song "Sausage Rolls for Everyone" to #1 at Christmas time, so y'all don't have a leg to stand on in this regard.

I'm not worried about Brenda Lee. I like the song, but Mariah's song is superior. They're different styles of song by different types of singers, so there's really no comparison here.
(Saturday 2 December 2023; 15:11)
this is a reply to message 104,324
Emotions formula (104,330) by BFF from United States
I agree. "Emotions" is far and away a better album than the debut. The debut album is over-produced and lacks the personality and Mariah-ness that MC brought to subsequent albums.

Early on, Mariah correctly lamented that the record label watered down her sound for the album. I like the four singles and "Vanishing" from the album, but that's about it. I don't think I've ever listened to it all the way through.

The label really should have tried harder to support the "Emotions" album. It felt like they purposely held back on promotional push in order to "reign Mariah in" from taking more creative control and going in a more R&B/soul-based direction.
(Saturday 2 December 2023; 15:00)
this is a reply to message 104,314
Mariah vs Brenda (104,329) by Bobby A from United States
The music business isn't a sweet easy going industry. Every artist will tell you that including sweet Dolly Parton. Record executives aren't playing nice when they are promoting a song to get it to number #1. There are some underhanded strategies being done behind the scenes to make it happen at the UMG executive offices. If RATCT goes to number #1, a huge television media frenzy will be made about it that week. Just my two cents from Texas.
(Saturday 2 December 2023; 14:05)
this is a reply to message 104,327
Mariah vs Brenda (104,328) by Edward from USA
I agree it's not a conspiracy. The wig post was a simple joke, chill. Now if she had shown a Christmas decorated nipple, that wouldn't be marketing.
(Saturday 2 December 2023; 13:51)
this is a reply to message 104,327
Mariah vs Brenda (104,327) by The Real Deal from USA
What in the actual [censored]? It's not a conspiracy. It's called marketing a song that's already popular and trying to get it to #1. The same way Mariah markets AIWFCIY every year is no different then Brenda Lee putting out a music video for her song. Um, didn't MC make 4 videos for AIWFCIY? And whoever wrote the message "now that they slapped a blonde wig on Brenda" - are you serious? Stop trying to make a conspiracy out of everything when there is none.
(Saturday 2 December 2023; 13:40)
this is a reply to message 104,318
Mariah vs Brenda (104,326) by Bobby A from United States
It's the tad sprinkle of the wall of sound and rockabilly country influences combined that made it a popular Christmas song.
(Saturday 2 December 2023; 13:33)
this is a reply to message 104,325
Mariah vs Brenda (104,325) by Edward from USA
I have no idea when or why it happened. There are many other great Christmas songs way better than it. The first time I listened to it was last year because she made it to the second spot. For me it is just a very basic song, that's all. I don't hate it, just don't care for it.
(Saturday 2 December 2023; 12:54)
this is a reply to message 104,324
Mariah vs Brenda (104,324) by Andrew from the UK
Rockin Around The Christmas Tree is bloody awful. Why it is so popular in the United States is beyond comprehension. But, then, we are talking about a country that sprays cheese out of a can. I'll add it to the list of American Unforgivables.
(Saturday 2 December 2023; 11:33)
this is a reply to message 104,315
Emotions formula (104,323) by Andrew from the UK
"The numbers never lie"? Do you mean sales equate quality? That's a dangerous path to walk when talking Mariah Carey albums. Is every album that sold more than Butterfly better than it? Many will agree, but a great many will disagree. I will say this, an as example: E=MC2 is definitely a better record than The Emancipation of Mimi, despite selling far less.

What, then, if you had to select three post-1997 ballads to be sung to Mariah in tribute at an awards show would you and others select? They need to be well-known and within the capability of the artists selected to sing them.
(Saturday 2 December 2023; 11:29)
this is a reply to message 104,316
Emotions formula (104,322) by Stacey from USA
I think MC could have recorded the phone book for her debut album and been successful. Her voice was so amazing and so unheard of at the time. She truly is a once in a generation artist.
(Saturday 2 December 2023; 06:56)
this is a reply to message 104,316
Mariah vs Brenda (104,321) by Andrew from the UK
So who is the victim of who now?
(Saturday 2 December 2023; 02:34)
this is a reply to message 104,318
Mariah vs Brenda (104,320) by Edward from USA
Brenda's label just wants to capitalize on the success of the song, Mariah has been doing it since it 2017. While Mariah angered some of these ladies, I don't think there's a conspiracy to block her from reaching the top. Promotion makes a difference but these two songs have legs of their own. I think Brenda will snatch at least one week this Christmas season. She was reading comments from fans, and they were very sweet to her. There was a lamb who stated they would love for her to be number one. Brenda is a sweet lady.
(Saturday 2 December 2023; 01:23)
this is a reply to message 104,318

MORE MESSAGES

Only registrated members can post messages. Registration is free.
LOG IN REGISTER



If you want to leave a message, there are a few rules you must follow:
1. This is a Mariah Carey messageboard, so the message must be related to Mariah Carey.
2. Only messages in English will be posted. And please try to write understandable English, with the proper use of dots and capitals.
3. Messages with all capitals will be ignored.
4. Messages that are insulting (to Mariah, other artists or members of this messageboard) will not be posted.
The webmaster has the right to refuse any message he doesn't like.
© MCArchives 1998-2025 (27 years!)
NEWS
MESSAGEBOARD